A method of testing for and at least reducing the possibility of the occurrence of cracking, spalling or like defects in the exterior cylindrical surface of a cylindrical steel rolling mill roll, the method including the steps of:
- a. determining the rate of change of hardness along a reference direction for at least a part of the roll surface to find locations therealong having rates of change greater than a predetermined maximum value known to foreshadow the possibility of the occurrence of defects for the roll and the conditions to which it is subjected in operation, and
- b. when the rate of change of hardness along the reference direction exceeds the said maximum value removing material from the roll including the tested surface until the rate of change of hardness is below another predetermined maximum value.