# US 8,278,939 B2 · Diagnostic method for determining deformations in a transformer winding

> Agents: this data is available as JSON from the patentgrep API and MCP server — see https://patentgrep.com/llms.txt

- Number: US 8,278,939 B2
- Document ID: US8278939B2
- Status: Granted
- Kind: B2
- Application number: 12/679,748
- Filed: 2008-09-11
- Published: 2010-08-19
- Granted: 2012-10-02
- Earliest claimed: 2007-09-27
- Assignees: Indian Institute of Technology Bombay
- Inventors: Prasad Madhukar Joshi; Shrikrishna Vyankatesh Kulkarni
- Web page: https://patentgrep.com/patent/US8278939B2

## CPC

- G01B 7/22: {using change in capacitance}
- G01B: MEASURING LENGTH, THICKNESS OR SIMILAR LINEAR DIMENSIONS; MEASURING ANGLES; MEASURING AREAS; MEASURING IRREGULARITIES OF SURFACES OR CONTOURS

## Abstract

A diagnostic method for determining deformations in a transformer winding including the steps of representing the winding as a lumped parameter circuit and dividing the winding into at least two sections; generating a first set of fingerprint values based on capacitive values of the winding; the first set of finger print values indicating the location and extent of radial deformation in the winding; generating a second set of fingerprint values based on capacitive values of the winding; the second set of finger prints indicating the location and extent of axial deformation in the winding and determining the location and extent of radial or axial deformation or combination of both radial and axial deformation in the winding by comparing the measured values with the first set and second set of finger print values.

## Claims

### Claim 1

A diagnostic method for determining deformations in a transformer winding, comprising the steps of:
A. representing the winding as a lumped parameter circuit and dividing the winding into at least two sections;
B. generating a first set of fingerprint values based on capacitive values of the winding; the first set of finger print values indicating the location and extent of radial deformation in the winding is as follows:
(i) measuring a terminal capacitance C1 between one end of the winding and one ground terminal at a high frequency beyond which the terminal impedance of the winding remains capacitive, while keeping the other end of the winding and the other ground terminal disconnected; measuring a terminal capacitance C2 between the other end of the winding and the other ground terminal at the same high frequency, while keeping the one end of the winding and the one ground terminal disconnected; measuring a capacitance C3 across the two ends of the winding at the same high frequency; measuring a terminal capacitance C4 between one end of the winding and one ground terminal or the other end of the winding and the other ground terminal at a low frequency at which the terminal impedance of the winding is predominantly capacitive in nature, while keeping disconnected the winding end and ground terminal, at which the measurement is not taken;
(ii) calculating the sectional series capacitance (Cs) and the sectional ground capacitance (Cg) of each of the different sections of the winding using the values of C3 and C4 obtained in step B(i);
(iii) simulating a range of deformations in each of the sections of the winding by changing the sectional ground capacitance Cg obtained in step B(ii) by predetermined percentages and generating simulated terminal capacitance values C1′, C2′, C3′ and C4′ under the same conditions and procedures corresponding to C1, C2, C3 and C4, respectively in step B(i) for each change of the sectional ground capacitance;
(iv) calculating a deformation coefficient which is a non-limiting function of (C1−C1′)/(C2−C2′) for each of the sections of the winding for each change of the sectional ground capacitance Cg made in step B(iii);
(iva) forming the first set of finger prints using the deformation coefficients obtained in the step above, the first set of finger prints indicating the location of the radially deformed section of the winding; and
(v) calculating the difference between C4 in step B(i) and C4′ obtained in step B(iii), a difference in the values indicating the extent of radial deformation in the deformed section of the winding;
C. generating a second set of fingerprint values based on capacitive values of the winding, the second set of finger prints indicating the location and extent of axial deformation in the winding as follows:
(vi) simulating a range of deformations in each of the sections of the winding by changing the sectional series capacitance Cs obtained in step B(ii) by predetermined percentages and generating simulated terminal capacitance values C1″ and C2″ and capacitance value C3″ under the same conditions and procedures corresponding to C1, C2 and C3, respectively in step B(i) for each of the said range of deformation percentages;
(vii) calculating the deformation coefficient which is a non-limiting function of (C1−C1″)/(C2−C2″) for each of the sections of the winding for each change of the sectional series capacitance Cs made in step C(vi);
(viia) forming one part of the second set of finger prints using the deformation coefficients obtained in the step above, the one part of the second set of fingerprints indicating the location of the axially deformed section of the winding;
(viii) calculating the difference between C3 obtained in step B(i) and C3″ obtained in step C(vi) for each section of the winding for each change of the sectional series capacitance in step C(vi); and
(viiia) forming a second part of the second set of finger prints using the differences obtained in the step above, the second part of the second set of fingerprints indicating the extent of the axial deformation in the deformed section of the winding;
D. determining the location and extent of radial or axial deformation or combination of both radial and axial deformation in the winding as follows:
(i) measuring the terminal capacitance values C1′″, C2′″, C4′″ and capacitance value C3′″ as explained in step B(i);
(ii) comparing the values of C1 with C1′″ and C2 with C2′″, wherein no difference in the values indicates that the winding has not been deformed, carrying out the following steps (iii)-(vi) for locating the deformed section of the winding and for determining whether the deformation in the section is radial or axial or combination of both radial and axial and its extent, if there is a difference between the values;
(iii) comparing the values of C4 with C4′″, a difference in the values indicating a radial deformation in the winding and its extent, calculating the deformation coefficient which is a non-limiting function of (C1−C1′″)/(C2−C2′″) for identifying the section of the winding which has been radially deformed, comparing the calculated deformation coefficient with the fingerprints of deformation coefficients obtained in step B(iv) for locating the section of the winding which has been radially deformed;
(iv) comparing the difference between C3′ corresponding to the deformed section located in the above step and C3′″, the difference C3′″−C3′, if any, indicating that a section of the winding has also been axially deformed, comparing C3′″−C3′ with C3 for knowing the extent of axial deformation, comparing the difference obtained with the fingerprints of the differences in step C(viiia); and
(v) wherein no difference between the values of C4 and C4′″ indicates that a section of the winding has been axially deformed, identifying the axially deformed section by comparing the deformation coefficient calculated in D(iii) with the fingerprints of deformation coefficients obtained in step C(vii) for locating the section of the winding which has been axially deformed, and
(vi) comparing C3′″ with C3, comparing the difference between C3′″ and C3 with the fingerprints in step C(viiia) for knowing the extent of axial deformation.

### Claim 2 (depends on 1)

A method as claimed in claim 1, wherein the transformer winding is divided into eight uniform sections and Cg and Cs of step B(ii) are calculated as follows:
Cg=C4/(number of sections)
Cg=C4/8 and
Cs=kCg,
where, k is a positive real number and is determined by
C
⁢
⁢
3
C
g
=
1
4
[
2
⁢
⁢
k
4
+
16
⁢
⁢
k
3
+
20
⁢
⁢
k
2
+
8
⁢
⁢
k
+
1
4
⁢
⁢
k
3
+
10
⁢
⁢
k
2
+
6
⁢
⁢
k
+
1
]
.

### Claim 3 (depends on 1, 2)

A method as claimed in claim 1 or 2, wherein the deformation co-efficient in steps B(iv) and C(vii) and D(iii) is calculated as log10 [(C1−C1′)/(C2−C2′)] and log10 [(C1−C1″)/(C2−C2″)] and log10 [(C1−C1′″)/(C2−C2′″)], respectively.

### Claim 4 (depends on 1)

A method as claimed in claim 1, wherein the selected high and low frequencies in step B(i) lie between 1 MHz-10 MHz and 50 Hz-100 Hz, respectively.

### Claim 5

A diagnostic method for determining deformations in a transformer winding comprising three phase windings connected in a delta configuration comprising the steps of:
E. representing one phase winding as a lumped parameter circuit and dividing the phase winding into at least two sections;
F. generating a first set of fingerprint values based on capacitive values of the phase winding, the first set of finger print values indicating the location and extent of radial deformation in the phase winding as follows:
(i) measuring a terminal capacitance C1 between one end of the phase winding and one ground terminal at a high frequency beyond which the terminal impedance of the phase winding remains capacitive, while keeping the other end of the phase winding and the other ground terminal disconnected; measuring a terminal capacitance C2 between the other end of the phase winding and the other ground terminal at the same high frequency, while keeping the one end of the phase winding and the one ground terminal disconnected; measuring a capacitance C3 across the two ends of the phase winding at the same high frequency; measuring a terminal capacitance C4 between one end of the phase winding and one ground terminal or the other end of the phase winding and the other ground terminal at a low frequency at which the terminal impedance of the phase winding is predominantly capacitive in nature, while keeping disconnected the phase winding end and ground terminal, at which the measurement is not taken;
(ii) calculating the sectional series capacitance (Cs) and the sectional ground capacitance (Cg) of each of the different sections of the phase winding using the values of C3 and C4 obtained in step F (i);
(iii) simulating a range of deformations in each of the sections of the phase winding by changing the sectional ground capacitance Cg obtained in step F(ii) by predetermined percentages and generating simulated terminal capacitance values C1′, C2′, C3′ and C4′ under the same conditions and procedures corresponding to C1, C2, C3 and C4, respectively in step F(i) for each change of the sectional ground capacitance;
(iv) calculating the deformation coefficient which is a non-limiting function of (C1−C1′)/(C2−C2′) for each of the sections of the phase winding for each change of the sectional ground capacitance Cg made in step F(iii);
(iva) forming the first set of finger prints using the deformation coefficients, first set of fingerprints indicating the location of the radially deformed section of the phase winding; and
(v) calculating the difference between C4 in step F(i) and C4′ obtained in step F(iii), a difference in the values indicating the extent of radial deformation in the deformed section of the phase winding
G. generating a second set of fingerprint values based on capacitive values of the phase winding, the second set of finger prints indicating the location and extent of axial deformation in the phase winding as follows:
(vi) simulating a range of deformations in each of the sections of the phase winding by changing the sectional series capacitance Cs obtained in step F(ii) by predetermined percentages and generating simulated terminal capacitance values C1″ and C2″ and capacitance value C3″ under the same conditions and procedures corresponding to C1, C2 and C3, respectively in step F(i) for each of the said range of deformation percentages;
(vii) calculating the deformation coefficient which is a non-limiting function of (C1−C1″)/(C2−C2″) for each of the sections of the phase winding for each change of the sectional series capacitance Cs made in step G(vi);
(viia) forming one part of the second set of finger prints using the deformation coefficients obtained in the step above, the one part of the second set of fingerprints indicating the location of the axially deformed section of the phase winding;
(viii) calculating the difference between C3 obtained in step F(i) and C3″ obtained in step G(vi) for each section of the phase winding for each change of the sectional series capacitance in step G(vi); and
(viiia) forming a second part of the second set of finger prints using the differences, the second part of the second set of fingerprints indicating the extent of the axial deformation in the deformed section of the phase winding
H. repeating the steps in F and G for the other two phase windings for generation of two sets of fingerprint values for the other two phase windings;
I. determining the location and extent of radial or axial deformation or combination of both radial and axial deformation in the phase windings as follows:
(i) measuring the terminal capacitance values C1′″, C2′″, C4′″ and capacitance value C3′″ as explained in step F (i) for each phase winding;
(ii) comparing the values of C1 with C1′″ and C2 with C2′″ for each phase winding; wherein no difference in the values indicates that the phase windings have not been deformed, carrying out the following steps (iii)-(vi) for locating the deformed section of the phase winding and for determining whether the deformation in the section is radial or axial or combination of both axial and radial and its extent, if there is a difference between the values for any one of the phase windings;
(iii) comparing the values of C4 with C4′″, a difference in the values indicating a radial deformation in phase winding and its extent, calculating the deformation coefficient which is a non-limiting function of [(C1−C1′″)/(C2−C2′″)] for identifying the section of the phase winding which has been radially deformed, comparing the calculated deformation coefficient with the fingerprints of deformation coefficients obtained in step F(iv) for the phase winding for locating the section of the phase winding which has been radially deformed;
(iv) comparing the difference between C3′ corresponding to the deformed section located in the above step and C3′″, the difference C3′″−C3′, if any, indicating that a section of the phase winding has also been axially deformed, comparing C3′″−C3′ with C3 for knowing the extent of axial deformation, comparing the difference obtained with the fingerprints of the differences in step G(viiia);
(v) wherein no difference between the values of C4 and C4′″ indicating indicates that a section of the phase winding has been axially deformed, identifying the axially deformed section by comparing the deformation coefficient calculated in I(iii) with the fingerprints of deformation coefficients obtained in step G(viia) for locating the section of the phase winding which has been axially deformed;
(vi) comparing C3′″ with C3, comparing the difference between C3′″ and C3 with the fingerprints of the differences in step G (viiia) for knowing the extent of axial deformation; and
(vii) repeating the steps in I(i) to I(vi) for each of the other two phase windings for determining the location and extent of axial or radial or combination deformation in that phase winding.

### Claim 6 (depends on 5)

A method as claimed in claim 5, wherein each phase winding is divided into eight uniform sections and Cg and Cs are calculated as follows:
Cg=C4/(number of sections)
i.e. Cg=C4/24 and
Cs=kCg,
where, k is a positive real number and is determined by
C
3
C
g
=
1
2
[
3
⁢
⁢
k
8
+
64
⁢
⁢
k
7
+
336
⁢
⁢
k
6
+
672
⁢
⁢
k
5
+
660
⁢
⁢
k
4
+
352
⁢
⁢
k
3
+
104
⁢
⁢
k
2
+
16
⁢
⁢
k
+
1
8
⁢
⁢
k
7
+
84
⁢
⁢
k
6
+
252
⁢
⁢
k
5
+
330
⁢
⁢
k
4
+
220
⁢
⁢
k
3
+
78
⁢
⁢
k
2
+
14
⁢
⁢
k
+
1
]
.

### Claim 7 (depends on 5, 6)

A method as claimed in claim 5 or 6, wherein the deformation co-efficient in steps F(iv), G(vii) and I(iii) is calculated as log10 [(C1−C1′)/(C2−C2′)] and log10 [(C1−C1″)/(C2−C2″)] and log10 [(C1−C1′″)/(C2−C2′″)] respectively.

### Claim 8 (depends on 5)

A method as claimed in claim 5, wherein the selected high and low frequencies in step F(i) lie between 1 MHz-10 MHz and 50 Hz-100 Hz, respectively.

### Claim 9

A diagnostic method for determining deformations in a transformer winding comprising three phase windings connected in a star configuration comprising the steps of:
J. representing one phase winding as a lumped parameter circuit and dividing the phase winding into at least two sections,
K. generating a first set of fingerprint values based on capacitive values of the phase winding, the first set of finger print values indicating the location and extent of radial deformation in the phase winding, as follows:
(i) measuring a terminal capacitance C1 between one end of the phase winding and one ground terminal at a high frequency beyond which the terminal impedance of the winding remains capacitive, while keeping the neutral and the other ground terminal disconnected; measuring a terminal capacitance C2 between neutral and the other ground terminal at the same high frequency, while keeping the one end of the phase winding and the one ground terminal disconnected; measuring a capacitance C3 across the two ends of the phase winding (one end and neutral) at the same high frequency; shorting one end of all phase windings and measuring a capacitance C3a across the one end of the phase winding and neutral at the same high frequency; measuring a terminal capacitance C4 between one end of the phase winding and one ground terminal or neutral end of the phase winding and the other ground terminal at a low frequency at which the terminal impedance of the phase winding is predominantly capacitive in nature;
(ii) calculating the sectional series capacitance (Cs) and the sectional ground capacitance (Cg) of each of the different sections of the phase winding using the values of C3a and C4 obtained in step K(i);
(iii) simulating a range of deformations in each of the sections of the phase winding by changing the sectional ground capacitance Cg obtained in step K(ii) by predetermined percentages and generating simulated terminal capacitance values C1′, C2′, C3′, C3a′, and C4′ under the same conditions and procedures corresponding to C1, C2, C3, C3a and C4, respectively in step K(i) for each change of the sectional ground capacitance;
(iv) calculating the deformation coefficient which is a non-limiting function of (C1−C1′)/(C2−C2′) for each of the sections of the phase winding for each change of the sectional ground capacitance Cg made in step K(iii);
(iva) forming the first set of finger prints using the deformation coefficients, first set of fingerprints indicating the location of the radially deformed section of the phase winding; and
(v) calculating the difference between C4 in step K(i) and C4′ obtained in step K(iii), a difference in the values indicating the extent of radial deformation in the deformed section of the phase winding;
L. generating a second set of fingerprint values based on capacitive values of the phase winding, the second set of finger prints indicating the location and extent of axial deformation in the phase winding as follows:
(vi) simulating a range of deformations in each of the sections of the phase winding by changing the sectional series capacitance Cs obtained in step K(ii) by predetermined percentages and generating simulated terminal capacitance values C1″ and C2″ and capacitance value C3″ under the same conditions and procedures corresponding to C1, C2 and C3, respectively in step K(i) for each of the said range of deformation percentages;
(vii) calculating the deformation coefficient which is a non-limiting function of (C1−C1″)/(C2−C2″) for each of the sections of the phase winding for each change of the sectional series capacitance Cs made in step L(vi);
(viia) forming one part of the second set of finger prints using the deformation coefficients, the one part of second set of fingerprints indicating the location of the axially deformed section of the phase winding;
(viii) calculating the difference between C3 obtained in step K(i) and C3″ obtained in step L(vi) for each section of the phase winding for each change of the sectional series capacitance in step L(vi); and
(viiia) forming a second part of the second set of finger prints using the differences, the second part of the second set of fingerprints indicates the extent of the axial deformation in the deformed section of the phase winding;
M. repeating the steps in K and L for each of the other two phase windings for generation of fingerprint values for the other two phase windings;
N. determining the location and extent of radial or axial deformation or combination of both radial and axial deformation in the phase windings as follows:
(i) measuring the terminal capacitance values C1′″, C2′″, C4′″ and capacitance value C3′″ as explained in step K(i);
(ii) comparing the values of C1 with C1′″ and C2 with C2′″, wherein no difference in the values indicates that the phase winding has not been deformed, carrying out the following steps (iii)-(vi) for locating the deformed section of the phase winding and for determining whether the deformation in the section is radial or axial or combination and its extent, if there is a difference between the values;
(iii) comparing the values of C4 with C4′″, a difference in the values indicating a radial deformation in the phase winding and its extent, calculating the deformation coefficient as a non-limiting function of [(C1−C1′″)/(C2−C2′″)] for identifying the section of the winding which has been radially deformed, comparing the calculated deformation coefficient with the fingerprints of deformation coefficients obtained in step K(iv) for locating the section of the phase winding which has been radially deformed,
(iv) comparing the difference between C3′ corresponding to the deformed section in the above step and C3′″, the difference C3′″−C3′, if any, indicating that a section of the phase winding has also been axially deformed, comparing C3′″−C3′ with C3 for knowing the extent of axial deformation, comparing the difference obtained with the fingerprints of the differences in step L(viiia);
(v) wherein no difference between the values of C4 and C4′″ indicates that a section of the phase winding has been axially deformed, identifying the axially deformed section by comparing the deformation coefficient calculated in N(iii) with the fingerprints of deformation coefficients obtained in step L(viia) for locating the section of the phase winding which has been axially deformed;
(vi) comparing C3′″ with C3, comparing the difference between C3 and C3′″ with the fingerprints of the differences in step L(viiia) for knowing the extent of axial deformation; and
(vii) repeating the steps in N(i) to N(vi) for each of the other two phase windings for determining the location and extent of deformation in that phase winding.

### Claim 10 (depends on 9)

A method as claimed in claim 9, wherein each phase winding is divided into eight uniform sections and Cg and Cs in step K(ii) are calculated as follows:
Cg=C4/(number of sections)
i.e. Cg=C4/24 and
Cs=kCg,
where, k is a positive real number and is determined by
C
⁢
⁢
3
⁢
⁢
a
C
g
=
3
4
[
2
⁢
⁢
k
4
+
16
⁢
⁢
k
3
+
20
⁢
⁢
k
2
+
8
⁢
⁢
k
+
1
4
⁢
⁢
k
3
+
10
⁢
⁢
k
2
+
6
⁢
⁢
k
+
1
]
.

### Claim 11 (depends on 9, 10)

A method as claimed in claim 9 or 10, wherein the deformation co-efficient in step K(iv), L(vii) and N(iii) is calculated as log10 [(C1−C1′)/(C2−C2′)] and log10 [(C1−C1″)/(C2−C2″)] and log10 [(C1−C1′″)/(C2−C2′″)].

### Claim 12 (depends on 9)

A method as claimed in claim 9, wherein the selected high and low frequencies in step K(i) lie between 1 MHz-10 MHz and 50 Hz-100 Hz, respectively.
