# US 2019/0356745 A1 · Use of corroboration to generate reputation scores within virtual reality environments

> Agents: this data is available as JSON from the patentgrep API and MCP server — see https://patentgrep.com/llms.txt

- Number: US 2019/0356745 A1
- Document ID: US20190356745A1
- Status: Published application
- Kind: A1
- Application number: 15/983,425
- Filed: 2018-05-18
- Published: 2019-11-21
- Earliest claimed: 2018-05-18
- Assignees: High Fidelity, Inc.
- Applicants: High Fidelity, Inc.
- Inventors: Philip Rosedale
- Web page: https://patentgrep.com/patent/US20190356745A1

## CPC

- H04L 67/535: {Tracking the activity of the user (network monitoring arrangements H04L43/00; recording of computer activity G06F11/34)}
- G06F 3/011: {Arrangements for interaction with the human body, e.g. for user immersion in virtual reality (blind teaching G09B21/00)}
- G06F 3/017: {Gesture based interaction, e.g. based on a set of recognized hand gestures (interaction based on gestures traced on a digitiser G06F3/04883)}
- G06F 21/316: {by observing the pattern of computer usage, e.g. typical user behaviour}
- G06F 21/554: {involving event detection and direct action}
- G06T 19/003: {Navigation within 3D models or images}
- H04L 67/131: Protocols for games, networked simulations or virtual reality
- H04L 67/306: User profiles
- H04N 7/157: {defining a virtual conference space and using avatars or agents (computer conference optimisation or adaptation H04L12/1827)}
- H04L: TRANSMISSION OF DIGITAL INFORMATION, e.g. TELEGRAPHIC COMMUNICATION (arrangements common to telegraphic and telephonic communication H04M)
- G06F: ELECTRIC DIGITAL DATA PROCESSING (computer systems based on specific computational models G06N)
- G06T: IMAGE DATA PROCESSING OR GENERATION, IN GENERAL
- H04N: PICTORIAL COMMUNICATION, e.g. TELEVISION

## Abstract

Embodiments described herein reduce the probability that a user of a VR environment can nefariously rig a system to positively and/or negatively influence another user's reputation score. Information indicative of a positive or negative interaction between an avatar of a first user and an avatar of a second user is received from a client computing device used by the first user. Further information is received from a client computing device used by a third user of the VR environment, and based thereon, there is a determination whether the positive or negative interaction is corroborated or contradicted. If corroborated, a reputation score associated with the second user is increased or decreased. If contradicted, the reputation score associated with the second user is not adjusted, and the reputation score of the first user may be decreased. Such reputation scores can be accessed and used by a user using a client computing device.

## Claims

### Claim 1

A method for use with a computer implemented virtual reality (VR) environment that enables users of the VR environment to explore the VR environment and interact with one another within the VR environment using client computing devices that are being used by the users, the method comprising:
(a) receiving, from a client computing device used by a first user of the VR environment, information indicative of a positive interaction between an avatar of the first user and an avatar of a second user of the VR environment, which positive interaction can be used to determine that the first user has a positive impression of the second user;
(b) receiving, from a client computing device used by a third user of the VR environment, further information that can be used to either corroborate or contradict that the positive interaction between the avatar of the first user and the avatar of the second user actually occurred within the VR environment;
(c) determining, based on the further information received from the client computing device used by the third user of the VR environment, whether the positive interaction is corroborated or contradicted;
(d) in response to determining that the positive interaction is corroborated, increasing a reputation score associated with the second user of the VR environment; and
(e) in response to determining that the positive interaction is contradicted, at least one of not increasing a reputation score associated with the second user of the VR environment or decreasing a reputation score associated with the first user of the VR environment. and
(f) enabling each of one or more users of the VR environment to access, using the client computing device they are using, the reputation score associated with the second user of the VR environment.

### Claim 2 (depends on 1)

The method of claim 1, wherein:
the information received at step (a), which is indicative of the positive interaction between the avatar of the first user and the avatar of the second user of the VR environment, comprises information indicative of a positive gesture that the avatar of the first user made towards the avatar of the second user; and
the further information received at step (b), which can be used to either corroborate or contradict that the positive interaction between the avatar of the first user and the avatar of the second user actually occurred within the VR environment, comprises information indicative of whether the third user, or their avatar, witnessed the avatar of the first user making the positive gesture towards the avatar of the second user.

### Claim 3 (depends on 2)

The method of claim 2, wherein the positive gesture is selected from the group consisting of:
nodding;
thumbs up;
hand shaking;
clapping; and
waving.

### Claim 4 (depends on 1)

The method of claim 1, wherein the reputation score associated with the second user of the VR environment, that is increased, not increased, or decreased, at one of steps (d) or (e) comprises an individual-to-individual (I2I) reputation score that is indicative of the first user's impression of the second user, the method further comprising:
(g) for a further user of the VR environment, whose avatar interacts with the avatar of the second user of the VR environment,
(g.1) determining a relative reputation score associated with a second user of the VR environment, wherein the relative reputation score is determined based on one or more I2I reputation scores associated with the second user that were determined for other users that are linked to both the further user and the second user of the VR environment; and
(g.2) enabling the further user of the VR environment to access, using the client computing device being used by the further user, the relative reputation score associated with the second user of the VR environment.

### Claim 5

A method for use with a computer implemented virtual reality (VR) environment that enables users of the VR environment to explore the VR environment and interact with one another within the VR environment using client computing devices that are being used by the users, the method comprising:
(a) receiving, from a client computing device used by a first user of the VR environment, information indicative of a negative interaction between an avatar of the first user and an avatar of a second user of the VR environment, which negative interaction can be used to determine that the first user has a positive impression of the second user;
(b) receiving, from a client computing device used by a third user of the VR environment, further information that can be used to either corroborate or contradict that the negative interaction between the avatar of the first user and the avatar of the second user actually occurred within the VR environment;
(c) determining, based on the further information received from the client computing device used by the third user of the VR environment, whether the negative interaction is corroborated or contradicted;
(d) in response to determining that the negative interaction is corroborated, decreasing a reputation score associated with the second user of the VR environment;
(e) in response to determining that the negative interaction is contradicted, at least one of not decreasing a reputation score associated with the second user of the VR environment or decreasing a reputation score associated with the first user of the VR environment; and
(f) enabling each of one or more users of the VR environment to access, using the client computing device they are using, the reputation score associated with the second user of the VR environment.

### Claim 6 (depends on 5)

The method of claim 5, wherein:
the information received at step (a), which is indicative of the negative interaction between the avatar of the first user and the avatar of the second user of the VR environment, comprises information indicative of a negative gesture that the avatar of the first user made towards the avatar of the second user; and
the further information received at step (b), which can be used to either corroborate or contradict that the negative interaction between the avatar of the first user and the avatar of the second user actually occurred within the VR environment, comprises information indicative of whether the third user, or their avatar, witnessed the avatar of the first user making the negative gesture towards the avatar of the second user.

### Claim 7 (depends on 6)

The method of claim 6, wherein the negative gesture is selected from the group consisting of:
shaking head side to side; and
thumbs down.

### Claim 8

One or more processor readable storage devices having instructions encoded thereon which when executed cause one or more processors to perform a method for use with a virtual reality (VR) environment in which users can explore the VR environment and interact with one another within the VR environment using client computing devices that are being used by the users, the method comprising:
(a) receiving, from a client computing device used by a first user of the VR environment, information indicative of a positive interaction between an avatar of the first user and an avatar of a second user of the VR environment, which positive interaction can be used to determine that the first user has a positive impression of the second user;
(b) receiving, from a client computing device used by a third user of the VR environment, further information that can be used to either corroborate or contradict that the positive interaction between the avatar of the first user and the avatar of the second user actually occurred within the VR environment;
(c) determining, based on the further information received from the client computing device used by the third user of the VR environment, whether the positive interaction is corroborated or contradicted;
(d) in response to determining that the positive interaction is corroborated, increasing a reputation score associated with the second user of the VR environment;
(e) in response to determining that the positive interaction is contradicted, at least one of not increasing or decreasing a reputation score associated with the second user of the VR environment; and
(f) enabling each of one or more users of the VR environment to access, using the client computing device they are using, the reputation score associated with the second user of the VR environment.

### Claim 9 (depends on 8)

The one or more processor readable storage devices of claim 8, wherein:
the information received at step (a), which is indicative of the positive interaction between the avatar of the first user and the avatar of the second user of the VR environment, comprises information indicative of a positive gesture that the avatar of the first user made towards the avatar of the second user;
the further information received at step (b), which can be used to either corroborate or contradict that the positive interaction between the avatar of the first user and the avatar of the second user actually occurred within the VR environment, comprises information indicative of whether the third user, or their avatar, witnessed the avatar of the first user making the positive gesture towards the avatar of the second user.

### Claim 10 (depends on 9)

The one or more processor readable storage devices of claim 9, wherein the positive gesture is selected from the group consisting of:
nodding;
thumbs up;
hand shaking;
clapping; and
waving.

### Claim 11 (depends on 8)

The one or more processor readable storage devices of claim 8, wherein the reputation score associated with the second user of the VR environment, that is increased, not increased, or decreased, at one of steps (d) or (e) comprises an individual-to-individual (I2I) reputation score that is indicative of the first user's impression of the second user, the method further comprising:
(g) for a further user of the VR environment, whose avatar interacts with the avatar of the second user of the VR environment,
(g.1) determining a relative reputation score associated with a second user of the VR environment, wherein the relative reputation score is determined based on one or more I2I reputation scores associated with the second user that were determined for other users that are linked to both the further user and the second user of the VR environment; and
(g.2) enabling the further user of the VR environment to access, using the client computing device being used by the further user, the relative reputation score associated with the second user of the VR environment.

### Claim 12

One or more processor readable storage devices having instructions encoded thereon which when executed cause one or more processors to perform a method for use with a virtual reality (VR) environment in which users can explore the VR environment and interact with one another within the VR environment using client computing devices that are being used by the users, the method comprising:
(a) receiving, from a client computing device used by a first user of the VR environment, information indicative of a negative interaction between an avatar of the first user and an avatar of a second user of the VR environment, which negative interaction can be used to determine that the first user has a positive impression of the second user;
(b) receiving, from a client computing device used by a third user of the VR environment, further information that can be used to either corroborate or contradict that the negative interaction between the avatar of the first user and the avatar of the second user actually occurred within the VR environment;
(c) determining, based on the further information received from the client computing device used by the third user of the VR environment, whether the negative interaction is corroborated or contradicted;
(d) in response to determining that the negative interaction is corroborated, decreasing a reputation score associated with the second user of the VR environment;
(e) in response to determining that the negative interaction is contradicted, at least one of not decreasing a reputation score associated with the second user of the VR environment or decreasing a reputation score associated with the first user of the VR environment; and
(f) enabling each of one or more users of the VR environment to access, using the client computing device they are using, the reputation score associated with the second user of the VR environment.

### Claim 13 (depends on 12)

The one or more processor readable storage devices of claim 12, wherein:
the information received at step (a), which is indicative of the negative interaction between the avatar of the first user and the avatar of the second user of the VR environment, comprises information indicative of a negative gesture that the avatar of the first user made towards the avatar of the second user; and
the further information received at step (b), which can be used to either corroborate or contradict that the negative interaction between the avatar of the first user and the avatar of the second user actually occurred within the VR environment, comprises information indicative of whether the third user, or their avatar, witnessed the avatar of the first user making the negative gesture towards the avatar of the second user.

### Claim 14 (depends on 8)

The one or more processor readable storage devices of claim 8, wherein the negative gesture is selected from the group consisting of:
shaking head side to side; and
thumbs down.

### Claim 15

A system for supporting a computer implemented virtual reality (VR) environment in which users of the VR environment can explore the VR environment and interact with one another within the VR environment using client computing devices that are being used by the users, the system comprising:
one or more processors configured to receive, from a client computing device used by a first user of the VR environment, information indicative of a positive or negative interaction between an avatar of the first user and an avatar of a second user of the VR environment, which positive or negative interaction can be used to determine that the first user has a positive or negative impression of the second user;
one or more processors also configured to receive, from a client computing device used by a third user of the VR environment, further information that can be used to either corroborate or contradict that the positive or negative interaction between the avatar of the first user and the avatar of the second user actually occurred within the VR environment;
the one or more processors also configured to determine, based on the further information received from the client computing device used by the third user of the VR environment, whether the positive or negative interaction is corroborated or contradicted;
the one or more processors also configured to adjust a reputation score associated with the second user of the VR environment, in response to a determination that the positive or negative interaction is corroborated;
the one or more processors also configured to not adjust a reputation score associated with the second user of the VR environment, in response to a determination that the positive or negative interaction is contradicted; and
the one or more processors also configured to enable each of one or more users of the VR environment to access, using the client computing device they are using, the reputation score associated with the second user of the VR environment.

### Claim 16 (depends on 15)

The system of claim 15, wherein:
the information is indicative of a positive interaction between the avatar of the first user and the avatar of the second user of the VR environment and comprises information indicative of a positive gesture that the avatar of the first user made towards the avatar of the second user; and
the further information, which can be used to either corroborate or contradict that the positive interaction between the avatar of the first user and the avatar of the second user actually occurred within the VR environment, comprises information indicative of whether the third user, or their avatar, witnessed the avatar of the first user making the positive gesture towards the avatar of the second user.

### Claim 17 (depends on 16)

The system of claim 16, wherein the positive gesture is selected from the group consisting of:
nodding;
thumbs up;
hand shaking;
clapping; and
waving.

### Claim 18 (depends on 15)

The system of claim 15, wherein:
the reputation score associated with the second user of the VR environment, that is increased, not increased, or decreased, comprises an individual-to-individual (I2I) reputation score that is indicative of the first user's impression of the second user;
the one or more processors are also configured to determine, for a further user of the VR environment, whose avatar interacts with the avatar of the second user of the VR environment, a relative reputation score associated with the second user of the VR environment, wherein the relative reputation score is determined based on one or more I2I reputation scores associated with the second user that were determined for other users that are linked to both the further user and the second user of the VR environment; and
the one or more processors are also configured to enable the further user of the VR environment to access, using the client computing device being used by the further user, the relative reputation score associated with the second user of the VR environment.

### Claim 19 (depends on 15)

The system of claim 15, wherein:
the information is indicative of a negative interaction between the avatar of the first user and the avatar of the second user of the VR environment and comprises information indicative of a negative gesture that the avatar of the first user made towards the avatar of the second user; and
the further information, which can be used to either corroborate or contradict that the negative interaction between the avatar of the first user and the avatar of the second user actually occurred within the VR environment, comprises information indicative of whether the third user, or their avatar, witnessed the avatar of the first user making the negative gesture towards the avatar of the second user.

### Claim 20 (depends on 19)

The system of claim 19, wherein the negative gesture is selected from the group consisting of:
shaking head side to side; and
thumbs down.
