# US 6,730,444 B2 · Needle comb reticle pattern for critical dimension and registration measurements using a registration tool and methods for using same

> Agents: this data is available as JSON from the patentgrep API and MCP server — see https://patentgrep.com/llms.txt

- Number: US 6,730,444 B2
- Document ID: US6730444B2
- Status: Granted
- Kind: B2
- Application number: 09/874,615
- Filed: 2001-06-05
- Published: 2002-12-05
- Granted: 2004-05-04
- Earliest claimed: 2001-06-05
- Assignees: Micron Technology, Inc.
- Inventors: Steve W. Bowes
- Web page: https://patentgrep.com/patent/US6730444B2

## CPC

- G03F 7/70625: {Dimensions, e.g. line width, critical dimension [CD], profile, sidewall angle or edge roughness}
- G03F 1/44: Testing or measuring features, e.g. grid patterns, focus monitors, sawtooth scales or notched scales
- G03F 7/70633: {Overlay, i.e. relative alignment between patterns printed by separate exposures in different layers, or in the same layer in multiple exposures or stitching}
- H10W 46/501: {for use before dicing}
- G03F: PHOTOMECHANICAL PRODUCTION OF TEXTURED OR PATTERNED SURFACES, e.g. FOR PRINTING, FOR PROCESSING OF SEMICONDUCTOR DEVICES; MATERIALS THEREFOR; ORIGINALS THEREFOR; APPARATUS SPECIALLY ADAPTED THEREFOR; (phototypographic composing devices B41B; photosensitive materials or processes for photographic purposes G03C; electrophotography, sensitive layers or processes therefor G03G)
- H10W: GENERIC PACKAGES, INTERCONNECTIONS, CONNECTORS OR OTHER CONSTRUCTIONAL DETAILS OF DEVICES COVERED BY CLASS H10

## Abstract

Needle comb reticle patterns for use in both critical dimension analysis and registration analysis with a registration tool are disclosed. One embodiment of a needle comb reticle pattern includes a box-in-box feature flanked on two adjacent sides by needle combs with tapered flat-tipped needles. Another embodiment of a needle comb reticle pattern includes a box-in-box feature flanked on two adjacent sides by needle combs with tapered flat-tipped needles and flanked on the other two adjacent sides by reference bars. Yet another embodiment of a needle comb reticle pattern includes two complementary needle comb reticle subpatterns, each subpattern including a box-in-box feature with four flanking needle combs. A registration tool can be used with the needle combs and reference bars to measure critical dimension of a semiconductor process. The registration tool can also be used with the box-in-box feature to measure registration between two adjacent layers during semiconductor fabrication. Reticles, fields within reticles, masks and wafers including the needle comb reticle pattern of the present invention are also disclosed. Additionally, methods for analyzing critical dimension and registration and characterizing needle comb reticle measurements to critical dimension using the needle comb reticle patterns of the present invention are also disclosed.

## Claims

### Claim 1

A needle comb reticle pattern for use in process measurement during semiconductor substrate processing comprising:
a box-in-box feature including a solid inner box having an outer periphery substantially defined by four substantially straight sides and an outer box frame having an inner periphery substantially defined by four inner substantially straight sides and an outer periphery substantially defined by four outer substantially straight sides;
wherein the outer box frame surrounds the inner box and a gap separates the outer periphery of the inner box and inner periphery of the outer box frame;
wherein the gap between the outer periphery of the inner box and the inner periphery of the outer box frame is substantially uniform along each side of the inner box and outer box frame;
a first needle comb proximately flanking the outer periphery of a first side of the outer box frame; and
a second needle comb proximately flanking the outer periphery of a second side of the outer box frame.

### Claim 2 (depends on 1)

The needle comb reticle pattern of claim 1, wherein each of the first and second needle combs comprises a plurality of needles emanating from a respective solid bar base and pointing toward the box-in-box feature.

### Claim 3 (depends on 2)

The needle comb reticle pattern of claim 2, wherein each of the plurality of needles tapers in width in stair-step fashion to a flat tip.

### Claim 4 (depends on 3)

The needle comb reticle pattern of claim 3, wherein each of the plurality of needles tapers in width from larger than stepper resolution to smaller than stepper resolution.

### Claim 5 (depends on 2)

The needle comb reticle pattern of claim 2, wherein each of the plurality of needles is approximately 1.5 μm in length.

### Claim 6 (depends on 2)

The needle comb reticle pattern of claim 2, wherein the plurality of needles is mutually spaced at a pitch of approximately 0.25 μm.

### Claim 7 (depends on 1)

The needle comb reticle pattern of claim 1, wherein the needle comb reticle pattern is substantially square in shape with sides of approximately 22 μm in length.

### Claim 8

A semiconductor reticle used in semiconductor fabrication comprising:
at least one active device pattern; and
a needle comb reticle pattern adjacent to the at least one active device pattern, wherein the needle comb reticle pattern comprises:
a box-in-box feature including a solid inner box having an outer periphery substantially defined by four substantially straight sides and an outer box frame having an inner periphery substantially defined by four inner substantially straight sides and an outer periphery substantially defined by four outer substantially straight sides;
wherein the outer box frame surrounds the inner box and a gap separates the outer periphery of the inner box and inner periphery of the outer box frame;.
wherein the gap between the outer periphery of the inner box and the inner periphery of the outer box frame is substantially uniform along each side of the inner box and outer box frame;
a first needle comb proximately flanking the outer periphery of a first side of the outer box frame; and
a second needle comb proximately flanking the outer periphery of a second side of the outer box frame.

### Claim 9 (depends on 8)

The semiconductor reticle of claim 8, wherein each of the first and second needle combs comprises a plurality of needles emanating from a solid bar base and pointing toward the box-in-box feature.

### Claim 10 (depends on 8)

The semiconductor reticle of claim 8, wherein each of the plurality of needles tapers in width in stair-step fashion to a flat tip.

### Claim 11 (depends on 9)

The semiconductor reticle of claim 9, wherein each of the plurality of needles tapers in width from larger than stepper resolution to smaller than stepper resolution.

### Claim 12

A semiconductor wafer comprising:
at least one active device patern; and
at least one needle comb reticle pattern adjacent to the at least one active device pattern, wherein the at least one needle comb reticle pattern comprises:
a box-in-box feature including a solid inner box having an outer periphery substantially defined by four substantially straight sides and an outer box frame having an inner periphery substantially defined by four inner substantially straight sides and an outer periphery substantially defined by four outer substantially straight sides;
wherein the outer box frame surrounds the inner box and a gap separates the outer periphery of the inner box and inner periphery of the outer box frame;
wherein the gap between the outer periphery of the inner box and the inner periphery of the outer box frame is substantially uniform along each side of the inner box and outer box frame;
a first needle comb proximately flanking the outer periphery of a first side of the outer box frame; and
a second needle comb proximately flanking the outer periphery of a second side of the outer box frame.

### Claim 13 (depends on 12)

The semiconductor wafer of claim 12, wherein each of the first and second needle combs comprises a plurality of needles emanating from a solid bar base and pointing toward the box-in-box feature.

### Claim 14 (depends on 12)

The semiconductor wafer of claim 12, wherein each of the plurality of needles tapers in width in stair-step fashion to a flat tip.

### Claim 15

A semiconductor mask comprising:
at least one active device pattern; and
at least one needle comb reticle pattern adjacent to the at least one active device pattern, wherein the at least one needle comb reticle pattern comprises:
a box-in-box feature including a solid inner box having an outer periphery substantially defined by four substantially straight sides and an outer box frame having an inner periphery substantially defined by four inner substantially straight sides and an outer periphery substantially defined by four outer substantially straight sides;
wherein the outer box frame surrounds the inner box and a gap separates the outer periphery of the inner box and inner periphery of the outer box frame;
wherein the gap between the outer periphery of the inner box and the inner periphery of the outer box frame is substantially uniform along each side of the inner box and outer box fame;
a first needle comb proximately flanking the outer periphery of a first side of the outer box frame; and
a second needle comb proximately flanking the outer periphery of a second side of the outer box frame.

### Claim 16 (depends on 15)

The semiconductor mask of claim 15, wherein each of the first and second needle combs comprises a plurality of needles emanating from a solid bar base and pointing toward the box-in-box feature.

### Claim 17 (depends on 16)

The semiconductor mask of claim 16, wherein each of the plurality of needles tapers in width in stair-step fashion to a flat tip.

### Claim 18 (depends on 16)

The semiconductor mask of claim 16, wherein each of the plurality of needles tapers in width from larger than stepper resolution to smaller than stepper resolution.

### Claim 19

A needle comb reticle pattern for use in process measurement during semiconductor substrate processing comprising:
a box-in-box feature including a solid inner box having an outer periphery substantially defined by four substantially straight sides and an outer box frame having an inner periphery substantially defined by four inner substantially straight sides and an outer periphery substantially defined by four outer substantially straight sides;
wherein the outer box frame surrounds the inner box and a gap separates the outer periphery of the inner box and inner periphery of the outer box frame;
wherein the gap between the outer periphery of the inner box and the inner periphery of the outer box frame is substantially uniform along each side of the inner box and outer box frame;
a first needle comb proximately flanking the outer periphery of a first side of the outer box frame;
a second needle comb proximately flanking the outer periphery of a second side of the outer box frame; and
a first reference bar proximately flanking the outer periphery of a third side of the outer box frame;
a second reference bar proximately flanking the outer periphery of a fourth side of the outer box frame.

### Claim 20 (depends on 19)

The needle comb reticle pattern of claim 19, wherein each of the first and second needle combs comprises a plurality of needles emanating from a solid bar base and pointing toward the box-in-box feature and one of the first and second reference bars.

### Claim 21 (depends on 20)

The needle comb reticle pattern of claim 20, wherein each of the plurality of needles tapers in width in stair-step fashion to a flat tip.

### Claim 22 (depends on 21)

The needle comb reticle pattern of claim 21, wherein each of the plurality of needles tapers in width from larger than stepper resolution to smaller than stepper resolution.

### Claim 23 (depends on 20)

The needle comb reticle pattern of claim 20, wherein each of the plurality of needles is approximately 1.5 μm in length.

### Claim 24 (depends on 20)

The needle comb reticle pattern of claim 20, wherein each of the plurality of needles is mutually spaced at a pitch of approximately 0.25 μm.

### Claim 25 (depends on 19)

The needle comb reticle pattern of claim 19, wherein the needle comb reticle pattern is substantially square in shape with sides of approximately 25 μm in length.

### Claim 26

A semiconductor reticle used in semiconductor fabrication comprising:
at least one active device pattern; and
a needle comb reticle pattern adjacent to the at least one active device pattern, wherein the needle comb reticle pattern comprises:
a box-in-box feature including a solid inner box having an outer periphery substantially defined by four substantially straight sides and an outer box frame having an inner periphery substantially defined by four inner substantially straight sides and an outer periphery substantially defined by four outer substantially straight sides;
wherein the outer box frame surrounds the inner box and a gap separates the outer periphery of the inner box and inner periphery of the outer box frame;
wherein the gap between the outer periphery of the inner box and the inner periphery of the outer box frame is substantially uniform along each side of the inner box and outer box frame;
a first needle comb proximately flanking the outer periphery of a first side of the outer box frame;
a second needle comb proximately flanking the outer periphery of a second side of the outer box frame; and
a first reference bar proximately flanking the outer periphery of a third side of the outer box frame; and
a second reference bar proximately flanging the outer periphery of a fourth side of the outer box frame.

### Claim 27 (depends on 26)

The semiconductor reticle of claim 26, wherein each of the first and second needle combs comprises a plurality of needles emanating from a solid bar base and pointing toward the box-in-box feature and one of the first and second reference bars.

### Claim 28 (depends on 27)

The semiconductor reticle of claim 27, wherein each of the plurality of needles tapers in width in stair-step fashion to a flat tip.

### Claim 29 (depends on 28)

The semiconductor reticle of claim 28, wherein each of the plurality of needles tapers in width from larger than stepper resolution to smaller than stepper resolution.

### Claim 30

A semiconductor wafer comprising:
at least one active device pattern; and
at least one needle comb reticle pattern adjacent to the at least one active device pattern, wherein the at least one needle comb reticle pattern comprises:
a box-in-box feature including a solid inner box having an outer periphery substantially defined by four substantially straight sides and an outer box frame having an inner periphery substantially defined by four inner substantially straight sides and an outer periphery substantially defined by four outer substantially straight sides;
wherein the outer box frame surrounds the inner box and a gap separates the outer periphery of the inner box and inner periphery of the outer box frame;
wherein the gap between the outer periphery of the inner box and the inner periphery of the outer box frame is substantially uniform along each side of the inner box and outer box frame;
a first needle comb proximately flanking the outer periphery of a first side of the outer box frame;
a second needle comb proximately flanking the outer periphery of a second side of the outer box frame;
a reference bar proximately flan the outer periphery of a third side of the outer box frame; and
a second reference bar proximately flanking the outer periphery of a fourth side of the outer box frame.

### Claim 31 (depends on 30)

The semiconductor wafer of claim 30, wherein each of the first and second needle combs comes a plurality of needles emanating from a solid bar base and pointing toward the box-in-box feature and one of the first and second reference bars.

### Claim 32 (depends on 31)

The semiconductor wafer of claim 31, wherein each of the plurality of needles tapers in width in stair-step fashion to a flat tip.

### Claim 33

A semiconductor mask comprising:
at least one active device pattern; and
at least one needle comb reticle pattern adjacent to the at least one active device patter, wherein the at least one needle comb reticle pattern comprises:
a box-in-box feature including a solid inner box having an outer periphery substantially defined by four substantially straight sides and an outer box frame having an inner periphery substantially defined by four inner substantially straight sides and an outer periphery substantially defined by four outer substantially straight sides;
wherein the outer box frame surrounds the inner box and a gap separates the outer periphery of the inner box and inner periphery of the outer box frame;
wherein the gap between the outer periphery of the inner box and the inner periphery of the outer box frame is substantially uniform along each side of the inner box and outer box frame;
a first needle comb proximately flanking the outer periphery of a first side of the outer box frame;
a second needle comb proximately flanking the outer periphery of a second side of the outer box frame;
a first reference bar proximately flanking the outer periphery of a third side of the outer box frame; and
a second reference bar proximately flanking the outer periphery of a fourth side of the otter box frame.

### Claim 34 (depends on 33)

The semiconductor mask of claim 33, wherein each of the first and second needle combs comprises a plurality of needles emanating from a solid bar base and pointing toward the box-in-box feature and one of the first and second reference bars.

### Claim 35 (depends on 34)

The semiconductor mask of claim 34, wherein each of the plurality of needles tapers in width in stair-step fashion to a flat tip.

### Claim 36 (depends on 34)

The semiconductor mask of claim 34, wherein each of the plurality of needles tapers in width from larger than stepper resolution to smaller than stepper resolution.

### Claim 37

A method of analyzing critical dimension and registration with needle comb reticle patterns using a registration tool, the method comprising:
providing a semiconductor wafer with at least one needle comb reticle pattern, including configuring the at least one needle comb reticle pattern to include:
a box-in-box feature including an solid inner box having an outer periphery substantially defined by four substantially straight sides and an outer box frame having an inner periphery substantially defined by four inner substantially straight sides and an outer periphery substantially defined by four outer substantially straight sides;
wherein the outer box frame surrounds the inner box and a gap separates the outer periphery of the inner box and inner periphery of the outer box frame;
wherein the gap between the outer periphery of the inner box and the inner periphery of the outer box frame is substantially uniform along each side of the inner box and outer box frame;
a first needle comb proximately flanking the outer periphery of a first side of the outer box frame; and
a second needle comb proximately flanking the outer periphery of a second side of the outer box frame;
providing a registration tool including:
a registration tool stage;
an optical registration tool; and
a monitor electrically coupled to the optical registration tool;
placing the semiconductor wafer on the registration tool stage;
aligning the optical registration tool with the at least one needle comb reticle pattern; and
analyzing critical dimension and registration from lengths measured from the at least one needle comb reticle pattern.

### Claim 38 (depends on 37)

The method of claim 37, further comprising configuring the at least one needle comb reticle pattern to include a first reference bar flanking the outer periphery of a third side of the outer box frame and a second reference bar flanking the outer periphery of a fourth side of the outer box frame.

### Claim 39 (depends on 38)

The method of claim 38, wherein each of the first and second needle combs comprises a plurality of needles emanating from a solid bar base and pointing toward the box-in-box feature and one of the first and second reference bars.

### Claim 40 (depends on 39)

The method of claim 39, wherein each of the plurality of needles tapers in width in stair-step fashion to a flat tip.

### Claim 41 (depends on 40)

The method of claim 40, wherein each of tie plurality of needles tapers in width from larger than stepper resolution to smaller than stepper resolution.

### Claim 42 (depends on 37)

The method of claim 37, further comprising repeating the aligning and the analyzing for the at least one needle comb reticle pattern on the semiconductor wafer.

### Claim 43

A field of a reticle comprising:
a rectangular window encompassing a plurality of active device patterns; and
a plurality of needle comb reticle patterns encompassed within the rectangular window and adjacent to the plurality of active device patterns, wherein each of the plurality of needle comb reticle patterns includes:
a box-in-box feature including a solid inner box having an outer periphery substantially defined by four substantially straight sides and an outer box frame having an inner periphery substantially defined by four inner substantially straight sides and an outer periphery substantially defined by four outer substantially straight sides;
wherein the outer box frame surrounds the inner box and a gap separates the outer periphery of the inner box and inner periphery of the outer box frame;
wherein the gap between the outer periphery of the inner box and the inner periphery of the outer box frame is substantially uniform along each side of the inner box and outer box frame;
a first needle comb proximately flanking the outer periphery of a first side of the outer box frame; and
a second needle comb proximately flanking the outer periphery of a second side of the outer box frame.

### Claim 44 (depends on 43)

The field of a reticle of claim 43, wherein the plurality of needle comb reticle patterns comprises four needle comb reticle patterns, each of which is located near a comer of the rectangular window.

### Claim 45

A field of a reticle comprising:
a rectangular window encompassing a plurality of active device patterns; and
a plurality of needle comb reticle patterns encompassed within the rectangular window and adjacent to the plurality of active device patterns, wherein each of the plurality of needle comb reticle patterns includes:
a box-in-box feature including a solid inner box having an outer periphery substantially defined by four substantially straight sides and an outer box frame having an inner periphery substantially defined by four inner substantially straight sides and an outer periphery substantially defined by four outer substantially straight sides;
wherein the outer box frame surrounds the inner box and a gap separates the outer periphery of the inner box and inner periphery of the outer box fame;
wherein the gap between the outer periphery of the inner box and the inner periphery of the outer box frame is substantially uniform along each side of the inner box and outer box frame;
a first needle comb proximately flanking the outer periphery of a first side of the outer box frame;
a second needle comb proximately flanking the outer periphery of a second side of the outer box frame;
a first reference bar proximately flanking the outer periphery of a third side of the outer box frame; and
a second reference bar proximately flanking the outer periphery of a fourth side of the outer box frame.

### Claim 46 (depends on 45)

The field of a reticle of claim 45, wherein the plurality of needle comb reticle patterns comprises four needle comb reticle patterns, each of which is located near a comer of the rectangular window.

### Claim 47

A needle comb reticle pattern for use in process measurement during semiconductor substrate processing comprising:
a first needle comb reticle subpattern comprising:
a box-in-box feature including a solid inner box having an outer periphery substantially defined by four substantially straight sides and an outer box frame having an inner periphery substantially defined by four inner substantially straight sides and an outer periphery substantially defined by four outer substantially straight sides;
first and second needle combs proximately flanking the outer box frame on two opposite peripheral sides of the outer box frame having needles aligned with an axis connecting the first and second needle combs and the inner box; and
third and fourth needle combs flanking the outer box frame on two other opposite peripheral sides of the outer box frame having needles aligned with an axis connecting the third and fourth needle combs and the inner box; and
a second needle comb reticle subpattern adjacent to a single side of the first needle comb reticle subpattern having substantially identically dimensioned complementary features relative to the first needle comb reticle subpattern.

### Claim 48

A method of characterizing measurements from a needle comb reticle pattern to pattern critical dimension comprising:
generating a focus-exposure matrix;
defining a process window for actual pattern critical dimension;
defining an equivalent window for a needle comb reticle mark wherein the needle comb reticle mark includes a box-in-box feature including:
a solid inner box having an outer periphery substantially defined by four substantially straight sides and an outer box frame having an inner periphery substantially defined by four inner substantially straight sides and an outer periphery substantially defined by four outer substantially straight sides;
wherein the outer box frame surrounds the inner box and a gap separates the outer periphery of the inner box and inner periphery of the outer box frame;
wherein the gap between the outer periphery of the inner box and the inner periphery of the outer box frame is substantially uniform along each side of the inner box and outer box frame;
a first needle comb proximately flanking the outer periphery of a first side of the outer box frame;
a second needle comb proximately flanking the outer periphery of a second side of the outer box frame;
determining whether the needle comb reticle mark is within the equivalent window; and
if the needle comb reticle mark is inside the equivalent window, then critical dimension will also be within the process window, indicating process is in control; and
if the needle comb reticle mark is outside the equivalent window, then critical dimension will also be outside the process window, indicating the process needs adjustment.
