A process for preserving a food product against a gram negative psychotropic bacteria comprising combining with a food product that is subject to spoilage by growth of a gram negative psychotropic bacteria, a metabolite-containing material that is produced by a culture of Propionibacterium and that contains a metabolite, other than propionic acid, the material being present in an amount sufficient that the metabolite inhibits the growth of gram negative psychotropic bacteria and that the material provides less than 0.02% propionic acid in the food product such that there is insufficient propionic acid per se to inhibit the growth of gram negative psychotropic bacteria.