# US 5,701,801 A · Mechanically redundant actuator assembly > Agents: this data is available as JSON from the patentgrep API and MCP server — see https://patentgrep.com/llms.txt - Number: US 5,701,801 A - Document ID: US5701801A - Status: Granted - Kind: A - Application number: 08/544,952 - Filed: 1995-10-18 - Granted: 1997-12-30 - Earliest claimed: 1995-10-18 - Assignees: McDonnell Douglas Corporation - Inventors: Wilfred E. Boehringer; Teunes Verhoeven; William V. Hutz - Web page: https://patentgrep.com/patent/US5701801A ## CPC - B64C 13/42: having duplication or stand-by provisions - F15B 20/00: Safety arrangements for fluid actuator systems; Applications of safety devices in fluid actuator systems; Emergency measures for fluid actuator systems - B64C: AEROPLANES; HELICOPTERS - F15B: SYSTEMS ACTING BY MEANS OF FLUIDS IN GENERAL; FLUID-PRESSURE ACTUATORS, e.g. SERVOMOTORS; DETAILS OF FLUID-PRESSURE SYSTEMS, NOT OTHERWISE PROVIDED FOR ## Abstract In a mechanically redundant actuator system, the actuator has a structurally redundant members for attaching it between a stationary anchor point to a movable control surface. Specifically the actuator consists of a cylinder body, a double action piston with a piston rod attached to the control surface at one end and a swivel bar at the other end. Single or multiple tie rods are attached between the swivel bar and the movable control surface. Each tie rod can withstand one half the load of the piston rod. Also, trunnion links attach the cylinder body to the structure. Each trunnion links can withstand the full limit load with or without any load factors. The trunnion fittings can be any configuration that provides a structural reaction, and provides a dual load path and freedom of movement in at least two axes. At least two of these actuator units are required per surface. Also, a dual tandem control valve with a hydraulic compensator for each actuator is required. With this arrangement, the failure modes allowable are latent mechanical failure of the mechanical links in addition to the total failure of any actuator in combination with any inoperative condition in the hydraulic power system. Various arrangements of the basic system are contemplated within the scope of this invention and include the tail end of each actuator's piston rod connected to a swivel beam. This beam is also connected to the control surface with one or more connecting rods. Each actuator is supported by a trunnion, whether directly connected to the cylinder or otherwise and the trunnion must be able to react to full surface hinge moments. ## Claims ### Claim 1 A mechanically redundant actuator comprising: a. at least one actuator body, having an elongated channel along at least one axis of said body, b. a piston received by said channel, said piston longitudinally displaceable along the longitudinal axis of said channel in said actuator body, c. a connector attaching said actuator body to an anchor point, d. a piston rod attached to said piston of greater length than said channel and disposed substantially parallel to the longitudinal axis of said channel, e. a connector attaching one end of said piston rod to a movable surface, f. a cross bar connected to the end of said piston rod opposite said movable surface, g. a plurality of tie rods rotatably connected at one end to said cross bar, and h. a connector attaching said plurality of tie rods, at an end opposite said cross bar, to said movable surface. ### Claim 2 (depends on 1) A mechanically redundant actuator as described in claim 1 wherein the cylinder body is provided with an end cap which encloses one side of said channel and a supporting piston gland which encloses said piston and wherein said end cap and gland each have openings for receiving an end of the piston rod and permit each such end to extend through said respective end cap and gland. ### Claim 3 (depends on 2) A mechanically redundant actuator as described in claim 2 wherein said means for anchoring said actuator body to a stationary surface comprises: a. at least one trunnion link rotatably attached to the stationary surface at one end and adapted to permit rotation along a first axis transverse to the axis of said piston rod, and rotatably attached to said actuator body at the other end and adapted to permit rotation along an axis transverse to the axis of said piston rod and transverse to said first axis. ### Claim 4 (depends on 3) A mechanically redundant actuator as described in claim 3 wherein there are at least two trunnion links each attached to said stationary surface at one end and attached on opposite sides to said actuator body at the other end. ### Claim 5 (depends on 3) A mechanically redundant actuator as described in claim 3 wherein each trunnion link is equal in strength to the piston rod, whereby should the piston rod fracture between the movable surface and the actuator body, the actuator will continue to operate and if any trunnion link should fracture between the stationary surface and the actuator body, the actuator will continue to operate. ### Claim 6 (depends on 5) A mechanically redundant actuator as described in claim 5 wherein the piston rod is greater in strength than any tie rod. ### Claim 7 A mechanically redundant actuator system which includes at least one mechanically redundant actuator comprising: a. at least one actuator body, having an elongated channel along at least one axis of said body, b. a piston received by said channel, said piston longitudinally displaceable along the longitudinal axis of said channel in said actuator body, c. means for anchoring said actuator body to an anchor point, d. a piston rod attached to said piston of greater length than said channel and disposed substantially parallel to the longitudinal axis of said channel, e. means for anchoring one end of said piston rod to a movable surface, f. a cross bar connected to the end of said piston rod opposite said movable surface, g. a plurality of tie rods rotatably connected at one end to said cross bar, and h. means for anchoring said plurality of tie rods, at an end opposite said cross bar, to said movable surface. ### Claim 8 (depends on 7) A mechanically redundant actuator system as described in claim 7 wherein the cylinder body is provided with an end cap which encloses said channel with an integral end and a gland which encloses said piston and wherein said end cap and a gland each have openings for receiving an end of the piston rod and permit each such end to extend through said respective end caps. ### Claim 9 (depends on 8) A mechanically redundant actuator system as described in claim 8 wherein said means for anchoring said actuator body to a stationary surface comprises: a. at least one trunnion link rotatably attached to the stationary surface at one end and adapted to permit rotation along a first axis transverse to the axis of said piston rod, and rotatably attached to said actuator body at the other end and adapted to permit rotation along an axis transverse to the axis of said piston rod and transverse to said first axis. ### Claim 10 (depends on 9) A mechanically redundant actuator system as described in claim 9 wherein there are at least two trunnion links each attached to said stationary surface at one end and attached on opposite sides to said actuator body at the other end. ### Claim 11 (depends on 10) A mechanically redundant actuator system as described in claim 10 wherein the strength of the trunnion links in the aggregate is at least substantially equal in strength to the piston rod, whereby should the piston rod fracture between the movable surface and the actuator body, the actuator will continue to operate and if any trunnion link should fracture between the stationary surface and the actuator body, the actuator will continue to operate. ### Claim 12 (depends on 11) A mechanically redundant actuator system as described in claim 11 wherein there are at least two actuators attached in parallel to said stationary surface and said movable surface. ### Claim 13 (depends on 12) A mechanically redundant actuator system as described in claim 12 wherein the piston rod is greater in strength than any tie rod. ### Claim 14 A mechanically redundant actuator system which includes at least one mechanically redundant actuator comprising: a. at least one actuator body, having an elongated channel along at least one axis of said body, b. a piston received by said channel, said piston longitudinally displaceable along the longitudinal axis of said channel in said actuator body, c. at east one trunnion link rotatably attached to an anchor point at one end and adapted to permit rotation along a first axis transverse to the axis of said piston rod, and rotatably attached to said actuator body at the other end and adapted to permit rotation along an axis transverse to the axis of said piston rod and transverse said first axis. ### Claim 15 (depends on 14) A mechanically redundant actuator system as described in claim 14 wherein there are at least two trunnion links each attached to said stationary surface at one end and attached on opposite sides to said actuator body at the other end. ### Claim 16 (depends on 14) A mechanically redundant actuator system as described in claim 14 wherein there are at least two actuators attached in parallel to said stationary surface and said movable surface. ### Claim 17 (depends on 16) A mechanically redundant actuator system as described in claim 16 further comprising a tandem valve for operating said actuators and a compensator for each valve of said tandem valve, whereby on operation said tandem valve will compensate for force contention between said hydraulic actuators through said compensators. ### Claim 18 (depends on 15) A mechanically redundant actuator system as described in claim 15 wherein the strength of the trunnion links in the aggregate is at least substantially equal in strength to the piston rod, whereby should the piston rod fracture between the movable surface and the actuator body, the actuator will continue to operate and if any trunnion link should fracture between the stationary surface and the actuator body, the actuator will continue to operate.