# US 2006/0078169 A1 · Method of evaluating image, device for supporting evaluation of image, and image processing apparatus

> Agents: this data is available as JSON from the patentgrep API and MCP server — see https://patentgrep.com/llms.txt

- Number: US 2006/0078169 A1
- Document ID: US20060078169A1
- Status: Published application
- Kind: A1
- Application number: 11/213,921
- Filed: 2005-08-30
- Published: 2006-04-13
- Earliest claimed: 2004-10-07
- Assignees: Brother Kogyo Kabushiki Kaisha
- Inventors: Masashi Ueda
- Web page: https://patentgrep.com/patent/US20060078169A1

## CPC

- G06T 7/0004: {Industrial image inspection}
- G06V 10/993: {Evaluation of the quality of the acquired pattern}
- G06T 2207/30144: Printing quality
- G06T: IMAGE DATA PROCESSING OR GENERATION, IN GENERAL
- G06V: IMAGE OR VIDEO RECOGNITION OR UNDERSTANDING

## Abstract

A method of evaluating an image, including: (a) obtaining evaluation-image data of an evaluation image to be evaluated, the evaluation-image data including coordinate-position data indicative of coordinate positions in the evaluation image and optical-characteristic-value data indicative of optical characteristic values at respective coordinate positions; (b) identifying, based on the evaluation-image data, a characteristic-value fluctuation which is a fluctuation of the optical characteristic values of the evaluation image in relation to the coordinate positions; (c) estimating, based on the evaluation-image data, an unperceivable low-frequency-fluctuation component which is one component of the characteristic-value fluctuation and which is a component that cannot be perceived due to a considerably low frequency of the fluctuation; and (d) evaluating the evaluation image based on the characteristic-value fluctuation and the unperceivable low-frequency-fluctuation component.

## Claims

### Claim 1

A method of evaluating an image, comprising:
(a) obtaining evaluation-image data of an evaluation image to be evaluated, the evaluation-image data including coordinate-position data indicative of coordinate positions in the evaluation image and optical-characteristic-value data indicative of optical characteristic values at respective coordinate positions;
(b) identifying, based on the evaluation-image data, a characteristic-value fluctuation which is a fluctuation of the optical characteristic values of the evaluation image in relation to the coordinate positions;
(c) estimating, based on the evaluation-image data, an unperceivable low-frequency-fluctuation component which is one component of the characteristic-value fluctuation and which is a component that cannot be perceived due to a considerably low frequency of the fluctuation; and
(d) evaluating the evaluation image based on the characteristic-value fluctuation and the unperceivable low-frequency-fluctuation component.

### Claim 2 (depends on 1)

The method according to claim 1, wherein (d) the evaluating the evaluation image comprises evaluating a degree of irregularity in the evaluation image.

### Claim 3 (depends on 1)

The method according to claim 1,
wherein (b) the identifying a characteristic-value fluctuation comprises identifying the characteristic-value fluctuation in a specific direction of the evaluation image,
wherein (c) the estimating an unperceivable low-frequency-fluctuation component comprises estimating the unperceivable low-frequency-fluctuation component in the specific direction of the evaluation image, and
wherein (d) the evaluating the evaluation image comprises evaluating the evaluation image in the specific direction.

### Claim 4 (depends on 1)

The method according to claim 1, wherein (d) the evaluating the evaluation image comprises: identifying, based on the characteristic-value fluctuation and the unperceivable low-frequency-fluctuation component, an evaluation index which is an index in evaluating the evaluation image; and evaluating the evaluation image based on the evaluation index.

### Claim 5 (depends on 1)

The method according to claim 1, wherein (d) the evaluating the evaluation image comprises: identifying an unperceivable-low-frequency-component-excluded fluctuation component of the evaluation image in relation to the coordinate positions, the unperceivable-low-frequency-component-excluded fluctuation component being obtained by excluding the unperceivable low-frequency-fluctuation component from the characteristic-value fluctuation; and evaluating the evaluation image based on the unperceivable-low-frequency-component-excluded fluctuation component.

### Claim 6 (depends on 5)

The method according to claim 5, which is a method wherein an evaluation index which is an index in evaluating the evaluation image is identified based on the characteristic-value fluctuation and the unperceivable low-frequency-fluctuation component, and wherein the evaluation image is evaluated based on the evaluation index, and
wherein (d) the evaluating the evaluation image comprises: identifying the evaluation index based on the unperceivable-low-frequency-component-excluded fluctuation component; and evaluating the evaluation image based on the evaluation index.

### Claim 7 (depends on 6)

The method according to claim 6, wherein (d) the evaluating the evaluation image comprises: identifying, as the evaluation index, a maximum value of an absolute value of the unperceivable-low-frequency-component-excluded fluctuation component; and evaluating the evaluation image based on the maximum value.

### Claim 8 (depends on 1)

The method according to claim 1, wherein (c) the estimating an unperceivable low-frequency-fluctuation component comprises forming, based on the evaluation-image data, at least one simulation function which simulates the unperceivable low-frequency fluctuation component and which uses the coordinate position as a variable.

### Claim 9 (depends on 8)

The method according to claim 8, which is a method wherein the characteristic-value fluctuation is identified in a specific direction of the evaluation image, wherein the unperceivable low-frequency-fluctuation component is estimated in the specific direction of the evaluation image, and wherein the evaluation image is evaluated in the specific direction, and
wherein (c) the estimating an unperceivable low-frequency-fluctuation component comprises forming, as each of the at least one simulation function, a function of an n-th order which uses the coordinate position in the specific direction as a variable.

### Claim 10 (depends on 8)

The method according to claim 8, wherein (c) the estimating an unperceivable low-frequency-fluctuation component comprises forming the at least one simulation function by performing operation according to a least square method on the evaluation-image data.

### Claim 11 (depends on 8)

The method according to claim 8, wherein (c) the estimating an unperceivable low-frequency-fluctuation component comprises forming the at least one simulation function whose order is in a range of 1-4.

### Claim 12 (depends on 8)

The method according to claim 8, wherein (c) the estimating an unperceivable low-frequency-fluctuation component comprises forming, as the at least one simulation function, a plurality of simulation functions having mutually different numbers of order.

### Claim 13 (depends on 12)

The method according to claim 12, which is a method wherein an unperceivable-low-frequency-component-excluded fluctuation component of the evaluation image in relation to the coordinate positions is identified, the unperceivable-low-frequency-component-excluded fluctuation component being obtained by excluding the unperceivable low-frequency-fluctuation component from the characteristic-value fluctuation, and wherein the evaluation image is evaluated based on the unperceivable-low-frequency-component-excluded fluctuation component, and
wherein (c) the estimating an unperceivable low-frequency-fluctuation component comprises estimating a plurality of the unperceivable-low-frequency-component-excluded fluctuation components by the plurality of simulation functions, respectively, and
wherein (d) the evaluating the evaluation image comprises evaluating the evaluation image based on the plurality of the unperceivable-low-frequency-component-excluded fluctuation components.

### Claim 14 (depends on 13)

The method according to claim 13, which is a method wherein an evaluation index which is an index in evaluating the evaluation image is identified on the basis of the unperceivable-low-frequency-component-excluded fluctuation component which is based on the characteristic-value fluctuation and the unperceivable low-frequency-fluctuation component, and wherein the evaluation image is evaluated based on the evaluation index, and
wherein (d) the evaluating the evaluation image comprises: identifying a plurality of the evaluation indices based on the plurality of the unperceivable-low-frequency-component-excluded fluctuation components; and evaluating the evaluation image based on the plurality of the evaluation indices.

### Claim 15 (depends on 14)

The method according to claim 14, wherein (d) the evaluating the evaluation image comprises: selecting, based on interrelationship of the plurality of the evaluation indices, one evaluation index to be utilized in evaluating the evaluation image; and evaluating the evaluation image based on the selected one evaluation index.

### Claim 16 (depends on 1)

The method according to claim 1, wherein (b) the identifying a characteristic-value fluctuation comprises identifying the characteristic-value fluctuation from which an unperceivable high-frequency fluctuation component has been at least excluded.

### Claim 17 (depends on 16)

The method according to claim 16, wherein (b) the identifying a characteristic-value fluctuation comprises identifying the characteristic-value fluctuation component from which the unperceivable high-frequency fluctuation component has been at least excluded with a result of performing of smoothing operation on the evaluation-image data.

### Claim 18 (depends on 16)

The method according to claim 16, wherein (b) the identifying a characteristic-value fluctuation comprises: identifying a basic characteristic-value fluctuation which is a basis of the characteristic-value fluctuation; forming spatial-frequency characteristic data by performing Fourier transformation on the basic characteristic-value fluctuation; performing filter operation on the spatial-frequency characteristic data for excluding at least the unperceivable high-frequency component; and performing inverse Fourier transformation on the spatial-frequency characteristic data which has been subjected to the filter operation.

### Claim 19

A method of evaluating an image forming characteristic of an image forming apparatus, comprising:
obtaining evaluation-image data of an evaluation image which is a basis of evaluation and which is formed by the image forming apparatus whose image forming characteristic is to be evaluated, the evaluation-image data including coordinate-position data indicative of coordinate positions in the evaluation image and optical-characteristic-value data indicative of optical characteristic values at respective coordinate positions;
identifying, based on the evaluation-image data, a characteristic-value fluctuation which is a fluctuation of the optical characteristic values of the evaluation image in relation to the coordinate positions;
estimating, based on the evaluation-image data, an unperceivable low-frequency-fluctuation component which is one component of the characteristic-value fluctuation and which is a component that cannot be perceived due to a considerably low frequency of the fluctuation; and
evaluating the image forming characteristic of the image forming apparatus by evaluating the evaluation image based on the characteristic-value fluctuation and the unperceivable low-frequency-fluctuation component.

### Claim 20

A device for supporting evaluation of an image, comprising:
an evaluation-image-data obtaining portion which obtains evaluation-image data of an evaluation image to be evaluated, the evaluation-image data including coordinate-position data indicative of coordinate positions in the evaluation image and optical-characteristic-value data indicative of optical characteristic values at respective coordinate positions;
a characteristic-value-fluctuation identifying portion which identifies, based on the evaluation-image data, a characteristic-value fluctuation which is a fluctuation of the optical characteristic values of the evaluation image in relation to the coordinate positions;
an unperceivable-low-frequency-fluctuation-component estimating portion which estimates, based on the evaluation-image data, an unperceivable low-frequency-fluctuation component which is one component of the characteristic-value fluctuation and which is a component that cannot be perceived due to a considerably low frequency of the fluctuation; and
an evaluation-index identifying portion which identifies, based on the characteristic-value fluctuation and the unperceivable low-frequency-fluctuation component, an evaluation index which is an index in evaluating the evaluation image.

### Claim 21

A device for supporting evaluation of an image forming characteristic of an image forming apparatus, comprising:
an evaluation-image-data obtaining portion which obtains evaluation-image data of an evaluation image that is a basis of evaluation and that is formed by the image forming apparatus whose image forming characteristic is to be evaluated, the evaluation-image data including coordinate-position data indicative of coordinate positions in the evaluation image and optical-characteristic-value data indicative of optical characteristic values at respective coordinate positions;
a characteristic-value-fluctuation identifying portion which identifies, based on the evaluation-image data, a characteristic-value fluctuation which is a fluctuation of the optical characteristic values of the evaluation image in relation to the coordinate positions;
an unperceivable-low-frequency-fluctuation-component estimating portion which estimates, based on the evaluation-image data, an unperceivable low-frequency-fluctuation component which is one component of the characteristic-value fluctuation and which is a component that cannot be perceived due to a considerably low frequency of the fluctuation; and
an evaluation-index identifying portion which identifies, based on the characteristic-value fluctuation and the unperceivable low-frequency-fluctuation component, an evaluation index with respect to the evaluation image which is an index in evaluating the image forming characteristic of the image forming apparatus.

### Claim 22

A program executed by a computer for evaluating an image, comprising:
an evaluation-image-data obtaining step of obtaining evaluation-image data of an evaluation image to be evaluated, the evaluation-image data including coordinate-position data indicative of coordinate positions in the evaluation image and optical-characteristic-value data indicative of optical characteristic values at respective coordinate positions;
a characteristic-value-fluctuation identifying step of identifying, based on the evaluation-image data, a characteristic-value fluctuation which is a fluctuation of the optical characteristic values of the evaluation image in relation to the coordinate positions;
an unperceivable-low-frequency-fluctuation-component estimating step of estimating, based on the evaluation-image data, an unperceivable low-frequency-fluctuation component which is one component of the characteristic-value fluctuation and which is a component that cannot be perceived due to a considerably low frequency of the fluctuation; and
an evaluation-index identifying step of identifying, based on the characteristic-value fluctuation and the unperceivable low-frequency-fluctuation component, an evaluation index which is an index in evaluating the evaluation image.

### Claim 23 (depends on 22)

A recording medium in which the program according to claim 22 is readably recorded.

### Claim 24

A program executed by a computer for evaluating an image forming characteristic of an image forming apparatus, comprising:
an evaluation-image-data obtaining step of obtaining evaluation-image data of an evaluation image which is a basis of evaluation and which is formed by the image forming apparatus whose image forming characteristic is to be evaluated, the evaluation-image data including coordinate-position data indicative of coordinate positions in the evaluation image and optical-characteristic-value data indicative of optical characteristic values at respective coordinate positions;
a characteristic-value-fluctuation identifying step of identifying, based on the evaluation-image data, a characteristic-value fluctuation which is a fluctuation of the optical characteristic values of the evaluation image in relation to the coordinate positions;
an unperceivable-low-frequency-fluctuation-component estimating step of estimating, based on the evaluation-image data, an unperceivable low-frequency-fluctuation component which is one component of the characteristic-value fluctuation and which is a component that cannot be perceived due to a considerably low frequency of the fluctuation; and
an evaluation-index identifying step of identifying, based on the characteristic-value fluctuation and the unperceivable low-frequency-fluctuation component, an evaluation index which is related to the evaluation image and which is an index in evaluating the image forming characteristic of the image forming apparatus.

### Claim 25 (depends on 24)

A recording medium in which the program according to claim 24 is readably recorded.

### Claim 26

An image processing apparatus comprising: an image forming device which forms an image on an image-formation medium; image-information reading device which can read information of the image formed on the image-formation medium; and a control device which controls the image processing apparatus,
wherein the control device includes: (A) an evaluation-image-forming control portion which controls the image forming device to form, on the image-formation medium, an evaluation image for evaluating an image forming characteristic of the image forming device; (B) an evaluation-image-data-obtaining control portion which controls the image-information reading device to read information of the evaluation image and obtains, based on the information, evaluation-image data of the evaluation image which includes coordinate position data indicative of coordinate positions in the evaluation image and optical-characteristic-value data indicative of optical characteristic values at respective coordinate positions; (C) a characteristic-value-fluctuation identifying portion which identifies, based on the evaluation-image data, a characteristic-value fluctuation which is a fluctuation of the optical characteristic values of the evaluation image in relation to the coordinate positions; (D) an unperceivable-low-frequency-fluctuation-component estimating portion which estimates, based on the evaluation-image data, an unperceivable low-frequency-fluctuation component which is one component of the characteristic-value fluctuation and which is a component that cannot be perceived due to a considerably low frequency of the fluctuation; and (E) an evaluation-index identifying portion which identifies, based on the characteristic-value fluctuation and the unperceivable low-frequency-fluctuation component, an evaluation index which is related to the evaluation image and which is an index in evaluating the image forming characteristic of the image forming device, and
wherein the control device has a function of supporting evaluation of the image forming characteristic of the image forming device.
