A method of operating a gaming system, said gaming system including a plurality of gaming machines, each gaming machine including a primary game and a display device, wherein each primary game is associated with a triggering event, and said gaming system includes a separate shared display, said method for each gaming machine comprising:
- (a) enabling a player to place at least one of a plurality of wagers, wherein at least one of the wagers is a designated wager;
- (b) if the player placed at least one of the wagers:
- (i) enabling the player to play the primary game on said gaming machine;
- (ii) determining a primary game outcome for the player based on the primary game;
- and
- (iii) upon an occurrence of the triggering event associated with the primary game:
- (1) determining if the player placed the designated wager;
- (2) if the player did not place the designated wager, enabling the player to play a bonus game wherein the bonus game is displayed on the individual display device of the gaming machine and said bonus game is associated with a first average expected payout;
- (3) if the player placed the designated wager, enabling the player to play the bonus game wherein said bonus game is displayed on the shared display and the bonus game is associated with a second average expected payout, wherein said second average expected payout is higher than the first average expected payout;
- (4) determining a bonus game outcome for the player;
- and
- (d) providing any awards to the player based on the primary game outcome and any bonus game outcome.