# US 2012/0253879 A1 · Optimizing workforce capacity and capability

> Agents: this data is available as JSON from the patentgrep API and MCP server — see https://patentgrep.com/llms.txt

- Number: US 2012/0253879 A1
- Document ID: US20120253879A1
- Status: Published application
- Kind: A1
- Application number: 13/077,932
- Filed: 2011-03-31
- Published: 2012-10-04
- Earliest claimed: 2011-03-31
- Inventors: Cipriano A. Santos; Maria Teresa Gonzalez Diaz; Xin Zhang; Shailendra K. Jain; Andrei Alexandru Fuciec; Haitao Li; Claudia Marquez-Nava; Christopher Mejia
- Web page: https://patentgrep.com/patent/US20120253879A1

## CPC

- G06Q 10/06: Resources, workflows, human or project management; Enterprise or organisation planning; Enterprise or organisation modelling
- G06Q: INFORMATION AND COMMUNICATION TECHNOLOGY [ICT] SPECIALLY ADAPTED FOR ADMINISTRATIVE, COMMERCIAL, FINANCIAL, MANAGERIAL OR SUPERVISORY PURPOSES; SYSTEMS OR METHODS SPECIALLY ADAPTED FOR ADMINISTRATIVE, COMMERCIAL, FINANCIAL, MANAGERIAL OR SUPERVISORY PURPOSES, NOT OTHERWISE PROVIDED FOR

## Abstract

A workforce capacity and capability at an entity is optimized. Values for parameters related to the workforce capacity and capability at the entity are received. A workforce capacity and capability model is used to generate values for decision variables related to the workforce capacity and capability at the entity, based on the values for the parameters that have been received. The workforce capacity and capability model models uncertainty associated with a workforce. The values for the decision variables assist evaluation of workforce capacity and capability strategic decisions

## Claims

### Claim 1

A method for optimizing a workforce capacity and capability at an entity, comprising:
receiving values for a plurality of parameters related to the workforce capacity and capability at the entity, by a processor; and,
using a workforce capacity and capability model, by the processor, to generate values for a plurality of decision variables related to the workforce capacity and capability at the entity, based on the values for the parameters that have been received, wherein
the workforce capacity and capability model models uncertainty associated with a workforce,
the values for the decision variables assist evaluation of workforce capacity and capability strategic decisions, and
the workforce capacity and capability model maximizes an expression A−B−C−D−E, where A specifies total revenue allocated, B specifies a cost of service delivery from non-entity-owned sources, C specifies a total entity-owned workforce cost, D specifies a total cross-training cost, and E specifies a penalty of idled regular workforce.

### Claim 2 (depends on 1)

The method of claim 1, further comprising determining one or more performance measures, by the processor, from the values for the decision variables generated using the workforce capacity and capability model.

### Claim 3 (depends on 1)

The method of claim 1, wherein the workforce capacity and capability model is a deterministic model.

### Claim 4 (depends on 3)

The method of claim 3, wherein using the workforce capacity and capability model comprises solving a mixed integer linear programming (MILP) problem to maximize the expression, given a plurality of constraints specified by the workforce capacity and capability model.

### Claim 5 (depends on 3)

The method of claim 3, further comprising performing sensitivity analysis, by the processor, on the parameters to determine effects of uncertainty in the parameters on the values for the decision variables generated using the workforce capacity and capability model,
wherein the value for each of one or more of the parameters is a priori unknown and therefore estimated.

### Claim 6

(canceled)

### Claim 7 (depends on 4)

The method of claim 4, wherein the constraints comprise:
a first constraint to ensure that a total revenue allocated to workforce sources equals a forecasted revenue target in each of a plurality of market offerings;
a second constraint to impose a lower bound on the total revenue as allocated to the workforce sources;
a third constraint to convert revenues in currency amounts into a number of full-time employees (FTEs) needed while considering one or more risk factors;
a fourth constraint to enforce a sum of different types of FTE equals a total number of the FTEs needed;
a fifth constraint to specify FTEs needed per FTE role;
a sixth constraint to specify a composition of FTE in terms of FTE roles;
a seventh constraint to balance an initial inventory, a reduced regular FTE used for cross-training, an increased regular FTE trained from other roles, and an idled regular FTE;
an eighth constraint to ensure that FTEs used for cross-training cannot exceed an available inventory;
a ninth constraint to ensure that that cross-trained FTEs cannot exceed a final regular FTE number;
a tenth constraint to forbid cross-training where impermissible;
one or more eleventh constraints to prevent cross-training idled regular FTEs; and,
a twelfth constraint to define decision variable domains.

### Claim 8 (depends on 4)

The method of claim 4, wherein M specifies a set of market offerings by the entity, L specifies a set of workforce sources available to the entity, R specifies a set of workforce roles, F specifies a set of full-time employee (FTE) types at the entity, m∈M specifies an index of the market offerings, l∈L specifies an index of the workforce sources, r∈R specifies an index of the workforce roles, f∈F specifies an index of the FTE types, F⊃{reg, ctw} such that reg represents regular FTEs at the entity and ctw represents contingent FTEs at the entity, and T⊂(M×R)×(M×R) specifies a set of valid cross-trainings from one pair of a market offering and a role to another pair of a market offering and a role,
wherein the parameters comprise: Ym specifying target revenue by the entity for marking offering m; ρml specifying a cost ratio of revenue generated by a non-entity-owned source
I
∈
L
L
E
to the target revenue in market offering m; cmlf specifying cost per FTE of type f per day in marketing offering m from source l; η specifying a number of working days over a planning horizon; μmrlm′r′ specifying a percentage of utilization that is lost due to lead time spent to cross-train an FTE from source l in role r of market offering m to role r′ of market offering m′; θml specifying a lower bound on a percentage of revenue in market offering m allocated to source l; Σml specifying an average discounted external rate of an FTE; umlf specifying a percentage of time of an FTE of type f in market offering m from source l that generates revenue; λml specifying a risk factor for an FTE in marketing offering m from source l; πmrl specifying a percentage of FTE of role r in market offering m from source l; lmrl specifying an available inventory of FTE of role r in market offering m from source l; a large positive number M, such as greater than a threshold; and, αmlr specifying a cost of the idled regular FTE of role r in market offering m from source l,
and wherein the decision variable comprise: xml specifying revenue allocated to source l in market offering m; yml specifying FTE for market offering m from source l; ymlf specifying FTE of type f for market offering m from source l; zmlrf specifying FTE in role r of type f for market offering m from source l; Xmrlm′r′ specifying regular FTE from source l in role r of market offering m trained to role r′ of market offering m′; Emlr specifying idled regular FTE of role r in market offering m from source l; and, δEmlr:=1 specifying whether the idled regular FTE of role r in market offering m from source l can be positive;
δ
X
mr
lm
′

r
′
:=
1
specifying whether cross-training from source l in role r of market offering m to role r′ of market offering m′ can be positive.

### Claim 9 (depends on 8)

The method of claim 8, wherein the expression is ΣmΣlxml−ΣmΣl∈L/LEρmlxml−ηΣmΣl∈LEΣfcmlf−ηΣmΣl∈LEΣrcmlregμmrlm′r′Xmrlm′r′−ηΣmΣl∈LEΣrαmlrEmlr,
and wherein the constraints comprise: Σlxml=Ym,∀m∈M; xml≧θmlYm,∀m∈M,l∈L; τmlη[Σfumlfymlf−λmlyml]=xml,∀m∈M,l∈LE; Σfymlf=yml,∀m∈M,l∈LE; Σrzmlrf=ymlf,∀m∈M,l∈LE,f∈F; Σfzmlrf=πmrlyml,∀m∈M,l∈LE,r∈R; zmlrreg=lmrl−Σm′Σr′Xmrlm′r′+Σm′Σr′(1−μm′r′lmr)Xm′r′lmr−Emlr, ∀m∈M,l∈LE,r∈R; Σm′Σr′Xmrlm′r′≦lmrl,∀m∈M,l∈LE,r∈R; Σm′Σr′(1−μm′r′lmr)Xm′r′lmr≦zmlrreg,∀m∈M,l∈LE,r∈R; Xmrlm′r′=0,∀(mr,m′r′)∉T,l∈LE; M□δEmlr>Emlr,∀,∀m∈M,l∈LE,r∈R;
M


•δ
X
mr
lm
′

r
′
≥
X
mr
lm
′

r
′
,
∀
(
mr
,
m
′

r
′
)
∈
T
,
I
∈
L
E
;
δ
E
mlr
+
δ
X
mr
lm
′

r
′
≤
1
,
∀
(
mr
,
m
′

r
′
)
∈
T
,

I
∈
L
E
;
δ
E
mlr
,
δ
X
mr
lm
′

r
′
∈
{
0
,
1
}
;
and
,

x
m
l
,
y
m
'
,
y
ml
f
,
z
mlr
f
,
X
mr
lm
′

r
′
≥
0.

### Claim 10 (depends on 1)

The method of claim 1, wherein the workforce capacity and capability model is a non-deterministic model.

### Claim 11 (depends on 10)

The method of claim 10, wherein the parameters are first parameters, and wherein using the workforce capacity and capability model comprises solving a stochastic programming (SP) problem to maximize the expression, given a plurality of constraints specified by the workforce capacity and capability model, and based on a plurality of second parameters that are random parameters and that are different than the first parameters.

### Claim 12 (depends on 11)

The method of claim 11, wherein the workforce capacity and capability model is a two-stage non-deterministic model such that the decision variables comprise one or more first-stage decision variables and one or more second-stage decision variables.

### Claim 13 (depends on 12)

The method of claim 12, wherein solving the SP problem comprises:
solving the SP problem at a first stage to generate the values for the first-stage decision variables to provide an estimated solution to the SP problem; and,
solving the SP problem at a second stage later in time than the first stage and for a specific scenario to generate the values for the second-stage decision variables to provide a solution to the SP problem for the specific scenario that is more accurate than the estimated solution to the SP problem.

### Claim 14 (depends on 12)

The method of claim 12, wherein C specifies the total entity-owned workforce cost weighted over a plurality of probabilistic scenarios, D specifies the total cross-training cost weighted over the probabilistic scenarios, and E specifies the penalty of the idled regular workforce weighted over the probabilistic scenarios.

### Claim 15 (depends on 14)

The method of claim 14, wherein the constraints comprise:
a first constraint to ensure that a total revenue allocated to workforce sources equals a forecasted revenue target in each of a plurality of market offerings;
a second constraint to impose a lower bound on the total revenue as allocated to the workforce sources;
a third constraint to convert revenues in currency amounts into a number of full-time employees (FTEs) needed while considering one or more risk factors, and as associated with a particular probabilistic scenario;
a fourth constraint to enforce a sum of different types of FTE equals a total number of the FTEs needed, as associated with the particular probabilistic scenario;
a fifth constraint to specify FTEs needed per FTE role, as associated with the particular probabilistic scenario;
a sixth constraint to specify a composition of FTE in terms of FTE roles, as associated with the particular probabilistic scenario;
a seventh constraint to balance an initial inventory, a reduced regular FTE used for cross-training, an increased regular FTE trained from other roles, and an idled regular FTE, as associated with the particular probabilistic scenario;
an eighth constraint to ensure that FTEs used for cross-training cannot exceed an available inventory, as associated with the particular probabilistic scenario;
a ninth constraint to ensure that that cross-trained FTEs cannot exceed a final regular FTE number, as associated with the particular probabilistic scenario;
a tenth constraint to forbid cross-training where impermissible, as associated with the particular probabilistic scenario;
one or more eleventh constraints to prevent cross-training idled regular FTEs, as associated with the particular probabilistic scenario; and,
a twelfth constraint to define decision variable domains, as associated with the particular probabilistic scenario.

### Claim 16 (depends on 12)

The method of claim 12, wherein M specifies a set of market offerings by the entity, L specifies a set of workforce sources available to the entity, R specifies a set of workforce roles, F specifies a set of full-time employee (FTE) types at the entity, m∈M specifies an index of the market offerings, l∈L specifies an index of the workforce sources, r∈R specifies an index of the workforce roles, f∈F specifies an index of the FTE types, F⊃{reg,ctw} such that reg represents regular FTEs at the entity and ctw represents contingent FTEs at the entity, T⊂(M×R)×(M×R) specifies a set of valid cross-trainings from one pair of a market offering and a role to another pair of a market offering and a role, Ω specifies a set of scenarios, ω∈Ω specifies a scenario representing a realization of the second parameters, and pω specifying a probability that scenario ω occurs,
wherein the first parameters comprise: Ym specifying target revenue by the entity for marking offering m; ρml specifying a cost ratio of revenue generated by a non-entity-owned source
I
∈
L
L
E
to the target revenue in market offering m; cmlf specifying cost per FTE of type f per day in marketing offering m from source l; η specifying a number of working days over a planning horizon; μmrlm′r′ specifying a percentage of utilization that is lost due to lead time spent to cross-train an FTE from source l in role r of market offering m to role r′ of market offering m′; θml specifying a lower bound on a percentage of revenue in market offering m allocated to source l; τml specifying an average discounted external rate of an FTE; umlf specifying a percentage of time of an FTE of type f in market offering m from source l that generates revenue; λml specifying a risk factor for an FTE in marketing offering m from source l; πmrl specifying a percentage of FTE of role r in market offering m from source l; lmrl specifying an available inventory of FTE of role r in market offering m from source l; a large positive number M greater than a threshold; and, αmlrω specifying a cost of the idled regular FTE of role r in market offering m from source l in scenario ω,
wherein the second parameters comprise: ũmlf specifying a commitment rate of type f FTE in market offering m from source l; and, {tilde over (λ)}ml specifying a risk factor of an FTE in market offering m from source l,
wherein the first-stage decision variables comprise: xml specifying revenue allocated to source l in market offering m,
and wherein the second-stage decision variables comprise: ymlω specifying FTE for market offering m from source l in scenario ω; ymlfω specifying FTE of type f for market offering m from source l in scenario ω; zmlrfω specifying FTE in role r of type f for market offering m from source l in scenario ω; Xmrωlm′r′ specifying regular FTE from source l in role r of market offering m trained to role r′ of market offering m′ in scenario ω; Emlrω specifying idled regular FTE of role r in market offering m from source l in scenario ω; δEmlrω:=1 specifying whether the idled regular FTE of role r in market offering m from source l can be positive in scenario ω; and,
δ
X
mr
lm
′

r
′
ω
:=
1
specifying whether cross-training from source l in role r of market offering m to role r′ of market offering m′ can be positive in scenario ω.

### Claim 17 (depends on 16)

The method of claim 16, wherein the expression is
∑
m

∑
l

x
m
l
-
∑
m

∑
I
∈
L
/
L

E


ρ
m
l

x
m
l
-
∑
ω

p
ω
(
η

∑
m

∑
I
∈
L

E

∑
f

c
ml
f


ω
+
η

∑
m

∑
I
∈
L

E

∑
r

c
ml
reg

μ
mr


ω
ml
′

r
′

X
mr


ω
lm
′

r
′
+
η

∑
m

∑
I
∈
L

E

∑
r

α
mlr

E
mlr
ω
)
,
and wherein the constraints comprise: Σlxml=Ym,∀m∈M; xml≧θmlYm,∀m∈M,l∈L; τmlη[Σfumlfωymlfω−λmlωymlω]=xmlm∀m∈M,l∈LE,ω∈Ω; Σfymlfω=ymlω,∀m∈M,l∈LE,ω∈Ω; Σrzmlrfω=ymlfω,∀m∈M,l∈LE,f∈F,ω∈Ω; Σfzmlrfω=πmrlymlω,∀m∈M,l∈LE,r∈R,ω∈Ω; zmlrreg,ω=lmrl−Σm′Σr′Xmrlm′r′+Σm′Σr′(1−μm′r′lmr)Xm′r′ωlmr−Elmrω, ∀m∈M,l∈LE,r∈R,ω∈Ω; Σm′Σr′Xmrωlm′r′≦lmrl,∀m∈M,l∈LE,r∈R,ω∈Ω; Σm′Σr′(1−μm′r′lmr)Xm′r′ωlmr≦zmlrreg,ω,∀m∈M,l∈LE,r∈R,ω∈Ω; Xmrωlm′r′=0,∀(mr,m′r′)∈T,l∈LE,ω∈Ω; M□δEmlrω>Emlr,∀,∀m∈M,l∈LE,r∈R,ω∈Ω;
M


•δ
X
mr
lm
′

r
′
ω
≥
X
mr


ω
lm
′

r
′
,
∀
(
mr
,
m
′

r
′
)
∈
T
,
I
∈
L
E
,
ω
∈
Ω
;
δ
E
ω
mlr
+
δ
X
mr
lm
′

r
′
ω
≤
1
,
∀
(
mr
,
m
′

r
′
)
∈
T
,

I
∈
L
E

ω
∈
Ω
;
δ
E
mlr
ω
,
δ
X
mr
lm
′

r
′
ω
∈
{
0
,
1
}
,
ω
∈
Ω
;
x
m
l
,
y
m
l


ω
,
y
ml
f


ω
,
z
mlr
f
,
X
mr


ω
lm
′

r
′
≥
0.

### Claim 18

A non-transitory computer-readable data storage medium storing a computer program, execution of the computer program by a processor causing a method to be performed, the method for optimizing a workforce capacity and capability at an entity and comprising:
retrieving values for a plurality of parameters related to the workforce capacity and capability at the entity; and,
employing a workforce capacity and capability model to generate values for a plurality of decision variables related to the workforce capacity and capability at the entity, based on the values for the parameters that have been received, wherein
the workforce capacity and capability model models uncertainty associated with a workforce,
the values for the decision variables assist evaluation of workforce capacity and capability strategic decisions, and
the workforce capacity and capability model maximizes an expression A−B−C−D−E, where A specifies total revenue allocated, B specifies a cost of service delivery from non-entity-owned sources, C specifies a total entity-owned workforce cost, D specifies a total cross-training cost, and E specifies a penalty of idled regular workforce.

### Claim 19

A system for optimizing a workforce capacity and capability at an entity, comprising:
a processor; and,
a computer-readable data storage medium to store a computer program, and a plurality of parameters related to the workforce capacity and capability at the entity,
wherein the computer program is to apply a workforce capacity and capability model to generate values for a plurality of decision variables related to the workforce capacity and capability at the entity, based on the values for the parameters that have been received, wherein
the workforce capacity and capability model models uncertainty associated with a workforce,
the values for the decision variables assist evaluation of workforce capacity and capability strategic decisions, and
the workforce capacity and capability model maximizes an expression A−B−C−D−E, where A specifies total revenue allocated, B specifies a cost of service delivery from non-entity-owned sources, C specifies a total entity-owned workforce cost, D specifies a total cross-training cost, and E specifies a penalty of idled regular workforce.
