# US 2012/0084066 A1 · System and method for efficient modeling of npskew effects on static timing tests

> Agents: this data is available as JSON from the patentgrep API and MCP server — see https://patentgrep.com/llms.txt

- Number: US 2012/0084066 A1
- Document ID: US20120084066A1
- Status: Published application
- Kind: A1
- Application number: 12/894,286
- Filed: 2010-09-30
- Published: 2012-04-05
- Earliest claimed: 2010-09-30
- Assignees: International Business Machines Corporation
- Inventors: Nathan C. Buck; Brian M. Dreibelbis; John P. Dubuque; Eric A. Foreman; Peter A. Habitz; Jeffrey G. Hemmett; Natesan Venkateswaran; Chandramouli Visweswariah; Xiaoyue X. Wang
- Web page: https://patentgrep.com/patent/US20120084066A1

## CPC

- G06F 13/105: {where the program performs an input/output emulation function}
- G06F 30/367: Design verification, e.g. using simulation, simulation program with integrated circuit emphasis [SPICE], direct methods or relaxation methods
- G06F 11/261: {by simulating additional hardware, e.g. fault simulation}
- G06F 30/00: Computer-aided design [CAD]
- G06F: ELECTRIC DIGITAL DATA PROCESSING (computer systems based on specific computational models G06N)

## Abstract

A computer-implemented method that simulates NPskew effects on a combination NFET (Negative Field Effect Transistor)/PFET (Positive Field Effect Transistor) semiconductor device using slew perturbations includes performing a timing test by a computing device, by: (1) evaluating perturb slews in Strong N/Weak P directions on the combination semiconductor device for a timing test result; (2) evaluation perturb slews in Weak N/Strong P directions on the combination semiconductor device for a timing test result; and (3) evaluating unperturbed slews in a balanced condition on the combination semiconductor device for a timing test result. After each test is performed, a determination is made as to which evaluation of the perturbed and unperturbed slews produces a most conservative timing test result for the combination semiconductor device. An NPskew effect adjusted timing test result is finally output based on determining the most conservative timing test result.

## Claims

### Claim 1

A computer-implemented method that simulates NPskew effects on a combination NFET (Negative Field Effect Transistor)/PFET (Positive Field Effect Transistor) semiconductor device using slew perturbations, said method comprising:
performing a timing test by a computing device, by:
evaluating, by said computing device, perturb slews in Strong N/Weak P directions on said combination semiconductor device for a first timing test result;
evaluating, by said computing device, perturb slews in Weak N/Strong P directions on said combination semiconductor device for a second timing test result; and
evaluating, by said computing device, unperturbed slews in a balanced condition on said combination semiconductor device for a third timing test result;
determining, by said computing device, which evaluation of said perturbed and unperturbed slews produces a most conservative timing test result from said first timing test result, said second timing test result and said third timing test result, for said combination semiconductor device; and
outputting a NPskew effect adjusted timing test result based on said determining said most conservative timing test result.

### Claim 2 (depends on 1)

The computer-implemented method according to claim 1, where said evaluating perturb slews in Strong N/Weak P directions define said first timing test result as:
[AT1−AT2−(P1*(SL1+X1))+(P2*(SL2+X2))−ADJUST−GUARD TIME],
where AT1 is a first arrival time on a first signal,
where AT2 is a second arrival time on a second signal,
where P1 is a percentage of a total time of a first signal transition time to where AT1 occurs along the first signal transition, defined relative to an end of the first signal transition,
where P2 is a percentage of a total time of a second signal transition time to where AT2 occurs along the second signal transition, defined relative to a start of the second signal transition,
where SL1 is a first slew time on the first signal, defined as a first total transition time for the first signal,
where SL2 is a second slew time on the second signal, defined as a second total transition time for the second signal,
where X1 is one of a negatively signed perturbation value applied on the first slew time if the first signal transition is falling, and a positively signed perturbation value applied on the first slew time if the first signal transition is rising, where X1 is equal to the product of the first slew time and one of a constant value, a derived variable adder value and a scalar value,
where X2 is one of a negatively signed perturbation value applied on the second slew time if the second signal transition is falling, and a positively signed perturbation value applied on the second slew time if the second signal transition is rising, where X2 is equal to the product of the second slew time and one of a constant value, a derived variable adder value and a scalar value,
where ADJUST is a signal adjust value; and
where GUARD TIME is a minimum allowable transition time.

### Claim 3 (depends on 1)

The computer-implemented method according to claim 1, where said evaluation perturb slews in Weak N/Strong P directions define said second timing test result as:
[AT1−AT2−(P1*(SL1+X1))+(P2*(SL2+X2))−ADJUST−GUARD TIME],
where AT1 is a first arrival time on a first signal,
where AT2 is a second arrival time on a second signal,
where P1 is a percentage of a total time of a first signal transition time to where AT1 occurs along the first signal transition, defined relative to an end of the first signal transition,
where P2 is a percentage of a total time of a second signal transition time to where AT2 occurs along the second signal transition, defined relative to a start of the second signal transition,
where SL1 is a first slew time on the first signal, defined as a first total transition time for the first signal,
where SL2 is a second slew time on the second signal, defined as a second total transition time for the second signal,
where X1 is one of a positively signed perturbation value applied on the first slew time if the first signal transition is falling, and a negatively signed perturbation value applied on the first slew time if the first transition is rising, where X1 is equal to the product of the first slew time and one of a constant value, a derived variable adder value and a scalar value,
where X2 is one of a positively signed perturbation value applied on the second slew time if the second signal transition is falling, and a negatively signed perturbation value applied on the second slew time if the second signal transition is rising, where X2 is equal to the product of the first slew time and one of a constant value, a derived variable adder value and a scalar value,
where ADJUST is a signal adjust value; and
where GUARD TIME is a minimum allowable transition time.

### Claim 4 (depends on 1)

The computer-implemented method according to claim 1, where said evaluating unperturbed slews in a balanced condition define said third timing test result as:
[AT131 AT2−(P1*SL1)+(P2*SL2)−ADJUST−GUARD TIME],
where AT1 is a first arrival time on a first signal,
where AT2 is a second arrival time on a second signal,
where P1 is a percentage of a total time of a first signal transition time to where AT1 occurs along the first signal transition, defined relative to an end of the first signal transition,
where P2 is a percentage of a total time of a second signal transition time to where AT2 occurs along the second signal transition, defined relative to a start of the second signal transition,
where SL1 is a first slew time on the first signal, defined as a first total transition time for the first signal,
where SL2 is a second slew time on the second signal, defined as a second total transition time for the second signal,
where ADJUST is a signal adjust value; and
where GUARD TIME is a minimum allowable transition time.

### Claim 5 (depends on 1)

The computer-implemented method according to claim 1, where said evaluating perturb slews in Strong N/Weak P directions define said first timing test result as:
[(P1*(SL1+X1))+(P2*(SL2+X2))],
where P1 is a percentage of a total time of a first signal transition time to where a first arrival time on a first signal occurs along the first signal transition, defined relative to an end of the first signal transition,
where P2 is a percentage of a total time of a second signal transition time to where a second arrival time on a second signal occurs along the second signal transition, defined relative to a start of the second signal transition,
where SL1 is a first slew time on the first signal, defined as a first total transition time for the first signal,
where SL2 is a second slew time on the second signal, defined as a second total transition time for the second signal,
where X1 is one of a negatively signed perturbation value applied on the first slew time if the first signal transition is falling, and a positively signed perturbation value applied on the first slew time if the first signal transition is rising, where X1 is equal to the product of the first slew time and one of a constant value, a derived variable adder value and a scalar value, and
where X2 is one of a negatively signed perturbation value applied on the second slew time if the second signal transition is falling, and a positively signed perturbation value applied on the second slew time if the second signal transition is rising, where X2 is equal to the product of the second slew time and one of a constant value, a derived variable adder value and a scalar value.

### Claim 6 (depends on 1)

The computer-implemented method according to claim 1, where said evaluation perturb slews in Weak N/Strong P directions define said second timing test result as:
[(P1*(SL1+X1))+(P2*(SL2+X2))],
where P1 is a percentage of a total time of a first signal transition time to where a first arrival time on a first signal occurs along the first signal transition, defined relative to an end of the first signal transition,
where P2 is a percentage of a total time of a second signal transition time to where a second arrival time on a second signal occurs along the second signal transition, defined relative to a start of the second signal transition,
where SL1 is a first slew time on the first signal, defined as a first total transition time for the first signal,
where SL2 is a second slew time on the second signal, defined as a second total transition time for the second signal,
where X1 is one of a positively signed perturbation value applied on the first slew time if the first signal transition is falling, and a negatively signed perturbation value applied on the first slew time if the first transition is rising, where X1 is equal to the product of the first slew time and one of a constant value, a derived variable adder value and a scalar value, and
where X2 is one of a positively signed perturbation value applied on the second slew time if the second signal transition is falling, and a negatively signed perturbation value applied on the second slew time if the second signal transition is rising, where X2 is equal to the product of the first slew time and one of a constant value, a derived variable adder value and a scalar value.

### Claim 7 (depends on 1)

The computer-implemented method according to claim 1, where said evaluating unperturbed slews in a balanced condition define said third timing test result defined as:
[(P1*SL1)+(P2*SL2)],
where AT1 is a first arrival time on a first signal,
where AT2 is a second arrival time on a second signal,
where P1 is a percentage of a total time of a first signal transition time to where AT1 occurs along the first signal transition, defined relative to an end of the first signal transition,
where P2 is a percentage of a total time of a second signal transition time to where AT2 occurs along the second signal transition, defined relative to a start of the second signal transition,
where SL1 is a first slew time on the first signal, defined as a first total transition time for the first signal, and
where SL2 is a second slew time on the second signal, defined as a second total transition time for the second signal.

### Claim 8 (depends on 1)

The computer-implemented method according to claim 1, where said timing test further comprises one of a pulse width test and an inactive test,
where a first signal is a trailing edge of a signal and a second signal is a leading edge of said signal, and
where a rising transition and a falling transition of said first and said second signals are reversed between said pulse width test and said inactive tests.

### Claim 9 (depends on 1)

The computer-implemented method according to claim 1, where said timing test further comprises a clock gating setup test,
where a first signal is a clock signal, and a second signal is a data signal, and
where at least one of said first signal and said second signal may be one of rising and falling.

### Claim 10 (depends on 1)

The computer-implemented method according to claim 1, where said timing test further comprises a clock gating hold test,
where a first signal is a data signal, and a second signal is a clock signal, and
where at least one of said first signal and said second signal may be one of rising and falling.

### Claim 11

A computer-implemented method that simulates NPskew effects on a combination NFET (Negative Field Effect Transistor)/PFET (Positive Field Effect Transistor) semiconductor device using slew perturbations, said method comprising:
performing a timing test by a computing device by:
evaluating, by said computing device, perturb slews in Strong N/Weak P directions on said combination semiconductor device for a first timing test result;
evaluating, by said computing device, perturb slews in Weak N/Strong P directions on said combination semiconductor device for a second timing test result;
considering a balanced condition on said combination semiconductor device having a null (0) timing test result;
selecting, by said computing device, a smallest solution of said evaluated a timing test result and said null (0) a timing test result as a selected timing test result for said combination semiconductor device; and
outputting a NPskew effect based on said selecting.

### Claim 12 (depends on 11)

The computer-implemented method according to claim 11, where said evaluating perturb slews in Strong N/Weak P directions define said slack adjust value as:
[(P1*X1)+(P2*X2)],
where P1 is a percentage of a total time of a first signal transition time to where a first arrival time of a first signal occurs along the first signal transition time, defined relative to an end of the first signal transition time,
where P2 is a percentage of a total time of a second signal transition time to where a second arrival time of a second signal is defined along the second signal transition time, defined relative to a start of the second signal transition time,
where X1 is one of a negatively signed perturbation value applied on the first slew time if the first signal transition is falling, and a positively signed perturbation value applied on the first slew time if the first signal transition is rising, where X1 is equal to the product of the first slew time and one of a constant value, a derived variable adder value and a scalar value, and
where X2 is one of a negatively signed perturbation value applied on the second slew time if the second signal transition is falling, and a positively signed perturbation value applied on the second slew time if the second signal transition is rising, where X2 is equal to the product of the second slew time and one of a constant value, a derived variable adder value and a scalar value.

### Claim 13 (depends on 11)

The computer-implemented method according to claim 11, where said evaluation perturb slews in Weak N/Strong P directions define said slack adjust value as:
[(P1*X1)+(P2*X2)],
where P1 is a percentage of a total time of a first signal transition time to where a first arrival time on a first signal occurs along the first signal transition, defined relative to an end of the first signal transition,
where P2 is a percentage of a total time of a second signal transition time to where a second arrival time on a second signal occurs along the second signal transition, defined relative to a start of the second signal transition,
where X1 is one of a positively signed perturbation value applied on the first slew time if the first signal transition is falling, and a negatively signed perturbation value applied on the first slew time if the first transition is rising, where X1 is equal to the product of the first slew time and one of a constant value, a derived variable adder value and a scalar value, and
where X2 is one of a positively signed perturbation value applied on the second slew time if the second signal transition is falling, and a negatively signed perturbation value applied on the second slew time if the second signal transition is rising, where X2 is equal to the product of the first slew time and one of a constant value, a derived variable adder value and a scalar value.

### Claim 14 (depends on 13)

The computer-implemented method according to claim 13, where said timing test further comprises one of a pulse width test and an inactive test,
where a first signal is a trailing edge of a signal and a second signal is a leading edge of said signal, and
where a rising transition and a falling transition of said first and said second signals are reversed between said pulse width test and said inactive tests.

### Claim 15 (depends on 13)

The computer-implemented method according to claim 13, where said timing test further comprises a clock gating setup test,
where a first signal is a clock signal, and a second signal is a data signal, and
where at least one of said first signal and said second signal may be one of rising and falling.

### Claim 16 (depends on 13)

The computer-implemented method according to claim 13, where said timing test further comprises a clock gating hold test,
where a first signal is a data signal, and a second signal is a clock signal, and
where at least one of said first signal and said second signal may be one of rising and falling.

### Claim 17

A computer-implemented method that simulates NPskew effects on a combination NFET (Negative Field Effect Transistor)/PFET (Positive Field Effect Transistor) semiconductor device using slew perturbations, said method comprising:
performing a timing test by a computer by evaluating, a slack adjust amount directly in a single perturbation difference equation on said combination semiconductor device for a slack adjust value,
where P1 is equal in value to P2, and
the ratio of SL1 to X1 is equal in value to the ratio of SL2 to X2,
where P1 is a percentage of a total time of a first signal transition time to where a first arrival time on a first signal occurs along the first signal transition, defined relative to an end of the first signal transition,
where P2 is a percentage of a total time of a second signal transition time to where a second arrival time on a second signal occurs along the second signal transition, defined relative to a start of the second signal transition,
where SL1 is a first slew time on the first signal, defined as a first total transition time for the first signal,
where SL2 is a second slew time on the second signal, defined as a second total transition time for the second signal,
where X1 is one of a negatively signed perturbation value applied on the first slew time if the first signal transition is falling, and a positively signed perturbation value applied on the first slew time if the first signal transition is rising, where X1 is equal to the product of the first slew time and one of a constant value, a derived variable adder value and a scalar value, and
where X2 is one of a negatively signed perturbation value applied on the second slew time if the second signal transition is falling, and a positively signed perturbation value applied on the second slew time if the second signal transition is rising, where X2 is equal to the product of the second slew time and one of a constant value, a derived variable adder value and a scalar value.

### Claim 18 (depends on 17)

The computer-implemented method according to claim 17, further comprising:
determining a slack adjust value according to the expression:
[−P*ABSOLUTE VALUE(X1−X2)],
where P is one of P1 and P2.

### Claim 19 (depends on 17)

The computer-implemented method according to claim 17, where said timing test further comprises one of a pulse width test and an inactive test,
where a first signal is a trailing edge of a signal and a second signal is a leading edge of said signal, and
where a rising transition and a falling transition of said first and said second signals are reversed between said pulse width test and said inactive tests.

### Claim 20 (depends on 17)

The computer-implemented method according to claim 17, where said timing test further comprises a clock gating setup test,
where a first signal is a clock signal, and a second signal is a data signal, and
where at least one of said first signal and said second signal may be one of rising and falling.

### Claim 21 (depends on 17)

The computer-implemented method according to claim 17, where said timing test further comprises a clock gating hold test,
where a first signal is a data signal, and a second signal is a clock signal, and
where at least one of said first signal and said second signal may be one of rising and falling.
