# US 2021/0241150 A1 · Method for Identifying a Valid Energy State

> Agents: this data is available as JSON from the patentgrep API and MCP server — see https://patentgrep.com/llms.txt

- Number: US 2021/0241150 A1
- Document ID: US20210241150A1
- Status: Published application
- Kind: A1
- Application number: 17/147,879
- Filed: 2021-01-13
- Published: 2021-08-05
- Earliest claimed: 2020-01-14
- Assignees: Rahko Limited
- Applicants: Rahko Limited
- Inventors: Jules Laurent Guy Tilly; Edward Nikolas Grant
- Web page: https://patentgrep.com/patent/US20210241150A1

## CPC

- G06N 3/045: Combinations of networks
- G06N 7/00: Computing arrangements based on specific mathematical models
- G06F 1/022: {Waveform generators, i.e. devices for generating periodical functions of time, e.g. direct digital synthesizers (G06F1/025, G06F1/03 take precedence)}
- G06F 17/16: Matrix or vector computation {, e.g. matrix-matrix or matrix-vector multiplication, matrix factorization (matrix transposition G06F7/78)}
- G06F 17/18: for evaluating statistical data {, e.g. average values, frequency distributions, probability functions, regression analysis (forecasting specially adapted for a specific administrative, business or logistic context G06Q10/04)}
- G06N 3/047: Probabilistic or stochastic networks
- G06N 3/0475: Generative networks
- G06N 5/01: Dynamic search techniques; Heuristics; Dynamic trees; Branch-and-bound
- G06N 10/20: Models of quantum computing, e.g. quantum circuits or universal quantum computers
- G06N 10/60: Quantum algorithms, e.g. based on quantum optimisation, quantum Fourier or Hadamard transforms
- G06N 20/00: Machine learning
- G06N 3/088: Non-supervised learning, e.g. competitive learning
- G06N: COMPUTING ARRANGEMENTS BASED ON SPECIFIC COMPUTATIONAL MODELS
- G06F: ELECTRIC DIGITAL DATA PROCESSING (computer systems based on specific computational models G06N)

## Abstract

A method for identifying an excited energy state of a system of interacting electrons, comprising providing a first quantum circuit defined by a generator function and providing a second quantum circuit defined by a discriminator function. The method comprises optimising the values of the set of parameters θ of the generator function to substantially minimise the energy of the state generated by the first quantum circuit, and to substantially minimise the extent of overlap of the state generated by the first quantum circuit and each known valid state of the system. The method further comprises, cooperatively, training the discriminator function by optimising the value of the set of parameters ϕ of the discriminator function, to train the discriminator function to discriminate between the state generated by the first quantum circuit and each of the known valid states of the system. The optimised values of the set of parameters θ of the generator function correspond to values parametrising the generator function for generating the next excited energy state of the system of interacting electrons.

## Claims

### Claim 1

A method for identifying an excited energy state of a system of interacting electrons, comprising:
providing a first quantum circuit, the first quantum circuit defined by a generator function parameterised by a set of parameters, θ, wherein applying the first quantum circuit to a set of qubits in an initial state generates a state of the system represented by a wavefunction, Ψ;
providing n sets of values θn−1 for the set of parameters, θ, wherein each set of values θn−1 generates an nth valid energy state of the system represented by a wavefunction, Ψn−1, wherein n is one or more;
providing a second quantum circuit, the second quantum circuit defined by a discriminator function parameterised by a set of parameters, ϕ, wherein applying the second quantum circuit to the set of qubits in the state of the system represented by the wavefunction, provides an output representing an extent of overlap of the wavefunction with the wavefunction Ψn−1 of each of the n known valid states of the system;
optimising the values of the set of parameters θ to substantially minimise the energy of the state generated by the first quantum circuit represented by the wavefunction Ψ, and to substantially minimise the extent of overlap of the state generated by the first quantum circuit represented by the wavefunction and each of the n known valid states of the system represented by respective wavefunction Ψn−1; and
cooperatively, training the discriminator function by optimising the value of the set of parameters ϕ to train the discriminator function to discriminate between the wavefunction Ψ of the state generated by the first quantum circuit and the wavefunction Ψn−1 representing each of the n valid states of the system;
wherein the optimised values of the set of parameters θ correspond to a set of values θn parametrising the generator function defining the first quantum circuit for generating an n+1th valid energy state of the system represented by wavefunction, Ψn, which is an excited energy state of the system of interacting electrons.

### Claim 2 (depends on 1)

The method of claim 1, wherein optimising the value of the set of parameters θ comprises:
generating a trial energy state of the system represented by a wavefunction ΨT by applying, to the set of qubits in an initial state, the first quantum circuit defined by the generator function with the set of parameters θ having trial values θT;
determining an output βT to the second quantum circuit by applying, to the set of qubits in the state generated by the first quantum circuit defined by the generator function with the set of parameters having trial values θT and to an ancilla qubit, the second quantum circuit, and then measuring the ancilla qubit, wherein the second quantum circuit is defined by the discriminator function with the set of parameters ϕ having a set of trial values ϕT;
calculating an energy ET of the trial energy state of the system represented by the wavefunction ΨT;
comparing the output βT of the second quantum circuit to a predefined distinctiveness threshold, Td;
wherein if the output βT to the second quantum circuit is not within a predefined interval of values representing the distinctiveness threshold, Td; and/or
if the energy ET of the trial energy state of the system represented by the wavefunction ΨT is not substantially at a minima;
then varying the set of trial values θt and repeating the generating, determining, calculating and comparing steps;
or, if the output βT to the second quantum circuit is within the predefined interval of values representing the distinctiveness threshold, Td; and
if the energy ET of the trial energy state of the system represented by the wavefunction ΨT is substantially at a minima;
then identifying the set of values θT as the set of values θn parametrising the generator function defining the first quantum circuit for generating the n+1th valid energy state of the system represented by wavefunction, Ψn, which is the identified excited energy state of the system of interacting electrons.

### Claim 3 (depends on 2)

The method of claim 2, wherein the generating, determining and calculating steps take place at a quantum computer, and the comparing, varying and identifying steps take place at a classical computer.

### Claim 4 (depends on 2)

The method of claim 2, wherein calculating an energy ET of the trial energy state of the system represented by the wavefunction ΨT comprises:
determining the positive-operator valued measurement of the wavefunction ΨT .

### Claim 5 (depends on 2)

The method of claim 2, wherein measuring the ancilla qubit to determine the output βT to the second quantum circuit comprises:
determining an expectation value of a positive-operator valued measurement of the state of the set of qubits and the ancilla qubit after application of the second quantum circuit.

### Claim 6 (depends on 2)

The method of claim 2, wherein the parameters θT are varied based on the output of a cost function parameterised by the energy ET of the trial energy state of the system represented by the wavefunction ΨT and the output βT to the second quantum circuit.

### Claim 7 (depends on 1)

The method of claim 1, wherein training the discriminator function by optimising the value of the set of parameters ϕ comprises:
generating an nth valid energy state of the system represented by the wavefunction, Ψn−1 by applying, to a set of qubits in an initial state, the first quantum circuit defined by the generator function with the set of parameters having values θn−1;
determining an output βV to the second quantum circuit by applying, to the set of qubits in the state generated by the first quantum circuit defined by the generator function with the set of parameters having values θn−1 and to an ancilla qubit, the second quantum circuit, and then measuring the ancilla qubit, wherein the second quantum circuit is defined by the discriminator function with the set of parameters ϕ having a set of trial values ϕT;
comparing the output βV of the second quantum circuit to a predefined similarity threshold, Ts;
wherein if the output βV of the second quantum circuit is not within a predefined interval of values representing the similarity threshold, Ts;
then varying the set of trial values ϕT and repeating the generating, determining and comparing steps.

### Claim 8 (depends on 7)

The method of claim 7, wherein the generating and determining steps take place at a quantum computer, and the comparing and varying steps take place at a classical computer.

### Claim 9 (depends on 7)

The method of claim 7, wherein measuring the ancilla qubit to determine the output βV to the second quantum circuit, comprises:
determining an expectation value of a positive-operator valued measurement of the state of the set of qubits and the ancilla qubit after application of the second quantum circuit.

### Claim 10 (depends on 7)

The method of claims 7, wherein the parameters ϕT are varied based on the output of a cost function parameterised by the output to the second quantum circuit, βV.

### Claim 11 (depends on 1)

The method of claim 1, wherein, prior to providing n sets of values θn−1 for the set of parameters θ, the method further comprises applying a variational quantum eigensolver to identify the set of values, θ0, parametrising the ground energy state of the system which is a first valid energy state of the system and represented by a wavefunction, Ψ0.

### Claim 12

A computing apparatus for identifying an excited energy state of a system of interacting electrons, comprising:
a classical computer; and
a quantum computer comprising a set of qubits, the quantum computer configured to apply a first quantum circuit the first quantum circuit defined by a generator function parameterised by a set of parameters, θ, wherein applying the first quantum circuit to a set of qubits in an initial state generates a state of the system represented by a wavefunction, Ψ, and to apply a second quantum circuit defined by a discriminator function parameterised by a set of parameters, ϕ, wherein applying the second quantum circuit to the set of qubits in a state of the system represented by a wavefunction, Ψ provides an output representing an extent of overlap of the wavefunction Ψ with the wavefunction Ψn−1 of each of the n known valid states of the system, wherein each of the n known valid states of the system are parametrised by a set of values θn−1 for the set of parameters, θ;
wherein the computing apparatus is configured to optimise the values of the set of parameters θ to substantially minimise the energy of the state generated by the first quantum circuit represented by the wavefunction Ψ, and to substantially minimise the extent of overlap of the state generated by the first quantum circuit represented by the wavefunction Ψ and each of the n known valid states of the system represented by respective wavefunction Ψn−1; and
cooperatively, to train the discriminator function by optimising the value of the set of parameters ϕ to train the discriminator function to discriminate between the wavefunction of the state generated by the first quantum circuit and the wavefunction Ψn−1 representing each of the n valid states of the system;
wherein the optimised values of the set of parameters θ correspond to a set of values θn parametrising the generator function defining the first quantum circuit for generating an n+1th valid energy state of the system represented by wavefunction, Ψn, which is an excited energy state of the system of interacting electrons.

### Claim 13 (depends on 12)

The computing apparatus of claim 12, wherein the computing apparatus configured to optimise the values of the set of parameters θ to substantially minimise the energy of the state generated by the first quantum circuit represented by the wavefunction Ψ, and to substantially minimise the extent of overlap of the state generated by the first quantum circuit represented by the wavefunction Ψ and each of the n known valid states of the system represented by respective wavefunction Ψn−1 comprises:
the quantum computer being configured to:
generate a trial energy state of the system represented by a wavefunction ΨT by applying, to the set of qubits in an initial state, the first quantum circuit defined by the generator function with the set of parameters θ having trial values θT;
determine an output βT to the second quantum circuit by applying, to the set of qubits in the state generated by the first quantum circuit defined by the generator function with the set of parameters having trial values θT and to an ancilla qubit, the second quantum circuit, and then measuring the ancilla qubit, wherein the second quantum circuit is defined by the discriminator function with the set of parameters ϕ having a set of trial values ϕT;
calculate an energy ET of the trial energy state of the system represented by the wavefunction ΨT; and
the classical computer being configured to:
compare the output βT of the second quantum circuit to a predefined distinctiveness threshold, Td;
wherein if the output βT to the second quantum circuit is not within a predefined interval of values representing the distinctiveness threshold, Td; and/or
if the energy ET of the trial energy state of the system represented by the wavefunction ΨT is not substantially at a minima;
then vary the set of trial values θT;
or, if the output βT to the second quantum circuit is within the predefined interval of values representing the distinctiveness threshold, Td; and
if the energy ET of the trial energy state of the system represented by the wavefunction ΨT is substantially at a minima;
then identify the set of values θT as the set of values θn parametrising the generator function defining the first quantum circuit for generating the n+1th valid energy state of the system represented by wavefunction, Ψn, which is the identified excited energy state of the system of interacting electrons.

### Claim 14 (depends on 13)

The computing apparatus of claim 13, wherein the quantum computer being configured to calculate an energy ET of the trial energy state of the system represented by the wavefunction ΨT comprises the classical computer being configured to:
determine the positive-operator valued measurement of the wavefunction ΨT .

### Claim 15 (depends on 13)

The computing apparatus of claim 13, wherein the quantum computer being configured to measure the ancilla qubit to determine the output βT to the second quantum circuit comprises the quantum computer configured to:
determine an expectation value of a positive-operator valued measurement of the state of the set of qubits and the ancilla qubit after application of the second quantum circuit.

### Claim 16 (depends on 13)

The computing apparatus of claim 13, wherein the classical computer being configured to vary the set of trial values θT comprises the classical computer configured to vary the parameters θT based on the output of a cost function parameterised by the energy ET of the trial energy state of the system represented by the wavefunction ΨT and the output βT to the second quantum circuit.

### Claim 17 (depends on 12)

The computing apparatus of claim 12, wherein the computing apparatus configured to train the discriminator function by optimising the value of the set of parameters ϕ to train the discriminator function to discriminate between the wavefunction Ψ of the state generated by the first quantum circuit and the wavefunction Ψn−1 representing each of the n valid states of the system, comprises:
the quantum computer configured to:
generate an nth valid energy state of the system represented by the wavefunction, Ψn−by applying, to a set of qubits in an initial state, the first quantum circuit defined by the generator function with the set of parameters having values θn−1;
determine an output βV to the second quantum circuit by applying, to the set of qubits in the state generated by the first quantum circuit defined by the generator function with the set of parameters having values θn−1 and to an ancilla qubit, the second quantum circuit, and then measuring the ancilla qubit, wherein the second quantum circuit is defined by the discriminator function with the set of parameters ϕ having a set of trial values ϕT; and the classical computer configured to:
compare the output βV of the second quantum circuit to a predefined similarity threshold, Ts;
wherein if the output βV of the second quantum circuit is not within a predefined interval of values representing the similarity threshold, Ts;
then vary the set of trial values ϕT and repeating the generating, determining and comparing steps.

### Claim 18

(canceled)

### Claim 19 (depends on 17)

The computing apparatus of claim 17, wherein the classical computer configured to vary the parameters ϕT comprises the classical computer configured to vary the parameters ϕT based on the output of a cost function parameterised by the output to the second quantum circuit, βV.

### Claim 20 (depends on 12)

The computing apparatus of claims 12, wherein the classical computer is further configured to applying a variational quantum eigensolver to identify the set of values, θ0, parametrising the ground energy state of the system which is a first valid energy state of the system and represented by a wavefunction, Ψ0.

### Claim 21

A method for identifying an excited energy state of a system of interacting electrons on a hybrid classical and quantum computer processing unit, comprising:
optimisation of a cooperating generator and discriminator function to generate a set of parameters for the generator function representing an excited energy state of the system which has minimum energy and which also has minimum overlap with a predefined ground energy state.
