# US 2013/0253945 A1 · Method and system for measuring quality of performance and/or compliance with protocol of a clinical study

> Agents: this data is available as JSON from the patentgrep API and MCP server — see https://patentgrep.com/llms.txt

- Number: US 2013/0253945 A1
- Document ID: US20130253945A1
- Status: Published application
- Kind: A1
- Application number: 13/895,566
- Filed: 2013-05-16
- Published: 2013-09-26
- Earliest claimed: 2004-10-28
- Assignees: Siemens Aktiengesellschaft
- Inventors: Klaus ABRAHAM-FUCHS; Gudrun ZAHLMANN; Rainer KUTH; Eva RUMPEL; Siegfried SCHNEIDER; Markus SCHMIDT; Horst SCHREINER
- Web page: https://patentgrep.com/patent/US20130253945A1

## CPC

- G06Q 10/06393: {Score-carding, benchmarking or key performance indicator [KPI] analysis}
- G06Q 30/018: Certifying business or products
- G16H 10/20: for electronic clinical trials or questionnaires
- G16H 10/40: for data related to laboratory analysis, e.g. patient specimen analysis
- G16H 40/20: for the management or administration of healthcare resources or facilities, e.g. managing hospital staff or surgery rooms
- G16H 70/20: relating to practices or guidelines
- G06Q: INFORMATION AND COMMUNICATION TECHNOLOGY [ICT] SPECIALLY ADAPTED FOR ADMINISTRATIVE, COMMERCIAL, FINANCIAL, MANAGERIAL OR SUPERVISORY PURPOSES; SYSTEMS OR METHODS SPECIALLY ADAPTED FOR ADMINISTRATIVE, COMMERCIAL, FINANCIAL, MANAGERIAL OR SUPERVISORY PURPOSES, NOT OTHERWISE PROVIDED FOR
- G16H: HEALTHCARE INFORMATICS, i.e. INFORMATION AND COMMUNICATION TECHNOLOGY [ICT] SPECIALLY ADAPTED FOR THE HANDLING OR PROCESSING OF MEDICAL OR HEALTHCARE DATA

## Abstract

A method is proposed for determining clinical study compliance. The method includes obtaining criteria for the clinical study and accessing stored clinical data relating to the clinical study. Thereafter, the criteria and clinical data are correlated to determine a measure of compliance with the criteria of the clinical study.

## Claims

### Claim at position 1

1-141. (canceled)

### Claim 142

A method of analyzing quality of a clinical study, comprising:
creating a database including quality related aspects from criteria for the clinical study;
accessing stored clinical data relating to the clinical study; and
correlating the quality related aspects of criteria and clinical data to determine performance of the quality related aspects of the criteria of the clinical study.

### Claim 143 (depends on 142)

The method of claim 142, further comprising:
calculating a measure of performance for a plurality of criteria for the clinical study.

### Claim 144 (depends on 142)

The method of claim 142, wherein the clinical data includes clinical actions.

### Claim 145 (depends on 143)

The method of claim 143, wherein the measure of performance includes patient performance.

### Claim 146 (depends on 143)

The method of claim 143, wherein the measure of performance includes performance of a clinical trial site wherein the clinical trial is performed.

### Claim 147 (depends on 142)

The method of claim 142, wherein the correlating is done via a computer device.

### Claim 148 (depends on 142)

The method of claim 142, wherein the clinical data and criteria for the clinical data are stored in separate databases.

### Claim 149 (depends on 142)

The method of claim 142, wherein the stored criteria includes quality aspects related to patient performance criteria and quality aspects related to non-patient performance criteria.

### Claim 150 (depends on 143)

The method of claim 143, wherein the criteria includes weighted criteria, wherein the weighting affects the measure of performance.

### Claim 151 (depends on 142)

The method of claim 142, wherein the criteria include measurable parameters and parameters of context.

### Claim 152 (depends on 150)

The method of claim 150, wherein the criteria include measurable parameters and parameters of context.

### Claim 153 (depends on 142)

A device for implementing the method of claim 142.

### Claim 154 (depends on 142)

A program, adapted to perform the method of claim 142, when executed on a computer.

### Claim 155 (depends on 154)

A computer readable medium, storing the program of claim 154.

### Claim 156 (depends on 142)

The method of claim 142, wherein the clinical data is stored in association with identification information of patients enrolled in the clinical study, wherein only clinical data relating to patients enrolled in the clinical study are correlated with the criteria.

### Claim 157 (depends on 156)

The method of claim 156, wherein the clinical data and identification information of patients enrolled in the clinical study are stored in a single database.

### Claim 158 (depends on 156)

The method of claim 156, wherein the clinical data and identification information of patients enrolled in the clinical study are stored in separate databases.

### Claim 159 (depends on 142)

The method of claim 142, further comprising:
informing the clinical trial site if the quality related aspects of criteria and clinical data do not correlate.

### Claim 160 (depends on 143)

The method of claim 143, further comprising:
informing the clinical trial site if the measure of performance is below a threshold.

### Claim 161 (depends on 159)

The method of claim 159, wherein the informing is achieved via an electronic message.

### Claim 162 (depends on 160)

The method of claim 160, wherein the informing is achieved via an electronic message.

### Claim 163 (depends on 142)

The method of claim 142, wherein an attempt is made to correlate volatile clinical data with criteria for the clinical study, and wherein the volatile data are permanently stored upon determining a lack of correlation.

### Claim 164 (depends on 143)

The method of claim 143, wherein volatile clinical data are correlated with criteria for the clinical study, and wherein the volatile data are permanently stored upon determining that the measure of performance is below a threshold.

### Claim 165 (depends on 142)

The method of claim 142, wherein clinical data are stored permanently, upon determining that the data relate to a patient enrolled in the clinical study.

### Claim 166 (depends on 156)

The method of claim 156, wherein clinical data are stored permanently, upon determining that the data relate to a patient enrolled in the clinical study.

### Claim 167 (depends on 142)

The method of claim 142, wherein a listing of correlated clinical data is reported to a sponsor of the clinical study.

### Claim 168 (depends on 143)

The method of claim 143, wherein the measure of performance is reported to a sponsor of the clinical study.

### Claim 169 (depends on 142)

The method of claim 142, wherein the criteria for the clinical study are automatically translated into rules which are machine-readable.

### Claim 170 (depends on 169)

The method of claim 169, wherein the rules are machine-readable via at least one of a look-up table, a thesaurus, and an ontology.

### Claim 171 (depends on 142)

The method of claim 142, wherein the criteria for the clinical study are translated into rules which are machine-readable and wherein applicable criteria are selected from a database.

### Claim 172

A system for analyzing quality of a clinical study, comprising:
means for creating a database including quality related aspects from criteria for the clinical study;
means for accessing stored clinical data relating to the clinical study; and
means for correlating the quality related aspects of criteria and clinical data to determine performance of the quality related aspects of the criteria of the clinical study.

### Claim 173 (depends on 172)

The system of claim 172, further comprising:
means for calculating a measure of performance for a plurality of criteria for the clinical study.

### Claim 174 (depends on 172)

The system of claim 172, wherein the clinical data includes clinical actions.

### Claim 175 (depends on 173)

The system of claim 173, wherein the measure of performance includes patient performance.

### Claim 176 (depends on 173)

The system of claim 173, wherein the measure of performance includes performance of a clinical trial site wherein the clinical trial is performed.

### Claim 177 (depends on 172)

The system of claim 172, wherein the correlating is done using a computer device.

### Claim 178 (depends on 172)

The system of claim 172, wherein the clinical data and criteria for the clinical data are stored in separate databases.

### Claim 179 (depends on 172)

The system of claim 172, wherein the stored criteria includes quality aspects related to patient performance criteria and quality aspects related to non-patient performance criteria.

### Claim 180 (depends on 173)

The system of claim 173, wherein the criteria includes weighted criteria, wherein the weighting affects the measure of performance.

### Claim 181 (depends on 172)

The system of claim 172, wherein the criteria include measurable parameters and parameters of context.

### Claim 182 (depends on 180)

The system of claim 180, wherein the criteria include measurable parameters and parameters of context.

### Claim 183 (depends on 172)

The system of claim 172, wherein the clinical data is stored in association with identification information of patients enrolled in the clinical study, wherein only clinical data relating to patients enrolled in the clinical study are correlated with the criteria.

### Claim 184 (depends on 183)

The system of claim 183, wherein the clinical data and identification information of patients enrolled in the clinical study are stored in a single database.

### Claim 185 (depends on 183)

The system of claim 183, wherein the clinical data and identification information of patients enrolled in the clinical study are stored in separate databases.

### Claim 186 (depends on 172)

The system of claim 172, further comprising:
means for informing the clinical trial site if the quality related aspects of criteria and clinical data do not correlate.

### Claim 187 (depends on 173)

The system of claim 173, further comprising:
means for informing the clinical trial site if the measure of performance is below a threshold.

### Claim 188 (depends on 186)

The system of claim 186, wherein the informing is achieved via an electronic message.

### Claim 189 (depends on 187)

The system of claim 187, wherein the informing is achieved via an electronic message.

### Claim 190 (depends on 172)

The system of claim 172, wherein an attempt is made to correlate volatile clinical data with criteria for the clinical study, and wherein the volatile data are permanently stored upon determining a lack of correlation.

### Claim 191 (depends on 173)

The system of claim 173, wherein volatile clinical data are correlated with criteria for the clinical study, and wherein the volatile data are permanently stored upon determining that the measure of performance is below a threshold.

### Claim 192 (depends on 172)

The system of claim 172, wherein clinical data are stored permanently, upon determining that the data relate to a patient enrolled in the clinical study.

### Claim 193 (depends on 183)

The system of claim 183, wherein clinical, data are stored permanently, upon determining that the data relate to a patient enrolled in the clinical study.

### Claim 194 (depends on 172)

The system of claim 172, wherein a listing of correlated clinical data is reported to a sponsor of the clinical study.

### Claim 195 (depends on 173)

The system of claim 173, wherein the measure of performance is reported to a sponsor of the clinical study.

### Claim 196 (depends on 172)

The system of claim 172, wherein the criteria for the clinical study are automatically translated into rules which are machine-readable.

### Claim 197 (depends on 196)

The system of claim 196, wherein the rules are machine-readable via at least one of a look-up table, a thesaurus, and an ontology.

### Claim 198 (depends on 172)

The system of claim 172, wherein the criteria for the clinical study are translated into rules which are machine-readable and wherein applicable criteria are selected from a database.

### Claim at position 59

199-213. (canceled)

### Claim 214

A method of analyzing quality of a clinical study, comprising:
creating a database including quality related aspects from criteria for the clinical study;
accessing stored clinical data relating to the clinical study; and
correlating the quality related aspects of criteria and clinical data to determine at least one of a quality score and a compliance score.

### Claim 215 (depends on 214)

A device for implementing the method of claim 214.

### Claim 216 (depends on 214)

A program, adapted to perform the method of claim 214, when executed on a computer.

### Claim 217 (depends on 215)

A computer readable medium, storing the program of claim 215.
