# US 2019/0378029 A1 · Methods for predicting likelihood of successful experimental synthesis of computer-generated materials by combining network analysis and machine learning

> Agents: this data is available as JSON from the patentgrep API and MCP server — see https://patentgrep.com/llms.txt

- Number: US 2019/0378029 A1
- Document ID: US20190378029A1
- Status: Published application
- Kind: A1
- Application number: 16/004,232
- Filed: 2018-06-08
- Published: 2019-12-12
- Earliest claimed: 2018-06-08
- Assignees: Toyota Research Institute, Inc.
- Applicants: Toyota Research Institute, Inc.
- Inventors: Muratahan Aykol; Santosh Karthik Suram; Linda Hung; Patrick Kenichi Herring
- Web page: https://patentgrep.com/patent/US20190378029A1

## CPC

- G16C 60/00: Computational materials science, i.e. ICT specially adapted for investigating the physical or chemical properties of materials or phenomena associated with their design, synthesis, processing, characterisation or utilisation
- G06N 3/09: Supervised learning
- G06N 7/01: Probabilistic graphical models, e.g. probabilistic networks
- G06N 20/00: Machine learning
- G06N 20/20: Ensemble learning
- G16C 20/10: Analysis or design of chemical reactions, syntheses or processes
- G16C 20/70: Machine learning, data mining or chemometrics
- G06F 18/241: relating to the classification model, e.g. parametric or non-parametric approaches
- G06N 3/08: Learning methods
- G06N 5/01: Dynamic search techniques; Heuristics; Dynamic trees; Branch-and-bound
- G16C: COMPUTATIONAL CHEMISTRY; CHEMOINFORMATICS; COMPUTATIONAL MATERIALS SCIENCE
- G06N: COMPUTING ARRANGEMENTS BASED ON SPECIFIC COMPUTATIONAL MODELS
- G06F: ELECTRIC DIGITAL DATA PROCESSING (computer systems based on specific computational models G06N)

## Abstract

One aspect of the disclosure relates to systems and methods for determining probabilities of successful synthesis of materials in the real world at one or more points in time. The probabilities of successful synthesis of materials in the real world at one or more points in time can be determined by representing the materials and their pre-defined relationships respectively as nodes and edges in a network form, and computation of the parameters of the nodes in the network as input to a classification model for successful synthesis. The classification model being configured to determine probabilities of successful synthesis of materials in the real world at one or more points in time.

## Claims

### Claim 1

A system configured to determine a probability of successful synthesis of a material in the real world at one or more points in time, the system comprising:
one or more physical processors configured by machine-readable instructions to:
obtain material network information defining a network for a set of previously synthesized materials, the material network information including node information, edge information, and discovery information, the node information characterizing previously synthesized materials represented by nodes in the network, the edge information representing connections between the previously synthesized materials based on shared components between individual ones of the previously synthesized materials, wherein the edge information further represents connections between the previously synthesized materials based on other relationship between the previously synthesized materials including relationships derived from thermodynamic co-existence information and/or phase diagrams, the discovery information defining points in time the individual previously synthesized materials in the network were first synthesized in the real world;
determine network parameter information for the network of the period of time, the network parameter information specifying sets of parameter values of the previously synthesized materials, wherein the sets of parameter values of the previously synthesized materials are determined by representing the previously synthesized materials as individual nodes in the network at discrete points in time over a period of time and determined the sets of parameter values based on the network, wherein the network at a given discrete points in time over the period of time includes the nodes representing the previously synthesized materials that were synthesized by the given discrete points in time, and the previously synthesized materials that were not synthesized by the given discrete points in time are independently introduced in the network to determine the sets of parameter values of the previously synthesized materials that were not synthesized;
train a classifier model from the individual previously synthesized materials using the discovery information and network parameter information to generate probabilities for materials being successfully synthesized in the real world at the individual discrete points in time;
determine a probability of an unsynthesized hypothetical material being successfully synthesized in the real world at the individual discrete points in time by applying the classifier model to unsynthesized material information defining the unsynthesized hypothetical material.

### Claim 2 (depends on 1)

The system of claim 1, wherein the discovery information specifies whether individual previously synthesized materials were synthesized in the real world at given points in time over a period of time.

### Claim 3 (depends on 1)

The system of claim 1, wherein the network at discrete points in time include a first point in time, and the network at the first point in time is characterized by the material network information for the nodes representing previously synthesized materials that were synthesized in the real world prior to the first point in time.

### Claim 4 (depends on 1)

The system of claim 1, wherein a set of parameter values include values for one or more of degree parameter, degree centrality parameter, eigenvector centrality parameter, mean shortest path parameter, mean degree of neighbors parameter, and/or clustering coefficient parameter.

### Claim 5 (depends on 1)

The system of claim 1, wherein the one or more physical processors are further configured by machine-readable instructions to:
obtain synthesis information, the synthesis information defining one or more synthesized materials not included in the network with the previously synthesized materials;
modify the material network information to include the synthesized materials in the network, the modification of the material network information include modifying the node information to represent the synthesized materials as additional nodes to the network, modifying the edge information to represent connections between the synthesized materials and previously synthesized materials, modifying the discovery information to include points in time the synthesized materials were first synthesized in the real world;
determine the network parameter information for the network over a period of time, the network parameter information specifying sets of parameter values of the previously synthesized materials and the synthesized materials, wherein the sets of parameter values of the previously synthesized materials and the synthesized materials are determined by representing the previously synthesized materials and the synthesized materials as individual nodes in the network at discrete points in time over a period of time and determined the sets of parameter values based on the network, wherein the network at a given discrete points in time over the period of time includes the nodes representing the previously synthesized materials and the synthesized materials that were synthesized by the given discrete points in time, and the previously synthesized materials and the synthesized materials that were not synthesized by the given discrete points in time are independently introduced in the network to determine the sets of parameter values of the previously synthesized materials and the synthesized materials that were not synthesized;
train the classifier model using the discovery information and network parameter information to generate probabilities for materials being successfully synthesized in the real world at the individual discrete points in time; and
determine a probability of the unsynthesized hypothetical material being successfully synthesized in the real world at the individual discrete points in time by applying the classifier model to unsynthesized material information defining the unsynthesized hypothetical material.

### Claim 6 (depends on 1)

The system of claim 1, wherein the one or more physical processors are further configured by machine-readable instructions to:
determine a change in the probability that the unsynthesized hypothetical material will be successfully synthesized in the real world at the individual discrete points in time based on synthesis information; and
provide a user with the change in the probability that the unsynthesized hypothetical material will be successfully synthesized in the real world at the individual discrete points in time on an interface.

### Claim 7 (depends on 1)

The system of claim 1, wherein the trained classifier model is stored in a non-transient electronic storage.

### Claim 8

A system configured to determine a probability of successful synthesis of a material in the real world at one or more points in time, the system comprising:
a non-transient electronic storage configured to store a trained classifier model;
one or more physical processors configured by machine-readable instructions to:
obtain unsynthesized hypothetical material information, the unsynthesized hypothetical material information defining a set of parameter values for an unsynthesized hypothetical material;
obtaining the classifier model from the non-transient electronic storage, the classifier model having been trained by a training data set, the training data set include (i) network parameter information and (ii) discovery information;
determine probabilities of successful synthesis of the unsynthesized hypothetical material at discrete points in time of the period of time by applying the classifier model to the unsynthesized hypothetical material information;
provide a user with the probabilities of successful synthesis of the unsynthesized hypothetical material at discrete points in time of the period of time on an interface.

### Claim 9 (depends on 8)

The system of claim 8, wherein the sets of parameter values for the unsynthesized hypothetical material is determined based on a relationship between the unsynthesized hypothetical material and the set of previously synthesized materials.

### Claim 10 (depends on 9)

The system of claim 9, wherein sets of parameter values for the unsynthesized hypothetical material and/or the sets of parameter values for the set of previously synthesized materials include values for one or more of degree parameter, degree centrality parameter, eigenvector centrality parameter, mean shortest path parameter, mean degree of neighbors parameter, and/or clustering coefficient parameter.

### Claim 11

A method for determining a probability of successful synthesis of a material in the real world at one or more points in time, the method comprising:
obtaining material network information defining a network for a set of previously synthesized materials, the material network information including node information, edge information, and discovery information, the node information characterizing previously synthesized materials represented by nodes in the network, the edge information representing connections between the previously synthesized materials based on shared components between individual ones of the previously synthesized materials, wherein the edge information further represents connections between the previously synthesized materials based on other relationship between previously synthesized materials including relationships derived from thermodynamic co-existence information and phase diagrams, the discovery information defining points in time the individual previously synthesized materials in the network were first synthesized in the real world;
determining network parameter information for the network of the period of time, the network parameter information specifying sets of parameter values of the previously synthesized materials, wherein the sets of parameter values of the previously synthesized materials are determined by representing the previously synthesized materials as individual nodes in the network at discrete points in time over a period of time and determined the sets of parameter values based on the network, wherein the network at a given discrete points in time over the period of time includes the nodes representing the previously synthesized materials that were synthesized by the given discrete points in time, and the previously synthesized materials that were not synthesized by the given discrete points in time are independently introduced in the network to determine the sets of parameter values of the previously synthesized materials that were not synthesized;
training a classifier model from the individual previously synthesized materials using the discovery information and network parameter information to generate probabilities for materials being successfully synthesized in the real world at the individual discrete points in time;
determining a probability of an unsynthesized hypothetical material being successfully synthesized in the real world at the individual discrete points in time by applying the classifier model to unsynthesized material information defining the unsynthesized hypothetical material.

### Claim 12 (depends on 11)

The method of claim 11, wherein the discovery information specifies whether individual previously synthesized materials were synthesized in the real world at given points in time over a period of time.

### Claim 13 (depends on 11)

The method of claim 11, wherein the network at discrete points in time include a first point in time, and the network at the first point in time is characterized by the material network information for the nodes representing previously synthesized materials that were synthesized in the real world prior to the first point in time.

### Claim 14 (depends on 11)

The method of claim 11, wherein a set of parameter values include values for one or more of degree parameter, degree centrality parameter, eigenvector centrality parameter, mean shortest path parameter, mean degree of neighbors parameter, and/or clustering coefficient parameter.

### Claim 15 (depends on 11)

The method of claim 11, wherein the method further comprises of:
obtaining synthesis information, the synthesis information defining one or more synthesized materials not included in the network with the previously synthesized materials;
modifying the material network information to include the synthesized materials in the network, the modification of the material network information include modifying the node information to represent the synthesized materials as additional nodes to the network, modifying the edge information to represent connections between the synthesized materials and previously synthesized materials, modifying the discovery information to include points in time the synthesized materials were first synthesized in the real world;
determining the network parameter information for the network over a period of time, the network parameter information specifying sets of parameter values of the previously synthesized materials and the synthesized materials, wherein the sets of parameter values of the previously synthesized materials and the synthesized materials are determined by representing the previously synthesized materials and the synthesized materials as individual nodes in the network at discrete points in time over a period of time and determined the sets of parameter values based on the network, wherein the network at a given discrete points in time over the period of time includes the nodes representing the previously synthesized materials and the synthesized materials that were synthesized by the given discrete points in time, and the previously synthesized materials and the synthesized materials that were not synthesized by the given discrete points in time are independently introduced in the network to determine the sets of parameter values of the previously synthesized materials and the synthesized materials that were not synthesized;
training the classifier model using the discovery information and network parameter information to generate probabilities for materials being successfully synthesized in the real world at the individual discrete points in time; and
determining a probability of the unsynthesized hypothetical material being successfully synthesized in the real world at the individual discrete points in time by applying the classifier model to unsynthesized material information defining the unsynthesized hypothetical material.

### Claim 16 (depends on 11)

The method of claim 11, wherein the method further comprises of:
determining a change in the probability that the unsynthesized hypothetical material will be successfully synthesized in the real world at the individual discrete points in time based on synthesis information; and
providing a user with the change in the probability that the unsynthesized hypothetical material will be successfully synthesized in the real world at the individual discrete points in time on an interface.

### Claim 17 (depends on 11)

The method of claim 11, wherein the trained classifier model is stored in a non-transient electronic storage.

### Claim 18

A method for determining a probability of successful synthesis of a material in the real world at one or more points in time, the system comprising:
obtaining unsynthesized hypothetical material information, the unsynthesized hypothetical material information defining a set of parameter values for an unsynthesized hypothetical material;
obtaining the classifier model from a non-transient electronic storage storing a trained classifier model, the classifier model having been trained by a training data set, the training data set include (i) network parameter information and (ii) discovery information;
determining probabilities of successful synthesis of the unsynthesized hypothetical material at the discrete points in time of the period of time by applying the classifier model to the unsynthesized hypothetical material information; and
providing a user with the probabilities of successful synthesis of the unsynthesized hypothetical material the discrete points in time of the period of time on an interface.

### Claim 19 (depends on 18)

The method of claim 18, wherein the sets of parameter values for the unsynthesized hypothetical material is determined based on a relationship between the unsynthesized hypothetical material and the set of previously synthesized materials.

### Claim 20 (depends on 19)

The method of claim 19, wherein sets of parameter values for the unsynthesized hypothetical material and/or the sets of parameter values for the set of previously synthesized materials include values for one or more of degree parameter, degree centrality parameter, eigenvector centrality parameter, mean shortest path parameter, mean degree of neighbors parameter, and/or clustering coefficient parameter.
