# US 8,280,649 B2 · Board or electronic component warp analyzing method, board or electronic component warp analyzing system and board or electronic component warp analyzing program

> Agents: this data is available as JSON from the patentgrep API and MCP server — see https://patentgrep.com/llms.txt

- Number: US 8,280,649 B2
- Document ID: US8280649B2
- Status: Granted
- Kind: B2
- Application number: 12/306,491
- Filed: 2007-06-25
- Published: 2009-11-05
- Granted: 2012-10-02
- Earliest claimed: 2006-06-27
- Assignees: NEC Corporation
- Inventors: Ichiro Hirata
- Web page: https://patentgrep.com/patent/US8280649B2

## CPC

- G06F 30/20: Design optimisation, verification or simulation (optimisation, verification or simulation of circuit designs G06F30/30)
- G06F 30/39: Circuit design at the physical level (physical level design for reconfigurable circuits G06F30/347)
- H05K 3/00: Apparatus or processes for manufacturing printed circuits
- G06F 2113/18: Chip packaging
- G06F 2119/08: Thermal analysis or thermal optimisation
- H05K 3/0005: {for designing circuits by computer}
- H05K 2201/09136: Means for correcting warpage
- G06F: ELECTRIC DIGITAL DATA PROCESSING (computer systems based on specific computational models G06N)
- H05K: PRINTED CIRCUITS; CASINGS OR CONSTRUCTIONAL DETAILS OF ELECTRIC APPARATUS; MANUFACTURE OF ASSEMBLAGES OF ELECTRICAL COMPONENTS

## Abstract

Board warp analysis includes dividing a temperature profile with respect to an electronic component by a predetermined time. A relaxation elastic modulus of the electronic component corresponding to the divisional time is obtained by shifting on a time base of a master curve related to the electronic component A curing degree of the electronic component is calculated based on a relationship between a time after shift and an actually applied temperature. A warp of the electronic component is analyzed based on a relaxation elastic modulus on the master curve or a relaxation elastic modulus calculated based on a relationship between the curing degree and the elastic constant according to a value of the curing degree calculated.

## Claims

### Claim 1

A board warp analysis method of analyzing a warp of a board, comprising the following steps executed by a data processing device,
in board warp calculation based on model data including at least a configuration and an elastic constant of said board and an electronic component mounted on said board:
dividing, by the data processing device, a temperature profile indicative of a relationship between a temperature and a time with respect to said electronic component by a predetermined time,
obtaining, by the data processing device, a relaxation elastic modulus of said electronic component corresponding to the divisional time by shifting on a time base of a master curve related to said electronic component which is composed with respect to a reference temperature based on a temperature-time conversion rule,
calculating, by the data processing device, a curing degree of said electronic component based on a relationship between a time after shift and an actually applied temperature, and
analyzing, by the data processing device, a warp of said electronic component based on a relaxation elastic modulus on said master curve corresponding to said curing degree or a relaxation elastic modulus calculated based on a relationship between said curing degree and said elastic constant according to a value of said curing degree calculated, wherein
when said curing degree calculated indicates curing-end, a warp and a stress of said electronic component are analyzed based on a relaxation elastic modulus on said master curve corresponding to said curing degree, and
when said curing degree indicates yet-to-be-cured, a warp and a stress of said electronic component are analyzed based on a relaxation elastic modulus calculated based on the relationship between said curing degree and said elastic constant,
wherein said analysis executed on a basis of a unit of division obtained by dividing said temperature profile by a predetermined time includes:
a time division step of dividing said temperature profile by a predetermined time,
an initialization step of initializing a parameter indicative of a division number of said division unit,
a division number change step of changing a parameter indicative of said division number in ascending order or descending order, and
a determination step of determining whether said division number changed exceeds the total number of divisions, and wherein
when the division number exceeds the total number of divisions, operation is ended and when not exceeding, a relaxation elastic modulus corresponding to said division unit is calculated.

### Claim 2 (depends on 1)

The board warp analysis method according to claim 1, wherein the master curve related to said electronic component is a curve indicative of a relationship between a relaxation elastic modulus and time with respect to a resin coating said electronic component.

### Claim 3 (depends on 1)

The board warp analysis method according to claim 1, wherein the curing degree related to said electronic component is a curing degree as of a relevant time point after said shift with respect to the resin coating said electronic component.

### Claim 4 (depends on 1)

The board warp analysis method according to claim 1, wherein the analysis processing is repeated as many times as the number of time divisions of said temperature profile.

### Claim 5 (depends on 1)

The board warp analysis method according to claim 1, wherein at said time division step, as a method of segmenting a time base of said temperature profile, equipartition or segmentation of a part whose temperature change is sharp is executed.

### Claim 6 (depends on 1)

The board warp analysis method according to claim 1, wherein at said initialization step, the value of zero is applied to said parameter indicative of said division number for initializing said parameter.

### Claim 7 (depends on 1)

The board warp analysis method according to claim 1, wherein said division number change step is processing of incrementing said division number, in which the division number is incremented by 1 or not less than 1.

### Claim 8 (depends on 1)

The board warp analysis method according to claim 1, wherein in the calculation of a relaxation elastic modulus corresponding to said division unit, at a time and a temperature of said temperature profile at said division number changed, a relaxation elastic modulus is calculated at said division number obtained after shifting on a time base of said master curve according to a shift factor.

### Claim 9

An electronic component warp analysis method of analyzing a warp of an electronic component, comprising the following steps executed by a data processing device, in electronic component warp calculation based on model data including at least a configuration and an elastic constant of said electronic component:
dividing, by the data processing device, a temperature profile indicative of a relationship between a temperature and a time with respect to said electronic component by a predetermined time,
obtaining, by the data processing device, a relaxation elastic modulus of said electronic component corresponding to the divisional time by shifting on a time base of a master curve related to said electronic component which is composed with respect to a reference temperature based on a temperature-time conversion rule,
calculating, by the data processing device, a curing degree of said electronic component based on a relationship between a time after shift and an actually applied temperature, and
analyzing, by the data processing device, a warp of said electronic component based on a relaxation elastic modulus on said master curve corresponding to said curing degree or a relaxation elastic modulus calculated based on a relationship between said curing degree and said elastic constant according to a value of said curing degree calculated, wherein
when said curing degree calculated indicates curing-end, a warp and a stress of said electronic component are analyzed based on a relaxation elastic modulus on said master curve corresponding to said curing degree, and
when said curing degree indicates yet-to-be-cured, a warp and a stress of said electronic component are analyzed based on a relaxation elastic modulus calculated based on the relationship between said curing degree and said elastic constant,
wherein said analysis executed on a basis of a unit of division obtained by dividing said temperature profile by a predetermined time includes:
a time division step of dividing said temperature profile by a predetermined time,
an initialization step of initializing a parameter indicative of a division number of said division unit,
a division number change step of changing a parameter indicative of said division number in ascending order or descending order, and
a determination step of determining whether said division number changed exceeds the total number of divisions, and wherein
when the division number exceeds the total number of divisions, operation is ended and when not exceeding, a relaxation elastic modulus corresponding to said division unit is calculated.

### Claim 10 (depends on 9)

The electronic component warp analysis method according to claim 9, wherein the master curve related to said electronic component is a curve indicative of a relationship between a relaxation elastic modulus and time with respect to a resin coating said electronic component.

### Claim 11 (depends on 9)

The electronic component warp analysis method according to claim 9, wherein the curing degree related to said electronic component is a curing degree as of a relevant time point after said shift with respect to the resin coating said electronic component.

### Claim 12 (depends on 9)

The electronic component warp analysis method according to claim 9, wherein the analysis processing is repeated as many times as the number of time divisions of said temperature profile.

### Claim 13 (depends on 9)

The board warp analysis method according to claim 9, wherein at said time division step, as a method of segmenting a time base of said temperature profile, equipartition or segmentation of a part whose temperature change is sharp is executed.

### Claim 14 (depends on 9)

The board warp analysis method according to claim 9, wherein at said initialization step, the value of zero is applied to said parameter indicative of said division number for initializing said parameter.

### Claim 15 (depends on 9)

The board warp analysis method according to claim 9, wherein said division number change step is processing of incrementing said division number, in which the division number is incremented by 1 or not less than 1.

### Claim 16 (depends on 9)

The board warp analysis method according to claim 9, wherein in the calculation of a relaxation elastic modulus corresponding to said division unit, at a time and a temperature of said temperature profile at said division number changed, a relaxation elastic modulus is calculated at said division number obtained after shifting on a time base of said master curve according to a shift factor.

### Claim 17

A board warp analysis system of analyzing a warp of a board, comprising,
in board warp calculation based on model data including at least a configuration and an elastic constant of said board and an electronic component mounted on said board, comprising:
division unit for dividing a temperature profile indicative of a relationship between a temperature and a time with respect to said electronic component by a predetermined time,
obtaining unit for obtaining a relaxation elastic modulus of said electronic component corresponding to the divisional time by shifting on a time base of a master curve related to said electronic component which is composed with respect to a reference temperature based on a temperature-time conversion rule,
curing degree calculation unit for calculating a curing degree of said electronic component based on a relationship between a time after shift and an actually applied temperature, and
analysis unit for analyzing a warp and a stress of said electronic component based on a relaxation elastic modulus on said master curve corresponding to said curing degree or a relaxation elastic modulus calculated based on a relationship between said curing degree and said elastic constant according to a value of said curing degree calculated,
wherein said analysis unit
when said curing degree calculated indicates curing-end, analyzes a warp and a stress of said electronic component based on a relaxation elastic modulus on said master curve corresponding to said curing degree, and
when said curing degree indicates yet-to-be-cured, analyzes a warp and a stress of said electronic component based on a relaxation elastic modulus calculated based on the relationship between said curing degree and said elastic constant,
further including:
initialization unit for initializing a parameter indicative of a division number of said division unit,
division number changing unit for changing a parameter indicative of said division number in ascending order or descending order, and
determination unit for determining whether said division number changed exceeds the total number of divisions, wherein
when the division number exceeds the total number of divisions, operation is ended and when failing to exceed, said obtaining unit obtains a relaxation elastic modulus of said electronic component corresponding to the division time,
said curing degree calculation unit calculates a curing degree,
said analysis unit analyzes a warp and a stress of said electronic component based on a relaxation elastic modulus corresponding to said division unit according to a value of said curing degree calculated, and
said processing is executed on a basis of a unit of division obtained by dividing said temperature profile by a predetermined time.

### Claim 18 (depends on 17)

The board warp analysis system according to claim 17, wherein the master curve related to said electronic component is a curve indicative of a relationship between a relaxation elastic modulus and time with respect to a resin coating said electronic component.

### Claim 19 (depends on 17)

The board warp analysis system according to claim 17, wherein the curing degree related to said electronic component is a curing degree as of a relevant time point after said shift with respect to the resin coating said electronic component.

### Claim 20 (depends on 17)

The board warp analysis system according to claim 17, wherein said obtaining unit, said curing degree calculation unit and said analysis unit repeat the processing as many times as the number of time divisions of said temperature profile.

### Claim 21 (depends on 17)

The board warp analysis system according to claim 17, wherein said division unit executes, as a method of segmenting a time base of said temperature profile, equipartition or segmentation of a part whose temperature change is sharp is executed.

### Claim 22 (depends on 17)

The board warp analysis system according to claim 17, wherein said initialization unit applies the value of zero to said parameter indicative of said division number for initializing said parameter.

### Claim 23 (depends on 17)

The board warp analysis system according to claim 17, wherein said division number changing unit increments said division number by 1 or not less than 1.

### Claim 24 (depends on 17)

The board warp analysis system according to claim 17, wherein in the calculation of a relaxation elastic modulus corresponding to said division unit by said obtaining unit, at a time and a temperature of said temperature profile at said division number changed, a relaxation elastic modulus is calculated at said division number obtained after shifting on a time base of said master curve according to a shift factor.

### Claim 25

An electronic component warp analysis system for analyzing a warp of an electronic component, comprising,
in electronic warp calculation based on model data including at least a configuration and an elastic constant of said electronic component:
division unit for dividing a temperature profile indicative of a relationship between a temperature and a time with respect to said electronic component by a predetermined time,
obtaining unit for obtaining a relaxation elastic modulus of said electronic component corresponding to the divisional time by shifting on a time base of a master curve related to said electronic component which is composed with respect to a reference temperature based on a temperature-time conversion rule,
curing degree calculation unit for calculating a curing degree of said electronic component based on a relationship between a time after shift and an actually applied temperature, and
an analysis unit for analyzing a warp and a stress of said electronic component based on a relaxation elastic modulus on said master curve corresponding to said curing degree or a relaxation elastic modulus calculated based on a relationship between said curing degree and said elastic constant according to a value of said curing degree calculated,
wherein said analysis unit
when said curing degree calculated indicates curing-end, analyzes a warp and a stress of said electronic component based on a relaxation elastic modulus on said master curve corresponding to said curing degree, and
when said curing degree indicates yet-to-be-cured, analyzes a warp and a stress of said electronic component based on a relaxation elastic modulus calculated based on the relationship between said curing degree and said elastic constant,
further including:
initialization unit for initializing a parameter indicative of a division number of said division unit,
division number changing unit for changing a parameter indicative of said division number in ascending order or descending order, and
determination unit for determining whether said division number changed exceeds the total number of divisions, wherein
when the division number exceeds the total number of divisions, operation is ended and when failing to exceed, said obtaining unit obtains a relaxation elastic modulus of said electronic component corresponding to the division time,
said curing degree calculation unit calculates a curing degree,
said analysis unit analyzes a warp and a stress of said electronic component based on a relaxation elastic modulus corresponding to said division unit according to a value of said curing degree calculated, and
said processing is executed on a basis of a unit of division obtained by dividing said temperature profile by a predetermined time.

### Claim 26 (depends on 25)

The electronic component warp analysis system according to claim 25, wherein the master curve related to said electronic component is a curve indicative of a relationship between a relaxation elastic modulus and time with respect to a resin coating said electronic component.

### Claim 27 (depends on 25)

The electronic component warp analysis system according to claim 25, wherein the curing degree related to said electronic component is a curing degree as of a relevant time point after said shift with respect to the resin coating said electronic component.

### Claim 28 (depends on 25)

The electronic component warp analysis system according to claim 25, wherein said obtaining unit, said curing degree calculation unit and said analysis unit repeat the processing as many times as the number of time divisions of said temperature profile.

### Claim 29 (depends on 25)

The electronic component warp analysis system according to claim 25, wherein said division unit executes, as a method of segmenting a time base of said temperature profile, equipartition or segmentation of a part whose temperature change is sharp is executed.

### Claim 30 (depends on 25)

The electronic component warp analysis system according to claim 25, wherein said initialization unit applies the value of zero to said parameter indicative of said division number for initializing said parameter.

### Claim 31 (depends on 25)

The electronic component warp analysis system according to claim 25, wherein said division number changing unit increments said division number by 1 or not less than 1.

### Claim 32 (depends on 25)

The electronic component warp analysis system according to claim 25, wherein in the calculation of a relaxation elastic modulus corresponding to said division unit by said obtaining unit, at a time and a temperature of said temperature profile at said division number changed, a relaxation elastic modulus is calculated at said division number obtained after shifting on a time base of said master curve according to a shift factor.

### Claim 33

A non-transitory computer readable medium for storing a board warp analysis program realized on a board warp analysis system of analyzing a warp of a board, which causes,
in board warp calculation based on model data including at least a configuration and an elastic constant of said board and an electronic component mounted on said board,
division unit to execute division processing of dividing a temperature profile indicative of a relationship between a temperature and a time with respect to said electronic component by a predetermined time,
obtaining unit to execute obtaining processing of obtaining a relaxation elastic modulus of said electronic component corresponding to the divisional time by shifting on a time base of a master curve related to said electronic component which is composed with respect to a reference temperature based on a temperature-time conversion rule,
curing degree calculating unit to execute curing degree calculation processing of calculating a curing degree of said electronic component based on a relationship between a time after shift and an actually applied temperature, and
analysis unit to execute analysis processing of analyzing a warp and a stress of said electronic component based on a relaxation elastic modulus on said master curve corresponding to said curing degree or a relaxation elastic modulus calculated based on a relationship between said curing degree and said elastic constant according to a value of said curing degree calculated,
wherein in said analysis processing,
when said curing degree calculated indicates curing-end, a warp and a stress of said electronic component are analyzed based on a relaxation elastic modulus on said master curve corresponding to said curing degree, and
when said curing degree indicates yet-to-be-cured, a warp and a stress of said electronic component are analyzed based on a relaxation elastic modulus calculated based on the relationship between said curing degree and said elastic constant,
further including:
said division processing,
initialization processing by initialization unit of initializing a parameter indicative of a division number of said division unit,
division number changing processing by division number changing unit of changing a parameter indicative of said division number in ascending order or descending order, and
determination processing by determination unit of determining whether said division number changed exceeds the total number of divisions, wherein
when the division number exceeds the total number of divisions, operation is ended and when failing to exceed, a relaxation elastic modulus of said electronic component corresponding to the division time is obtained in said obtaining processing,
a curing degree is calculated in said curing degree calculation processing,
a warp and a stress of said electronic component are analyzed by said analysis unit based on a relaxation elastic modulus corresponding to said division unit according to a value of said curing degree calculated, and
said processing is executed on a basis of a unit of division obtained by dividing said temperature profile by a predetermined time.

### Claim 34 (depends on 33)

The non-transitory computer readable medium for storing the board warp analysis program according to claim 33, wherein the master curve related to said electronic component is a curve indicative of a relationship between a relaxation elastic modulus and time with respect to a resin coating said electronic component.

### Claim 35 (depends on 33)

The non-transitory computer readable medium for storing the board warp analysis program according to claim 33, wherein the curing degree related to said electronic component is a curing degree as of a relevant time point after said shift with respect to the resin coating said electronic component.

### Claim 36 (depends on 33)

The non-transitory computer readable medium for storing the board warp analysis program according to claim 33, wherein in said obtaining processing, said curing degree calculation processing and said analysis processing, the processing is repeated as many times as the number of time divisions of said temperature profile.

### Claim 37 (depends on 33)

The non-transitory computer readable medium for storing the board warp analysis program according to claim 33, wherein in said division processing, as a method of segmenting a time base of said temperature profile, equipartition or segmentation of a part whose temperature change is sharp is executed.

### Claim 38 (depends on 33)

The non-transitory computer readable medium for storing the board warp analysis program according to claim 33, wherein in said initialization processing, the value of zero is applied to said parameter indicative of said division number for initializing said parameter.

### Claim 39 (depends on 33)

The non-transitory computer readable medium for storing the board warp analysis program according to claim 33, wherein in said division number changing processing, said division number is incremented by 1 or not less than 1.

### Claim 40 (depends on 33)

The non-transitory computer readable medium for storing the board warp analysis program according to claim 33, wherein in the calculation of a relaxation elastic modulus corresponding to said division unit by said obtaining processing, at a time and a temperature of said temperature profile at said division number changed, a relaxation elastic modulus is calculated at said division number obtained after shifting on a time base of said master curve according to a shift factor.

### Claim 41

A non-transitory computer readable medium for storing a program for analyzing a warp of an electronic component which is realized on an electronic component warp analysis system of analyzing a warp of an electronic component, which causes,
in board warp calculation based on model data including at least a configuration and an elastic constant of said electronic component,
division unit to execute division processing of dividing a temperature profile indicative of a relationship between a temperature and a time with respect to said electronic component by a predetermined time,
obtaining unit to execute obtaining processing of obtaining a relaxation elastic modulus of said electronic component corresponding to the divisional time by shifting on a time base of a master curve related to said electronic component which is composed with respect to a reference temperature based on a temperature-time conversion rule,
curing degree calculating unit to execute curing degree calculation processing of calculating a curing degree of said electronic component based on a relationship between a time after shift and an actually applied temperature, and
analysis unit to execute analysis processing of analyzing a warp and a stress of said electronic component based on a relaxation elastic modulus on said master curve corresponding to said curing degree or a relaxation elastic modulus calculated based on a relationship between said curing degree and said elastic constant according to a value of said curing degree calculated,
wherein in said analysis processing,
when said curing degree calculated indicates curing-end, a warp and a stress of said electronic component are analyzed based on a relaxation elastic modulus on said master curve corresponding to said curing degree, and
when said curing degree indicates yet-to-be cured, a warp and a stress of said electronic component are analyzed based on a relaxation elastic modulus calculated based on a relationship between said curing degree and said elastic constant,
further including:
said division processing,
initialization processing by initialization unit of initializing a parameter indicative of a division number of said division unit,
division number changing processing by division number changing unit of changing a parameter indicative of said division number in ascending order or descending order, and
determination processing by determination unit of determining whether said division number changed exceeds the total number of divisions, wherein
when the division number exceeds the total number of divisions, operation is ended and when failing to exceed, a relaxation elastic modulus of said electronic component corresponding to said division time is obtained in said obtaining processing,
a curing degree is calculated in said curing degree calculation processing,
a warp and a stress of said electronic component are analyzed by said analysis unit based on a relaxation elastic modulus corresponding to said division unit according to a value of said curing degree calculated, and
said processing is executed on a basis of a unit of division obtained by dividing said temperature profile by a predetermined time.

### Claim 42 (depends on 41)

The non-transitory computer readable medium for storing the electronic component warp analysis program according to claim 41, wherein the master curve related to said electronic component is a curve indicative of a relationship between a relaxation elastic modulus and time with respect to a resin coating said electronic component.

### Claim 43 (depends on 41)

The non-transitory computer readable medium for storing the electronic component warp analysis program according to claim 41, wherein the curing degree related to said electronic component is a curing degree as of a relevant time point after said shift with respect to the resin coating said electronic component.

### Claim 44 (depends on 41)

The non-transitory computer readable medium for storing the electronic component warp analysis program according to claim 41, wherein in said obtaining processing, said curing degree calculation processing and said analysis processing, the processing is repeated as many times as the number of time divisions of said temperature profile.

### Claim 45 (depends on 41)

The non-transitory computer readable medium for storing the electronic component warp analysis program according to claim 41, wherein in said division processing, as a method of segmenting a time base of said temperature profile, equipartition or segmentation of a part whose temperature change is sharp is executed.

### Claim 46 (depends on 41)

The non-transitory computer readable medium for storing the electronic component warp analysis program according to claim 41, wherein in said initialization processing, the value of zero is applied to said parameter indicative of said division number for initializing said parameter.

### Claim 47 (depends on 41)

The non-transitory computer readable medium for storing the electronic component warp analysis program according to claim 41, wherein in said division number changing processing, said division number is incremented by 1 or not less than 1.

### Claim 48 (depends on 41)

The non-transitory computer readable medium for storing the electronic component warp analysis program according to claim 41, wherein in the calculation of a relaxation elastic modulus corresponding to said division unit by said obtaining processing, at a time and a temperature of said temperature profile at said division number changed, a relaxation elastic modulus is calculated at said division number obtained after shifting on a time base of said master curve according to a shift factor.
