In a method of processing comestible materials in order to produce a substantially fully cooked extrudate selected from the group consisting of pet feeds and aquatic feeds, said method comprising the steps of passing a comestible material including a starch-bearing ingredient through a cooking extruder having an elongated, tubular barrel with an inlet and an outlet and presenting a longitudinal axis, a restrictive orifice die plate disposed across said outlet, and an elongated, axially rotatable, helically flighted screw within said barrel, said passing step comprising the step of imparting an SME to said material, the improvement which comprises imparting an SME of up to about 18 kWhr/T to a pet food extrudate, and up to about 16 kWhr/T to an aquatic feed extrudate.