A method of determining whether a patient suffering from cancer will achieve a response with an immune checkpoint inhibitor and treating the patient, comprising the steps of i) isolating a population of immune effector cells from a biological sample obtained from the patient, ii) contacting the population of immune effector cells with a population of target cells for a sufficient period of time and under conditions suitable for allowing the population of immune effector cells to induce a cytotoxic response in the presence of the immune checkpoint inhibitor, iii) measuring the reparative membrane turnover level in the population of target cells, and when the reparative membrane turnover level determined at step iii) is higher than the reparative membrane turnover level measured in the absence of the immune checkpoint inhibitor, then iv) treating the patient with the immune checkpoint inhibitor.