# US 2012/0253723 A1 · System and method for producing statistically valid assay means and ranges for quality control materials

> Agents: this data is available as JSON from the patentgrep API and MCP server — see https://patentgrep.com/llms.txt

- Number: US 2012/0253723 A1
- Document ID: US20120253723A1
- Status: Published application
- Kind: A1
- Application number: 13/074,649
- Filed: 2011-03-29
- Published: 2012-10-04
- Earliest claimed: 2011-03-29
- Assignees: Bio-Rad Laboratories, Inc.
- Inventors: Lakshmi Samyukta Kuchipudi; Curtis Alan Parvin; John Christopher Yundt-Pacheco
- Web page: https://patentgrep.com/patent/US20120253723A1

## CPC

- G06Q 10/20: Administration of product repair or maintenance
- G06Q: INFORMATION AND COMMUNICATION TECHNOLOGY [ICT] SPECIALLY ADAPTED FOR ADMINISTRATIVE, COMMERCIAL, FINANCIAL, MANAGERIAL OR SUPERVISORY PURPOSES; SYSTEMS OR METHODS SPECIALLY ADAPTED FOR ADMINISTRATIVE, COMMERCIAL, FINANCIAL, MANAGERIAL OR SUPERVISORY PURPOSES, NOT OTHERWISE PROVIDED FOR

## Abstract

A method of establishing statistically valid assay means and ranges for quality control materials, used to qualify medical testing machines, utilizes tests on a new lot of quality control material to establish an assay mean, and uses data from a database of historical test results to establish an assay range. The system may estimate the variability of test results from prior lot data, and then compute the limits of the assay range such that a new test on a new lot of the quality control material will be expected to fall within the range with a specified probability. Because historical data is used to estimate the test variability, the number of new tests required to specify a statistically valid mean and range may be dramatically reduced, as compared with establishing the mean and range based only on tests of the new lot of material.

## Claims

### Claim 1

A method of establishing a statistically valid assay mean and assay range for a particular lot of a quality control material, the method comprising:
obtaining a number of test results obtained from tests on a number of samples from the particular lot of the quality control material;
computing a mean of the test results;
accessing a database of historical test results obtained from tests performed on prior lots of the quality control material;
computing at least in part from the historical test results a variability estimate that is an estimate of the variability of test results obtained from tests performed on at least one prior lot of the quality control material;
specifying a target probability with which a new qualification test result performed on a sample of the new lot of quality control material will fall within the assay range; and
computing, based at least in part on the mean and the variability estimate, a range of test result values within which a result from a qualification test of a sample from the particular lot of the quality control material is expected to fall, with the target probability.

### Claim 2 (depends on 1)

The method of claim 1, further comprising testing the samples from the particular lot of the quality control material to obtain the test results.

### Claim 3 (depends on 1)

The method of claim 1, further comprising outputting the range.

### Claim 4 (depends on 1)

The method of claim 1, wherein computing the variability estimate comprises:
computing at least in part from the historical test results an estimate of the uncertainty of the mean;
computing at least in part from the historical test results a within-instrument variability estimate that is an estimate of the variability of test results obtained using a single testing instrument on at least one prior lot of the quality control material; and
computing at least in part from the historical test results a between-instrument variability estimate that is an estimate of the variability of test results obtained using different testing instruments on at least one prior lot of the quality control material;
and wherein computing the range based at least in part on the mean and the variability estimate comprises computing the range based at least in part on the mean, the estimate of the uncertainty of the mean, the within-instrument variability estimate, and the between-instrument variability estimate.

### Claim 5 (depends on 4)

The method of claim 4, further comprising:
setting an upper limit for the percentage of the assay range that is due to uncertainty in estimating the mean; and
establishing a sampling plan, based at least in part on the within- and between-instrument variability estimates, to achieve an assay range having a percentage of its width due to uncertainty in estimating the mean, the percentage being at or below the upper limit.

### Claim 6 (depends on 4)

The method of claim 4, wherein the within-instrument variability estimate is derived from an average of variances, each variance being the variance of test results from a respective one of a plurality of instruments.

### Claim 7 (depends on 4)

The method of claim 4, wherein the between-instrument variability estimate is derived from a variance of averages, each average being an average test result from a respective one of a plurality of instruments.

### Claim 8 (depends on 1)

The method of claim 1, wherein the estimate of the uncertainty of the mean is a standard error of the mean, and the standard error of the mean is computed based at least in part on estimates of variability derived from the database of historical test results.

### Claim 9 (depends on 1)

The method of claim 1, wherein computing the variability estimate at least in part from the historical test results comprises accounting for an observed relationship between the mean and the variability of test results.

### Claim 10 (depends on 1)

The method of claim 1, wherein computing the variability estimate at least in part from the historical test results comprises:
performing a regression using the historical test results to characterize the relationship between the mean and at least one component of the variability; and
adjusting the variability estimate based on the mean and the relationship.

### Claim 11 (depends on 1)

The method of claim 1, wherein computing the variability estimate at least in part from the historical test results comprises:
identifying a specific prior lot of the quality control material that has a mean test result comparable to the mean computed from the test results from the particular lot of quality control material;
computing a variability of test results obtained from tests of the specific prior lot of quality control material; and
assigning to the particular lot of quality control material a variability estimate that is equal to the computed variability of test results from the specific prior lot of quality control material.

### Claim 12 (depends on 1)

The method of claim 1, wherein computing the variability estimate comprises:
computing at least in part from the historical test results an estimate of the uncertainty of the mean;
computing at least in part from the historical test results a within-laboratory variability estimate that is an estimate of the variability of test results obtained within a single laboratory on at least one prior lot of the quality control material; and
computing at least in part from the historical test results a between-laboratory variability estimate that is an estimate of the variability of test results obtained from different laboratories on at least one prior lot of the quality control material;
and wherein computing the range based at least in part on the mean and the variability estimate comprises computing the range based at least in part on the mean, the estimate of the uncertainty of the mean, the within-laboratory variability estimate, and the between- laboratory variability estimate.

### Claim 13 (depends on 1)

The method of claim 1, further comprising removing from consideration anomalous test results found in the database of historical test results.

### Claim 14

A method of establishing a sampling plan for assigning an assay mean and range to a particular lot of a quality control material, the method comprising:
setting an upper limit for the percentage of the assay range that is due to uncertainty in estimating the mean;
accessing a database of historical test results obtained from tests performed on prior lots of the quality control material;
computing at least in part from the historical test results a within-instrument variability estimate that is an estimate of the variability of test results obtained using a single testing instrument on at least one prior lot of the quality control material; and
computing at least in part from the historical test results a between-instrument variability estimate that is an estimate of the variability of test results obtained using different testing instruments on at least one prior lot of the quality control material; and
establishing a sampling plan, based at least in part on the within- and between-instrument variability estimates, to achieve an assay range having a percentage of its width due to uncertainty in estimating the mean, the percentage being at or below the upper limit.

### Claim 15

A system for establishing a statistically valid assay mean and assay range for a particular lot of a quality control material, the system comprising:
a processor;
a database holding historical test results obtained from tests performed on prior lots of the quality control material; and
a memory readable by the processor, the memory holding processor instructions that when executed by the processor cause the system to
obtain a number of test results obtained from tests on a number of samples from the particular lot of the quality control material;
compute a mean of the test results;
access the database of historical test results obtained from tests performed on prior lots of the quality control material;
compute at least in part from the historical test results a variability estimate that is an estimate of the variability of test results obtained from tests performed on at least one prior lot of the quality control material;
receive a specification of a target probability with which a new qualification test result performed on a sample of the new lot of quality control material will fall within the assay range; and
compute, based at least in part on the mean and the variability estimate, a range of test result values within which a result from a qualification test of a sample from the particular lot of the quality control material is expected to fall, with the target probability.

### Claim 16 (depends on 15)

The system of claim 15, wherein the instructions, when executed by the processor to compute the variability estimate, further cause the processor to compute at least in part from the historical test results an estimate of the uncertainty of the mean;
compute at least in part from the historical test results a within-instrument variability estimate that is an estimate of the variability of test results obtained using a single testing instrument on at least one prior lot of the quality control material; and
compute at least in part from the historical test results a between-instrument variability estimate that is an estimate of the variability of test results obtained using different testing instruments on at least one prior lot of the quality control material.

### Claim 17

An assay mean and range assignment system for establishing a statistically valid assay mean and assay range for a particular lot of a quality control material, the system comprising:
a database holding historical test results obtained from tests performed on prior lots of a quality control material;
a mean determination module that receives a number of test results obtained from tests on a number of samples from a new lot of the quality control material and computes a mean of the test results;
a variability estimation module that computes at least in part from the historical test results a variability estimate that is an estimate of the variability of test results obtained from tests performed on at least one prior lot of the quality control material; and
a range establishment module that establishes, based at least in part on the mean and the variability estimate, a range of test result values within which a result from a qualification test of a sample from the new lot of the quality control material is expected to fall, with a target probability.

### Claim 18 (depends on 17)

The system of claim 17, wherein:
the variability estimate comprises a within-instrument variability estimate that is an estimate of the variability of test results obtained using a single testing instrument on at least one prior lot of the quality control material; and
the variability estimate comprises a between-instrument variability estimate that is an estimate of the variability of test results obtained using different testing instruments on at least one prior lot of the quality control material; and
the system further comprises a sampling plan establishment module that establishes a sampling plan based at least in part on the within-instrument variability estimate and the between-instrument variability estimate.

### Claim 19 (depends on 18)

The system of claim 18, wherein the sampling plan establishment module receives a specification of an upper limit for the percentage of the assay range that is due to uncertainty in estimating the mean, and establishes the sampling plan based at least in part on the within-instrument variability estimate, the between-instrument variability estimate, and the upper limit for the percentage of the assay range that is due to uncertainty in estimating the mean.

### Claim 20 (depends on 17)

The system of claim 17, wherein the range establishment module accounts for an observed relationship between the mean and variability of historical test results.

### Claim 21 (depends on 17)

The system of claim 17, wherein:
the variability estimate comprises an estimate the uncertainty of the mean;
the variability estimate comprises a within-instrument variability estimate that is an estimate of the variability of test results obtained using a single testing instrument on at least one prior lot of the quality control material;
the variability estimate comprises a between-instrument variability estimate that is an estimate of the variability of test results obtained using different testing instruments on at least one prior lot of the quality control material; and
the range establishment module establishes the range based at least in part on the mean, the estimate of the uncertainty of the mean, the within-instrument variability estimate, and the between-instrument variability estimate.
