# US 2010/0169187 A1 · Revenue raising auction processes for public goods

> Agents: this data is available as JSON from the patentgrep API and MCP server — see https://patentgrep.com/llms.txt

- Number: US 2010/0169187 A1
- Document ID: US20100169187A1
- Status: Published application
- Kind: A1
- Application number: 12/653,125
- Filed: 2009-12-08
- Published: 2010-07-01
- Earliest claimed: 2008-12-08
- Inventors: Stephen K. Swallow; Christopher M. Anderson; Elizabeth C. Smith
- Web page: https://patentgrep.com/patent/US20100169187A1

## CPC

- G06Q 30/02: Marketing; Price estimation or determination; Fundraising
- G06Q 30/0234: Rebates after completed purchase
- G06Q 30/0279: Fundraising management
- G06Q 30/0601: Electronic shopping [e-shopping]
- Y02A 40/22: Improving land use; Improving water use or availability; Controlling erosion
- G06Q: INFORMATION AND COMMUNICATION TECHNOLOGY [ICT] SPECIALLY ADAPTED FOR ADMINISTRATIVE, COMMERCIAL, FINANCIAL, MANAGERIAL OR SUPERVISORY PURPOSES; SYSTEMS OR METHODS SPECIALLY ADAPTED FOR ADMINISTRATIVE, COMMERCIAL, FINANCIAL, MANAGERIAL OR SUPERVISORY PURPOSES, NOT OTHERWISE PROVIDED FOR
- Y02A: TECHNOLOGIES FOR ADAPTATION TO CLIMATE CHANGE

## Abstract

A computer system for a pricing and auction process allows private enterprise firms to establish an individual price for each consumer paying in to support delivery of the same units of a public good. The process solicits bids from individuals who value a public good, while reducing each individual's incentives to free ride, thereby increasing their incentives to bid or offer a payment that approaches their full value for each, successive unit of the good. Examples include farmers selling the services of land for wildlife habitat, farmers altering production processes to reduce pesticides and nutrients and increase local water quality, particularly during transition from technologically intensive farming to organic farming, or businesses established to help neighborhoods and communities become carbon neutral in a global economy. The process benefits profit or non-profit organizations supporting conservation such as wetland and salt marsh restoration or restoration of endangered species habitat.

## Claims

### Claim 1

A revenue raising auction process for public goods, which said process reduces the incentive for individuals to free ride, on the voluntary monetary support from others, during the individual's use and enjoyment of public goods, comprising the steps of:
providing a computer system with a microprocessor for implementing a revenue raising auction process for public goods;
a database for receiving and storing data;
said database having data processing systems and a microprocessor by which a firm provides said revenue raising auction,
said firm establishing an ability to deliver by pre-signing contracts with individuals or entities capable of supplying increments of public goods to a community of beneficiaries and to deliver said public goods to said defined population and/or community of beneficiaries;
said firm soliciting individual bids from said beneficiaries acting as consumer-bidder beneficiaries;
wherein said consumer-bidder beneficiaries are asked to make said bids conditional on numbers of units of said public goods delivered;
wherein said contracts to supply increments of public goods include withholding delivery of said public goods without sufficient payment from said community of consumer-bidder beneficiaries;
said firm offering a rebate of funds, and,
said rebate of funds based on the application of incentives to reduce free riding behavior as bidders make bids on each marginal unit.

### Claim 2 (depends on 1)

The revenue raising auction process for public goods as in claim 1 where said firm's offering of a rebate of funds is a proportionate rebate of funds in excess of cost of delivery.

### Claim 3 (depends on 1)

The revenue raising auction process for public goods as in claim 1 where said firm's offering of said rebate of funds is a rebate on a marginal unit while charging said consumer-bidder beneficiaries for infra-marginal units.

### Claim 4 (depends on 1)

The revenue raising auction process for public goods as in claim 1 wherein the firm communicates with the consumer-bidder beneficiaries via a browser controlling communications over a network;
said computer system further comprising a server, wherein said firm communicates with a defined population and/or community of beneficiaries through said server;
wherein said firm is formed to interact with said computer system via the internet with corresponding computer systems having internet connections in respective locations where said beneficiaries participate in said revenue raising auction process;

### Claim 5 (depends on 1)

The revenue raising auction process for public goods as in claim 1 wherein the firm communicates with the consumer-bidder beneficiaries via an in situ intranet controlling communications over a local area network;

### Claim 6 (depends on 1)

The revenue raising auction process for public goods as in claim 1 wherein the firm communicates with the consumer-bidder beneficiaries at a single clearinghouse location having a computer communicating visual data in a power point presentation to the consumer-bidder beneficiaries attending the revenue raising auction at said single clearinghouse location.

### Claim 7 (depends on 4)

The revenue raising auction process for public goods as in claim 4 wherein said computer communicates via said server over the Internet with respective personal digital assistant (PDA's) electronic devices of the consumer-bidder beneficiaries.

### Claim 8 (depends on 4)

The revenue raising auction process for public goods as in claim 4 wherein said computer communicates via said server over the Internet with respective laptop/notebook computers of the consumer-bidder beneficiaries.

### Claim 9

A computer system and method of raising revenue for a public good comprising the steps of:
providing a computer system for implementing a revenue raising auction process for public goods;
a database for receiving and storing data;
said database having data processing systems and a microprocessor by which a firm provides said revenue raising auction;
a broker/auctioneer entering into a conditional contract with an entity capable of supplying at least one unit of said public good;
said broker/auctioneer identifying and establishing an electronic data base of a defined population which would benefit from said public good;
said broker/auctioneer using a local area network or the internet to solicit from members of said defined population bids for contributing funds to be used to fulfill obligations under said contract;
said broker/auctioneer using said local area network, internet and other media to publish auction rules for establishing individualized prices to be charged to members of said defined population;
finalizing said conditional contract when sufficient funds are acquired to pay for completion for said at least one unit of the common public good;
said broker/auctioneer using said microprocessor in determining, under published auction rules, individualized prices charged to members of said defined population who bid on at least one unit of said public good;
said entity proceeding to use said microprocessor to account for and to collect revenues through said individualized prices and to carry out provisions of said contract with respect to said public good, all members of said defined population benefiting from said public good including those members who did not contribute anything toward said public good.

### Claim 10 (depends on 9)

The method of claim 9 in which said at least one unit of public good is a plurality of units of public good.

### Claim 11 (depends on 10)

The method of claim 10 in which funds collected in excess of that required to pay for the last unit provided of said plurality of units of public good are returned proportionately to members of said population who contributed to said last unit of public good thereby establishing an individualized price for each bidder on all other said units of said plurality of units of public good and creating an incentive to members of said population to offer bids.

### Claim 12 (depends on 10)

The method of claim 10 in which funds collected in excess of that required to pay for said plurality of units of public good are used toward a greater number of units of said public good, or are used to provide extended benefits through provision of units of some other public good.

### Claim 13 (depends on 10)

The method of claim 10 in which funds collected from or offered by an individual bidder on a last unit of said plurality of units of the public good, such that these funds create an excess of that required to pay for said last unit of said plurality of units of the public good, establish the individual bidders price on all other provided units of said public good while an individual bidder pays a discounted price between the individual bidder's last-unit offer and zero, for said last unit of said public good, thereby creating an incentive for members of said population to offer bids;
said broker/auctioneer using any excess funds collected by this method on respective units other than and prior to the last unit of said plurality of units of public good provided to pay all or part of the costs of providing said last unit, with or without matching funds provided by an additional party to pay for or assist with paying for said last unit;
and said additional party being at least one of a philanthropic donor to the provision of said public good or at least one government agency supporting the public good through government funding.

### Claim 14

A computer system and a method of selling multiple units of one or more public goods to a community of beneficiaries comprising:
providing a computer system for implementing a revenue raising auction process for public goods including at least one of environmentally related goods, cultural goods, or public, non-environmental, non-cultural goods that benefit numerous people simultaneously;
a database for receiving and storing data;
said computer having a microprocessor and a database having data processing systems by which a broker/auctioneer provides said revenue raising auction,
said microprocessor determining individualized prices of said auction process that enable raising of revenues to cover costs of provision of selected units of public good, including normal return to business;
said individualized prices being part of a pricing framework analogous to a Lindahl pricing framework,
said process reducing free-riding behavior of beneficiaries of the selected units of public good by altering incentives for marginal bids, thereby said auction process reducing incentives of said beneficiaries of the public good to free ride at the margin and thereby encouraging higher bids that approach the individual bidder's full value;
said auction process further comprising a practical method to elicit higher bids from participant bidders of said beneficiaries of a public good;
said auction process establishing a contract right to deliver a public good to a community of participant bidders of said community of beneficiaries,
wherein said broker/auctioneer uses said microprocessor of said computer system to establish an ability to control delivery of the public good to said participant bidders of said community of beneficiaries;
said auction process further comprising a platform enhancing the delivery and increasing the quantity of the public goods provided through at least one of
a) private, non-profit, non-governmental action,
b) private, for profit, non-governmental action,
c) private non-profit action in conjunction with government action,
d) private for profit action in conjunction with government action, or,
e) combinations thereof.

### Claim 15 (depends on 14)

The computer system and a method of selling multiple units of one or more public goods to a community of beneficiaries as in claim 14,
wherein said broker/auctioneer requests said participant bidders of said community of beneficiaries to make bid offers starting from a first unit of said plurality of units of public good to be provided and continuing to make bids on successive units up to some maximum number of units chosen by the broker/auctioneer and then,
based on collecting said bids from each bidder on each unit of said plurality of units of public good, said broker/auctioneer analyzes bids received on the first unit of public good to determine with said microprocessor whether first-unit bids are sufficient to cover first-unit delivery costs, wherein further said broker/auctioneer proceeds to evaluate with said microprocessor the second-unit bids for sufficiency to cover second-unit delivery costs, wherein further said broker/auctioneer proceeds with said microprocessor in like manner with successive bids until identifying a unit (herein termed “the last unit”) prior to the first instance when unit-specific bids received are insufficient to cover unit-specific delivery costs, thereby establishing said last unit as the last unit that may be delivered,
wherein said broker/auctioneer uses individual bidders' bids on said last unit to establish with said microprocessor a per-unit price (herein termed an “individualized price”) to be paid on each unit by the corresponding individual bidder,
wherein said broker/auctioneer uses said microprocessor to provide incentives to said respective bidders by determining at least one of:
a) the proportional rebate method wherein said individualized price on all units for each participant-bidder equals said participant-bidders bid minus any rebate of said participant-bidders bid in proportion to the excess of funds from the sum of all bidders said last unit bids over the delivery cost of said last unit; or
b) wherein by the pivotal bidder method said individualized price on all units before said last unit for each participant-bidder equals the participant-bidders bid on said last unit, while the discount price paid by each participant-bidder for the last unit is the amount of the participant-bidders bid on the last unit that is just enough to cover said last-unit delivery costs when added to the sum of all last-unit bids by all other bidders.

### Claim 16 (depends on 14)

The computer system and a method of selling multiple units of one or more public goods to a community of beneficiaries as in claim 14, in which said broker/auctioneer enters into a conditional contract for a maximum quantity of said units of public good that could be delivered, said broker/auctioneer requesting bids for a per-unit price for said maximum quantity, following up by requesting in succession bids for fewer units of said units of public good, and
based on collecting said bids the broker/auctioneer uses said microprocessor to analyze unit-specific bids from the last potentially available unit backward toward the first potentially available unit, wherein said broker/auctioneer uses said microprocessor to stop analysis at the first instance when the sum of unit-specific bids sufficient to cover corresponding unit-specific delivery costs, thereby establishing said specific unit as the last unit that may be provided.

### Claim 17 (depends on 14)

The computer system and a method of selling multiple units of one or more public goods to a community of beneficiaries as in claim 14,
wherein said broker/auctioneer uses said microprocessor to determine that said units of public good are to be delivered when a sum of marginal bids exceeds a provision point for at least one unit of public good; said broker/auctioneer uses said microprocessor in analyzing subsequent bids of subsequent units of public good until said broker/auctioneer determines with said microprocessor a last unit that may be provided given the total number of bids received from said participant bidders and said broker/auctioneer establishing a final-round of bidding offers;
wherein said broker/auctioneer then uses said microprocessor to determine a discount price that each said participant bidder pays on said last unit of public good provided and a price that said participant bidders pay on said previously bid-on infra-marginal units of public good before said bid on said last unit;
wherein said discount price is determined by said microprocessor for each said participant bidder on said last unit is calculated as a proportion of each said participant bidder's bid on said last unit that is required in order to meet a provision point for said last unit set equal to the amount of money needed to bring the sum of all bids from all participant bidders up to said provision point,
wherein further said microprocessor determines an individualized price for each said participant bidder for infra-marginal units is equal to said participant bidder's bid on said last unit provided.

### Claim 18 (depends on 14)

The computer system and a method of selling multiple units of one or more public goods to a community of beneficiaries as in claim 14, in which funds collected in excess of that required to pay for said unit of public good are returned proportionately to members of said population who contributed to said unit of public good thereby creating an incentive to members of said population to offer bids.

### Claim 19 (depends on 16)

The computer system and a method of selling multiple units of one or more public goods to a community of beneficiaries as in claim 16 wherein said broker/auctioneer establishes unit specific prices as stated by a proportional rebate method wherein said individualized price on all units for each participant-bidder equals said participant-bidders bid minus any rebate of said participant-bidders bid in proportion to the excess of funds from the sum of all bidders said last unit bids over the delivery cost of said last unit.

### Claim 20 (depends on 16)

The computer system and a method of selling multiple units of one or more public goods to a community of beneficiaries as in claim 16 wherein said broker/auctioneer establishes unit specific prices as stated by a pivotal bidder method. wherein by the pivotal bidder method said individualized price on all units before said last unit for each participant-bidder equals the participant-bidders bid on said last unit, while the discount price paid by each participant-bidder for the last unit is the amount of the participant-bidders bid on the last unit that is just enough to cover said last-unit delivery costs when added to the sum of all last-unit bids by all other bidders.
