# US 2021/0341733 A1 · Method and program for predicting bending in optical products

> Agents: this data is available as JSON from the patentgrep API and MCP server — see https://patentgrep.com/llms.txt

- Number: US 2021/0341733 A1
- Document ID: US20210341733A1
- Status: Published application
- Kind: A1
- Application number: 17/305,611
- Filed: 2021-07-12
- Published: 2021-11-04
- Earliest claimed: 2019-01-17
- Assignees: Tokai Optical Co., Ltd.
- Applicants: Tokai Optical Co., Ltd.
- Inventors: Muneo SUGIURA; Koichi TAMURA; Takuro YOSHIDA
- Web page: https://patentgrep.com/patent/US20210341733A1

## CPC

- G02B 27/0012: {Optical design, e.g. procedures, algorithms, optimisation routines}
- G02B 1/10: Optical coatings produced by application to, or surface treatment of, optical elements (G02B1/08 takes precedence)
- G06F 30/20: Design optimisation, verification or simulation (optimisation, verification or simulation of circuit designs G06F30/30)
- G06F 2111/10: Numerical modelling
- G02B: OPTICAL ELEMENTS, SYSTEMS OR APPARATUS
- G06F: ELECTRIC DIGITAL DATA PROCESSING (computer systems based on specific computational models G06N)

## Abstract

In the optical product bending prediction method according to the present invention, bending δ of a substrate having a film is predicted by a computer performing calculation (steps S11 to S13) of the following Expressions (A1), (B1), etc., in which a and Td are set as fitting parameters and have been optimized in each coating condition using a plurality of samples. Here, σint is intrinsic stress, Ef is a Young's modulus of a multilayer film, vf is a Poisson's ratio of the multilayer film, αf is a linear coefficient expansion of the multilayer film, αs is a linear coefficient expansion of the substrate, T is a room temperature, d is a film thickness, b is a substrate thickness, l is a radius of the substrate, Es is a Young's modulus of the substrate, and vs is a Poisson's ratio of the substrate. [ Mathematical ⁢ ⁢ 1 ] δ = 3 ⁢ l 2 b 2 ⁢ ( 1 - v s E s ) ⁢ d ⁢ ⁢ σ ( A1 ) σ = a ⁢ ⁢ σ int + ( α s - α f ) ⁢ ( E f 1 - v f ) ⁢ ( T - T d ) ( B1 )

## Claims

### Claim 1

An optical product bending prediction method of predicting bending δ of a substrate having a film by a computer performing calculation of the following Expressions (A1) to (I) in which a is set as a first fitting parameter and Td is set as a second fitting parameter, and these parameters have been optimized in each coating condition using a plurality of samples,
[
Mathematical
⁢
⁢
1
]
δ
=
3
⁢
l
2
b
2
⁢
(
1
-
v
s
E
s
)
⁢
d
⁢
⁢
σ
(
A1
)
σ
=
a
⁢
⁢
σ
i
⁢
n
⁢
C
+
(
α
s
-
α
f
)
⁢
(
E
f
1
-
v
f
)
⁢
(
T
-
T
a
)
(
B1
)
d
=
d
H
+
d
L
(
C
)
σ
int
=
d
~
H
⁢
σ
H
+
d
~
L
⁢
σ
L
(
D
)
d
~
H
=
d
H
/
d
(
E
)
d
~
L
=
d
L
/
d
(
F
)
E
f
=
d
~
H
⁢
E
H
+
d
~
L
⁢
E
L
(
G
)
v
f
=
d
~
H
⁢
v
H
+
d
~
L
⁢
v
L
(
H
)
α
r
=
d
~
H
⁢
a
H
+
d
~
L
⁢
α
L
(
I
)
where σint is intrinsic stress, Ef is a Young's modulus of a multilayer film, EH is a Young's modulus of a high refractive index layer, EL is a Young's modulus of a low refractive index layer, αf is a Poisson's ratio of the multilayer film, vH is a Poisson's ratio of the high refractive index layer, vL is a Poisson's ratio of the low refractive index layer, αf is a coefficient of linear expansion of the multilayer film, αH is a coefficient of linear expansion of the high refractive index layer, αL is a coefficient of linear expansion of the low refractive index layer, αs is a coefficient of linear expansion of the substrate, T is a room temperature, d is a film thickness, b is a thickness of the substrate, 1 is a radius of the substrate, Es is a Young's modulus of the substrate, vs is a Poisson's ratio of the substrate, dr′ is a total film thickness of the high refractive index layer, dL is a total film thickness of the low refractive index layer, σH is intrinsic stress of the high refractive index layer, and σL is intrinsic stress of the low refractive index layer.

### Claim 2

An optical product bending prediction method of predicting bending δ of a substrate having a film by a computer performing calculation of the following Expressions (A1) to (I) in which aH is set as a first primary fitting parameter, aL is set as a first secondary fitting parameter, and Td is set as a second fitting parameter, and these parameters have been optimized in each coating condition using a plurality of samples,
[
Mathematical
⁢
⁢
2
]
δ
=
3
⁢
l
2
b
2
⁢
(
1
-
v
s
E
s
)
⁢
d
⁢
⁢
σ
(
A1
)
σ
=
a
H
⁢
σ
H
⁢
d
~
H
+
a
L
⁢
σ
L
⁢
d
~
L
+
(
α
s
-
a
f
)
⁢
(
E
f
1
-
v
f
)
⁢
(
T
-
T
d
)
(
B2
)
d
=
d
H
+
d
L
(
C
)
d
˜
H
=
d
H
/
d
(
E
)
d
~
L
=
d
L
/
d
(
F
)
E
f
=
d
~
H
⁢
E
H
+
d
~
L
⁢
E
L
(
G
)
v
f
=
d
~
H
⁢
v
H
+
d
~
L
⁢
v
L
(
H
)
α
f
=
d
~
H
⁢
α
H
+
d
~
L
⁢
α
L
(
I
)
where σint is intrinsic stress, Ef is a Young's modulus of a multilayer film, EH is a Young's modulus of a high refractive index layer, EL is a Young's modulus of a low refractive index layer, vf is a Poisson's ratio of the multilayer film, vH is a Poisson's ratio of the high refractive index layer, vf is a Poisson's ratio of the low refractive index layer, αf is a coefficient of linear expansion of the multilayer film, αH is a coefficient of linear expansion of the high refractive index layer, αL is a coefficient of linear expansion of the low refractive index layer, αs is a coefficient of linear expansion of the substrate, T is a room temperature, d is a film thickness, b is a thickness of the substrate, l is a radius of the substrate, Es is a Young's modulus of the substrate, vs is a Poisson's ratio of the substrate, dH is a total film thickness of the high refractive index layer, dL is a total film thickness of the low refractive index layer, σH is intrinsic stress of the high refractive index layer, and σL is intrinsic stress of the low refractive index layer.

### Claim 3 (depends on 1)

The optical product bending prediction method according to claim 1, wherein
the Expression (A1) is replaced with the following Expression (A2) in which δs is set as a third fitting parameter, and
the bending δ of the substrate having the film is predicted by the computer performing calculation of the Expressions (A2) to (I) for which optimization has been performed in each coating condition using a plurality of samples.
[
Mathematical
⁢
⁢
3
]
δ
=
3
⁢
l
2
b
2
⁢
(
1
-
v
s
E
s
)
⁢
d
⁢
⁢
σ
+
δ
s
(
A2
)

### Claim 4 (depends on 2)

The optical product bending prediction method according to claim 2, wherein
the Expression (A1) is replaced with the following Expression (A2) in which δs is set as a third fitting parameter, and
the bending δ of the substrate having the film is predicted by the computer performing calculation of the Expressions (A2) to (I) for which optimization has been performed in each coating condition using a plurality of samples.
[
Mathematical
⁢
⁢
3
]
δ
=
3
⁢
l
2
b
2
⁢
(
1
-
v
s
E
s
)
⁢
d
⁢
⁢
σ
+
δ
s
(
A2
)

### Claim 5 (depends on 1)

The optical product bending prediction method according to claim 1, wherein
the Expression (A1) is replaced with the following Expression (A3) including bending δ0 of the substrate on which the film has not been formed yet, and
the bending δ of the substrate having the film is predicted by the computer performing calculation of the Expressions (A3) to (I) for which optimization has been performed in each coating condition using a plurality of samples.
[
Mathematical
⁢
⁢
4
]
δ
=
3
⁢
l
2
b
2
⁢
(
1
-
v
s
E
s
)
⁢
d
⁢
⁢
σ
+
δ
0
(
A3
)

### Claim 6 (depends on 2)

The optical product bending prediction method according to claim 2, wherein
the Expression (A1) is replaced with the following Expression (A3) including bending δ0 of the substrate on which the film has not been formed yet, and
the bending δ of the substrate having the film is predicted by the computer performing calculation of the Expressions (A3) to (I) for which optimization has been performed in each coating condition using a plurality of samples.
[
Mathematical
⁢
⁢
4
]
δ
=
3
⁢
l
2
b
2
⁢
(
1
-
v
s
E
s
)
⁢
d
⁢
⁢
σ
+
δ
0
(
A3
)

### Claim 7 (depends on 1)

The optical product bending prediction method according to claim 1, wherein
the Expression (A1) is replaced with the following Expression (A4) including a third fitting parameter δs and bending δ0 of the substrate on which the film has not been formed yet, and
the bending δ of the substrate having the film is predicted by the computer performing calculation of the Expressions (A4) to (I) for which optimization has been performed in each coating condition using a plurality of samples.
[
Mathematical
⁢
⁢
5
]
δ
=
3
⁢
l
2
b
2
⁢
(
1
-
v
s
E
s
)
⁢
d
⁢
⁢
σ
+
δ
0
+
δ
s
(
A4
)

### Claim 8 (depends on 2)

The optical product bending prediction method according to claim 2, wherein
the Expression (A1) is replaced with the following Expression (A4) including a third fitting parameter δs and bending δ0 of the substrate on which the film has not been formed yet, and
the bending δ of the substrate having the film is predicted by the computer performing calculation of the Expressions (A4) to (I) for which optimization has been performed in each coating condition using a plurality of samples.
[
Mathematical
⁢
⁢
5
]
δ
=
3
⁢
l
2
b
2
⁢
(
1
-
v
s
E
s
)
⁢
d
⁢
σ
+
δ
0
+
δ
s
(
A4
)

### Claim 9

An optical product bending prediction program configured to form, through execution thereof by a computer, control means capable of referring to storage of the following Expressions (A1) to (I) in which a is set as a first fitting parameter and Td is set as a second fitting parameter, and these parameters have been optimized in each coating condition using a plurality of samples, the control means being configured to predict bending δ of a substrate having a film through calculation of the Expressions (A1) to (I),
[
Mathematical
⁢
⁢
6
]
δ
=
3
⁢
l
2
b
2
⁢
(
1
-
v
s
E
s
)
⁢
d
⁢
⁢
σ
(
A1
)
σ
=
a
⁢
⁢
σ
int
+
(
α
s
-
a
f
)
⁢
(
E
f
1
-
v
f
)
⁢
(
T
-
T
d
)
(
B1
)
d
=
d
H
+
d
L
(
C
)
σ
i
⁢
n
⁢
t
=
d
~
H
⁢
σ
H
+
d
~
L
⁢
σ
L
(
D
)
d
~
H
=
d
H
/
d
(
E
)
d
~
L
=
d
L
/
d
(
F
)
E
f
=
d
~
H
⁢
E
H
+
d
~
L
⁢
E
L
(
G
)
v
f
=
d
~
H
⁢
v
H
+
d
~
L
⁢
v
L
(
H
)
α
f
=
d
~
H
⁢
α
H
+
d
~
L
⁢
α
L
(
I
)
where σint is intrinsic stress, Ef is a Young's modulus of a multilayer film, EH is a Young's modulus of a high refractive index layer, EL is a Young's modulus of a low refractive index layer, vf is a Poisson's ratio of the multilayer film, vH is a Poisson's ratio of the high refractive index layer, vL is a Poisson's ratio of the low refractive index layer, αf is a coefficient of linear expansion of the multilayer film, αH is a coefficient of linear expansion of the high refractive index layer, αL is a coefficient of linear expansion of the low refractive index layer, αs is a coefficient of linear expansion of the substrate, T is a room temperature, d is a film thickness, b is a thickness of the substrate, 1 is a radius of the substrate, Es is a Young's modulus of the substrate, vs is a Poisson's ratio of the substrate, dH is a total film thickness of the high refractive index layer, dL is a total film thickness of the low refractive index layer, σH is intrinsic stress of the high refractive index layer, and σL is intrinsic stress of the low refractive index layer.

### Claim 10

An optical product bending prediction program configured to form, through execution thereof by a computer, control means capable of referring to storage of the following Expressions (A1) to (I) in which aH is set as a first primary fitting parameter, aL is set as a first secondary fitting parameter, and Td is set as a second fitting parameter, and these parameters have been optimized in each coating condition using a plurality of samples, the control means being configured to predict bending δ of a substrate having a film through calculation of the Expressions (A1) to (I),
[
Mathematical
⁢
⁢
7
]
δ
=
3
⁢
l
2
b
2
⁢
(
1
-
v
s
E
s
)
⁢
d
⁢
⁢
σ
(
A1
)
σ
=
a
H
⁢
σ
H
⁢
d
~
H
+
a
L
⁢
σ
L
⁢
d
~
L
+
(
α
s
-
α
f
)
⁢
(
E
f
1
-
v
f
)
⁢
(
T
-
T
d
)
(
B2
)
d
=
d
H
+
d
L
(
C
)
d
~
H
=
d
H
/
d
(
E
)
d
~
L
=
d
L
/
d
(
F
)
E
f
=
d
~
H
⁢
E
H
+
d
~
L
⁢
E
L
(
G
)
v
f
=
d
~
H
⁢
v
H
+
d
~
L
⁢
v
L
(
H
)
α
f
=
d
~
H
⁢
α
H
+
d
~
L
⁢
α
L
(
I
)
where σint is intrinsic stress, Ef is a Young's modulus of a multilayer film, EH is a Young's modulus of a high refractive index layer, EL is a Young's modulus of a low refractive index layer, vf is a Poisson's ratio of the multilayer film, vH is a Poisson's ratio of the high refractive index layer, vL is a Poisson's ratio of the low refractive index layer, αf is a coefficient of linear expansion of the multilayer film, αH is a coefficient of linear expansion of the high refractive index layer, αL is a coefficient of linear expansion of the low refractive index layer, αs is a coefficient of linear expansion of the substrate, T is a room temperature, d is a film thickness, b is a thickness of the substrate, 1 is a radius of the substrate, Es is a Young's modulus of the substrate, vs is a Poisson's ratio of the substrate, dH is a total film thickness of the high refractive index layer, dL is a total film thickness of the low refractive index layer, σH is intrinsic stress of the high refractive index layer, and σL is intrinsic stress of the low refractive index layer.

### Claim 11 (depends on 9)

The optical product bending prediction program according to claim 9, wherein
the Expression (A1) is replaced with the following Expression (A2) in which δs is set as a third fitting parameter, and
the program is configured to form, through execution thereof by the computer, the control means configured to predict the bending δ of the substrate having the film through calculation of the Expressions (A2) to (I) for which optimization has been performed in each coating condition using a plurality of samples.
[
Mathematical
⁢
⁢
7
]
δ
=
3
⁢
l
2
b
2
⁢
(
1
-
v
s
E
s
)
⁢
d
⁢
σ
+
δ
s
(
A2
)

### Claim 12 (depends on 10)

The optical product bending prediction program according to claim 10, wherein
the Expression (A1) is replaced with the following Expression (A2) in which δs is set as a third fitting parameter, and
the program is configured to form, through execution thereof by the computer, the control means configured to predict the bending δ of the substrate having the film through calculation of the Expressions (A2) to (I) for which optimization has been performed in each coating condition using a plurality of samples.
[
Mathematical
⁢
⁢
8
]
δ
=
3
⁢
l
2
b
2
⁢
(
1
-
v
s
E
s
)
⁢
d
⁢
⁢
σ
+
δ
s
(
A2
)

### Claim 13 (depends on 9)

The optical product bending prediction program according to claim 9, wherein
the Expression (A1) is replaced with the following Expression (A3) including bending δ0 of the substrate on which the film has not been formed yet, and
the program is configured to form, through execution thereof by the computer, the control means configured to predict the bending δ of the substrate having the film through calculation of the Expressions (A3) to (I) for which optimization has been performed in each coating condition using a plurality of samples.
[
Mathematical
⁢
⁢
9
]
δ
=
3
⁢
l
2
b
2
⁢
(
1
-
v
s
E
s
)
⁢
d
⁢
⁢
σ
+
δ
0
(
A3
)

### Claim 14 (depends on 10)

The optical product bending prediction program according to claim 10, wherein
the Expression (A1) is replaced with the following Expression (A3) including bending δ0 of the substrate on which the film has not been formed yet, and
the program is configured to form, through execution thereof by the computer, the control means configured to predict the bending δ of the substrate having the film through calculation of the Expressions (A3) to (I) for which optimization has been performed in each coating condition using a plurality of samples.
[
Mathematical
⁢
⁢
9
]
δ
=
3
⁢
l
2
b
2
⁢
(
1
-
v
s
E
s
)
⁢
d
⁢
⁢
σ
+
δ
0
(
A3
)

### Claim 15 (depends on 9)

The optical product bending prediction program according to claim 9, wherein
the Expression (A1) is replaced with the following Expression (A4) including a third fitting parameter δs and bending δ0 of the substrate on which the film has not been formed yet, and
the program is configured to form, through execution thereof by the computer, the control means configured to predict the bending δ of the substrate having the film through calculation of the Expressions (A4) to (I) for which optimization has been performed in each coating condition using a plurality of samples.
[
Mathematical
⁢
⁢
10
]
δ
=
3
⁢
l
2
b
2
⁢
(
1
-
v
s
E
s
)
⁢
d
⁢
⁢
σ
+
δ
0
+
δ
s
(
A4
)

### Claim 16 (depends on 10)

The optical product bending prediction program according to claim 10, wherein
the Expression (A1) is replaced with the following Expression (A4) including a third fitting parameter δs and bending δ0 of the substrate on which the film has not been formed yet, and
the program is configured to form, through execution thereof by the computer, the control means configured to predict the bending δ of the substrate having the film through calculation of the Expressions (A4) to (I) for which optimization has been performed in each coating condition using a plurality of samples.
[
Mathematical
⁢
⁢
10
]
δ
=
3
⁢
l
2
b
2
⁢
(
1
-
v
s
E
s
)
⁢
d
⁢
⁢
σ
+
δ
0
+
δ
s
(
A4
)
