# US 2021/0343374 A1 · Monte carlo method for the automated and highly efficient calculation of kinetic data of chemical reactions

> Agents: this data is available as JSON from the patentgrep API and MCP server — see https://patentgrep.com/llms.txt

- Number: US 2021/0343374 A1
- Document ID: US20210343374A1
- Status: Published application
- Kind: A1
- Application number: 17/284,548
- Filed: 2019-10-16
- Published: 2021-11-04
- Earliest claimed: 2018-10-18
- Assignees: Covestro Intellectual Property GmbH & Co. KG
- Applicants: Covestro Intellectual Property GmbH & Co. KG
- Inventors: Matthias Leven; Jose Gamez; Kunibert Rehm
- Web page: https://patentgrep.com/patent/US20210343374A1

## CPC

- G16C 10/00: Computational theoretical chemistry, i.e. ICT specially adapted for theoretical aspects of quantum chemistry, molecular mechanics, molecular dynamics or the like
- G16C 20/10: Analysis or design of chemical reactions, syntheses or processes
- G16C: COMPUTATIONAL CHEMISTRY; CHEMOINFORMATICS; COMPUTATIONAL MATERIALS SCIENCE

## Abstract

The present invention relates to a computer-implemented method for calculating transition states of a chemical reaction, and to a system for data processing comprising means for carrying out the method, to a computer program comprising instructions which cause a computer to execute the method and to the use of the computer program.

## Claims

### Claim 1

A computer-implemented method of calculating transition states of a chemical reaction, comprising the steps of:
A Generating a starting geometry by
A1 providing the three-dimensional representation of at least one molecule at ground state energy,
A2 selecting at least one bond of the at least one molecule and selecting a length of the bond, where the selected length does not correspond to the length of the bond at ground state energy of the molecule, such that a starting geometry for the chemical reaction is obtained,
A3 representing the starting geometry in three dimensions in Cartesian and/or internal coordinates, and
B Ascertaining an optimized starting geometry
B1 defining a function space encompassing the at least one bond from step A2 and the atoms joined by this bond,
B2 optimizing the geometry of the function space selected in step B1 by means of a quantum-chemical method and with the boundary condition that the length of the at least one bond selected in step A2 is kept constant, such that an optimized starting geometry is obtained,
B3 ascertaining the gradient norm B3 for the optimized starting geometry, where the gradient norm is obtained via the first derivative of a function E=f(x) of the quantum-chemical method and, with E=total energy of the optimized starting geometry and x=nuclear coordinates of the molecule in the optimized starting geometry, and
B4.1 when the gradient norm B3 ∇ is 0≤∇≤0.03 Eh a0−1, classifying the optimized starting geometry as a precursor to the transition state of the chemical reaction and continuing the method with step D1, or
B4.2 when the gradient norm B3 ∇ is >0.03 Eh a0−1, ascertaining the precursor to the transition state of the chemical reaction proceeding from the optimized starting geometry by a method comprising the following steps:
C Ascertaining the precursor to the transition state of the chemical reaction by
C1 varying the optimized starting geometry using a Monte Carlo algorithm,
C1.1 wherein at least one atom from the function space selected in step B1 is selected at random,
C1.2 wherein a vector for a deflection of the atom chosen in step C1 is selected at random, weighting the randomly chosen magnitude of the vector by the gradient norm B3,
C1.3 wherein the atom selected in step C1.1 is deflected from the position of the atom in the optimized starting geometry using the vector from step C1.2, so as to obtain a precursor to a transition state of the chemical reaction,
C2 optimizing the geometry of the precursor to the transition state by means of the quantum-chemical method and with the boundary condition that the at least one bond from step A2 has the length that was ascertained in step C3,
C3 ascertaining the gradient norm C3 for the precursor to the transition state from step C2, where the gradient norm is obtained via the first derivative of the function E=f(x) of the quantum-chemical method and, with E=total energy of the precursor to the transition state and x=nuclear coordinates of the molecule in the precursor to the transition state, and
C4.1 when the gradient norm C3 ∇ is 0≤∇≤0.03 Eh a0−1, continuing the method with step D1, or
C4.2 when the gradient norm C3∇>0.03 Eh a0−1, repeating steps C1 to C3 until a gradient norm C3 ∇ of 0≤∇≤0.03 Eh a0−1 is obtained, wherein
(a) if steps C1 to C3 have been performed once, the geometry of the precursor to the transition state is varied in step C1 when the value of its gradient norm C3 is lower than the value of the gradient norm B3 of the optimized starting geometry, or
(b) if steps C1 to C3 have been performed more than once, the geometry of the optimized starting geometry or that precursor to the transition state from the preceding repetitions that has the lowest value for the gradient norm C3 or B3 compared to all the gradient norms C3 and B3 previously obtained is varied in step C1,
D Ascertaining the transition state by
D1 varying the precursor from step C4.1 or the precursor from step B4.1 by performing the following steps for one atom within the function space defined in B1:
D1.1 selecting an atom from the function space selected in step B1,
D1.2 selecting a vector for a deflection of the atom chosen in step D1.1,
D1.3 deflecting the atom selected in step D1.1 using the vector from step D1.2 from its position in the precursor, wherein the position is deflected once by the positive value of the magnitude of the vector and once by the negative value of the magnitude of the vector, such that two deflected precursors are obtained when steps D1.1 to D1.3 are conducted,
D2 optimizing the geometry of the two deflected precursors from step D1 by means of the quantum-chemical method under the constraint that the bond distances obtained in D1 are kept constant, such that two optimized precursors (i) and (ii) are obtained,
D3 calculating the energy of the two optimized precursors (i) and (ii) from step D2 by means of the quantum-chemical method,
D4 comparing the energy values of the two optimized precursors with the value of the gradient norm C3 or B3 of the precursor that was used in step D1,
D4.1. if the energy value of the optimized precursor (i) and the energy value of the optimized precursor (ii) are each smaller than the energy value C3 or B3 of the precursor that was used in step D1, classifying the precursor that was used in step D1 as the transition state,
D4.2. if the energy value of the optimized precursor (i) or the energy value of the optimized precursor (ii) is not smaller than the energy value C3 or B3 of the precursor that was used in step D1, repeating the method from step C1.

### Claim 2 (depends on 1)

The method of claim 1, wherein the quantum-chemical method from steps B2, B3, C2, C3, D2 and D3 is a semiempirical method, density functional theory method or an approximation of the Schrödinger equation.

### Claim 3 (depends on 1)

The method of claim 1, wherein the chemical reaction is a synthesis selected from the group consisting of polymer syntheses, syntheses of monomers for polymerization reactions, industrially required commodity chemicals, platform chemicals, additives, surfactants and active pharmacological ingredients.

### Claim 4 (depends on 1)

The method of claim 1, wherein in step A1, at least two molecules I and II are provided and wherein in step A2, alternatively or additionally to the at least one bond, at least one distance between at least one atom from molecule I and at least one atom from molecule II and the length of the at least one distance is also selected, where the length of the distance is especially not more than 230 pm.

### Claim 5 (depends on 4)

The method of claim 4, wherein molecule I is a catalyst for the chemical reaction, and molecule II is a reactant in the chemical reaction, and wherein molecule I has a size of 2 to 1000 atoms and molecules II has a size of 2 to 1000 atoms, where the sum total of the atoms from molecule I and from molecule II is especially to be more than 100 atoms.

### Claim 6 (depends on 1)

The method claim 1, wherein information as to the transition state ascertained in step D.1 or the equilibrium state ascertained in step D.2 is communicated to a user.

### Claim 7 (depends on 1)

The method of claim 1, wherein information as to the transition state ascertained in step D.1 or the equilibrium state ascertained in step D.2 is received by a user.

### Claim 8 (depends on 5)

The method of claim 5, wherein the molecule I is synthesized after step D.1 or after step D.2.

### Claim 9 (depends on 5)

The method of claim 5, wherein after step D.1 or after step D.2, by a chemical reaction is performed with molecule I as a catalyst.

### Claim 10 (depends on 5)

The method according to of claim 5, wherein after step D.1 or after step D.2, a chemical reaction is performed with molecule II as a co-reactant.

### Claim 11

A system for data processing, comprising means of executing a method comprising the steps of:
A Generating a starting geometry by
A1 providing the three-dimensional representation of at least one molecule at ground state energy,
A2 selecting at least one bond of the at least one molecule and selecting a length of the bond, where the selected length does not correspond to the length of the bond at ground state energy of the molecule, such that a starting geometry for the chemical reaction is obtained,
A3 representing the starting geometry in three dimensions in Cartesian and/or internal coordinates, and
B Ascertaining an optimized starting geometry
B1 defining a function space encompassing the at least one bond from step A2 and the atoms joined by this bond,
B2 optimizing the geometry of the function space selected in step B1 by means of a quantum-chemical method and with the boundary condition that the length of the at least one bond selected in step A2 is kept constant, such that an optimized starting geometry is obtained,
B3 ascertaining the gradient norm B3 for the optimized starting geometry, where the gradient norm is obtained via the first derivative of a function E=f(x) of the quantum-chemical method and, with E=total energy of the optimized starting geometry and x=nuclear coordinates of the molecule in the optimized starting geometry, and
B4.1 when the gradient norm B3 ∇ is 0≤∇≤0.03 Eh a0−1, classifying the optimized starting geometry as a precursor to the transition state of the chemical reaction and continuing the method with step D1, or
B4.2 when the gradient norm B3 ∇ is >0.03 Eh a0−1, ascertaining the precursor to the transition state of the chemical reaction proceeding from the optimized starting geometry by a method comprising the following steps:
C Ascertaining the precursor to the transition state of the chemical reaction
C1 varying the optimized starting geometry using a Monte Carlo algorithm,
C1.1 wherein at least one atom from the function space selected in step B1 is selected at random,
C1.2 wherein a vector for a deflection of the atom chosen in step C1 is selected at random, weighting the randomly chosen magnitude of the vector by the gradient norm B3,
C1.3 wherein the atom selected in step C1.1 is deflected from the position of the atom in the optimized starting geometry using the vector from step C1.2, so as to obtain a precursor to a transition state of the chemical reaction,
C2 optimizing the geometry of the precursor to the transition state by means of the quantum-chemical method and with the boundary condition that the at least one bond from step A2 has the length that was ascertained in step C3,
C3 ascertaining the gradient norm C3 for the precursor to the transition state from step C2, where the gradient norm is obtained via the first derivative of the function E=f(x) of the quantum-chemical method and, with E=total energy of the precursor to the transition state and x=nuclear coordinates of the molecule in the precursor to the transition state, and
C4.1 when the gradient norm C3 ∇ is 0≤∇≤0.03 Eh a0−1, continuing the method with step D1, or
C4.2 when the gradient norm C3∇>0.03 Eh a0−1 Eh ahd 0−1, repeating steps C1 to C3 until a gradient norm C3 V of 0≤∇≤0.03 Eh a0−1 is obtained, wherein
(a) if steps C1 to C3 have been performed once, the geometry of the precursor to the transition state is varied in step C1 when the value of its gradient norm C3 is lower than the value of the gradient norm B3 of the optimized starting geometry, or
(b) if steps C1 to C3 have been performed more than once, the geometry of the optimized starting geometry or that precursor to the transition state from the preceding repetitions that has the lowest value for the gradient norm C3 or B3 compared to all the gradient norms C3 and B3 previously obtained is varied in step C1,
D Ascertaining the transition state by
D1 varying the precursor from step C4.1 or the precursor from step B4.1 by performing the following steps for one atom within the function space defined in B1; by
D1.1 selecting an atom from the function space selected in step B1,
D1.2 selecting a vector for a deflection of the atom chosen in step D1.1, and
D1.3 deflecting the atom selected in step D1.1 using the vector from step D1.2 from its position in the precursor, wherein the position is deflected once by the positive value of the magnitude of the vector and once by the negative value of the magnitude of the vector, such that two deflected precursors are obtained when steps D1.1 to D1.3 are conducted,
D2 optimizing the geometry of the two deflected precursors from step D1 by means of the quantum-chemical method under the constraint that the bond distances obtained in D1 are kept constant, such that two optimized precursors (i) and (ii) are obtained,
D3 calculating the energy of the two optimized precursors (i) and (ii) from step D2 by means of the quantum-chemical method,
D4 comparing the energy values of the two optimized precursors with the energy value C3 or B3 of the precursor that was used in step D1,
D4.1. if the energy value of the optimized precursor (i) and the energy value of the optimized precursor (ii) are each smaller than the energy value C3 or B3 of the precursor that was used in step D1, classifying the precursor that was used in step D1 as the transition state,
D4.2. if the energy value of the optimized precursor (i) or the energy value of the optimized precursor (ii) is not smaller than the energy value C3 or B3 of the precursor that was used in step D1, repeating the method from step C1.

### Claim at position 12

12-14. (canceled)

### Claim 15 (depends on 11)

The system of claim 11, wherein the quantum-chemical method from steps B2, B3, C2, C3, D2 and D3 is a semiempirical method, density functional theory method or an approximation of the Schrödinger equation.

### Claim 16 (depends on 11)

The system of claim 11, wherein the chemical reaction is a synthesis selected from the group consisting of polymer syntheses, syntheses of monomers for polymerization reactions, industrially required commodity chemicals, platform chemicals, additives, surfactants and active pharmacological ingredients.

### Claim 17 (depends on 11)

The system of claim 11, wherein in step A1, at least two molecules I and II are provided and wherein in step A2, alternatively or additionally to the at least one bond, at least one distance between at least one atom from molecule I and at least one atom from molecule II and the length of the at least one distance is also selected, where the length of the distance is especially not more than 230 pm.

### Claim 18 (depends on 17)

The system of claim 17, wherein molecule I is a catalyst for the chemical reaction, and molecule II is a reactant in the chemical reaction, and wherein molecule I has a size of 2 to 1000 atoms and molecule II has a size of 2 to 1000 atoms, where the sum total of the atoms from molecule I and from molecule II is especially to be more than 100 atoms.

### Claim 19 (depends on 11)

The system of claim 11, wherein information as to the transition state ascertained in step D.1 or the equilibrium state ascertained in step D.2 is communicated to a user.

### Claim 20 (depends on 11)

The system of claim 11, wherein information as to the transition state ascertained in step D.1 or the equilibrium state ascertained in step D.2 is received by a user.

### Claim 21 (depends on 18)

The system of claim 18, wherein the molecule I is synthesized after step D.1 or after step D.2.

### Claim 22 (depends on 18)

The system of claim 18, wherein after step D.1 or after step D.2, a chemical reaction is performed with molecule I as a catalyst.

### Claim 23 (depends on 18)

The method of claim 18, wherein after step D.1 or after step D.2, a chemical reaction is performed with molecule II as a co-reactant.
