# US 2003/0203223 A1 · Titanium-containing interference pigments and foils with color shifting properties

> Agents: this data is available as JSON from the patentgrep API and MCP server — see https://patentgrep.com/llms.txt

- Number: US 2003/0203223 A1
- Document ID: US20030203223A1
- Status: Published application
- Kind: A1
- Application number: 10/413,092
- Filed: 2003-04-14
- Published: 2003-10-30
- Earliest claimed: 2000-10-10
- Assignees: Flex Products, Inc.
- Inventors: Roger W. Phillips; Charlotte R. LeGallee; Paul T. Kohlmann; Vladimir Raksha; Alberto Argoitia
- Web page: https://patentgrep.com/patent/US20030203223A1

## CPC

- G02B 5/285: {comprising deposited thin solid films (G02B5/281 - G02B5/289 take precedence; multilayered film filters for fibre optic multiplexing G02B6/29361)}
- C09C 1/0015: {Pigments exhibiting interference colours, e.g. transparent platelets of appropriate thinness or flaky substrates, e.g. mica, bearing appropriate thin transparent coatings}
- C09C 1/0021: {comprising a core coated with only one layer having a high or low refractive index}
- C09C 1/0066: {consisting of at least one coloured inorganic material}
- C09C 1/0078: {Pigments consisting of flaky, non-metallic substrates, characterised by a surface-region containing free metal}
- C09D 5/36: Pearl essence, e.g. coatings containing platelet-like pigments for pearl lustre
- C01P 2006/60: Optical properties, e.g. expressed in CIELAB-values
- C01P 2006/62: L* (lightness axis)
- C01P 2006/63: a* (red-green axis)
- C01P 2006/64: b* (yellow-blue axis)
- C01P 2006/65: Chroma (C*)
- C01P 2006/66: Hue (H*)
- C09C 2200/1054: the core consisting of a metal
- C09C 2200/1058: comprising a protective coating on the metallic layer
- C09C 2200/301: Thickness of the core
- C09C 2220/106: comprising only a drying or calcination step of the finally coated pigment
- C09C 2220/20: PVD, CVD methods or coating in a gas-phase using a fluidized bed
- Y10T 428/12028: Composite; i.e., plural, adjacent, spatially distinct metal components [e.g., layers, etc.]
- Y10T 428/12056: Entirely inorganic
- Y10T 428/12181: Composite powder [e.g., coated, etc.]
- Y10T 428/1259: Oxide
- Y10T 428/12618: Plural oxides
- Y10T 428/24942: including components having same physical characteristic in differing degree
- Y10T 428/265: 1 mil or less
- Y10T 428/2982: Particulate matter [e.g., sphere, flake, etc.]
- Y10T 428/2991: Coated
- Y10T 428/2993: Silicic or refractory material containing [e.g., tungsten oxide, glass, cement, etc.]
- Y10T 428/2996: Glass particles or spheres
- G02B: OPTICAL ELEMENTS, SYSTEMS OR APPARATUS
- C09C: TREATMENT OF INORGANIC MATERIALS, OTHER THAN FIBROUS FILLERS, TO ENHANCE THEIR PIGMENTING OR FILLING PROPERTIES (treatment of materials specially adapted to enhance their filling properties in mortars, concrete or artificial stone C04B14/00, C04B18/00, C04B20/00); PREPARATION OF CARBON BLACK {; PREPARATION OF INORGANIC MATERIALS WHICH ARE NO SINGLE CHEMICAL COMPOUNDS AND WHICH ARE MAINLY USED AS PIGMENTS OR FILLERS}
- C09D: COATING COMPOSITIONS, e.g. PAINTS, VARNISHES OR LACQUERS; FILLING PASTES; CHEMICAL PAINT OR INK REMOVERS; INKS; CORRECTING FLUIDS; WOODSTAINS; PASTES OR SOLIDS FOR COLOURING OR PRINTING; USE OF MATERIALS THEREFOR (cosmetics A61K; processes for applying liquids or other fluent materials to surfaces, in general, B05D; staining wood B27K5/02; glazes or vitreous enamels C03C; natural resins, French polish, drying-oils, driers, turpentine, per se, C09F; polishing compositions other than French polish, ski waxes C09G; adhesives or use of materials as adhesives C09J; materials for sealing or packing joints or covers C09K3/10; materials for stopping leaks C09K3/12; processes for the electrolytic or electrophoretic production of coatings C25D)
- C01P: INDEXING SCHEME RELATING TO STRUCTURAL AND PHYSICAL ASPECTS OF SOLID INORGANIC COMPOUNDS
- Y10T: TECHNICAL SUBJECTS COVERED BY FORMER US CLASSIFICATION

## Abstract

Interference pigment flakes and foils are provided which have color shifting properties. The pigment flakes can have a symmetrical coating structure on opposing sides of a reflector layer, can have an asymmetrical coating structure with all of the layers on one side of the reflector layer, or can be formed with encapsulating coatings around a core reflector layer. The coating structure of the flakes and foils includes a reflector layer, a dielectric layer on the reflector layer, and a titanium-containing absorber layer on the dielectric layer. The pigment flakes and foils exhibit a discrete color shift so as to have a first color at a first angle of incident light or viewing and a second color different from the first color at a second angle of incident light or viewing. The pigment flakes can be interspersed into liquid media such as paints or inks to produce colorant compositions for subsequent application to objects or papers. The foils can be laminated to various objects or can be formed on a carrier substrate.

## Claims

### Claim 1

A color shifting pigment flake, comprising:
a reflector layer;
a first dielectric layer on the reflector layer; and
a first titanium-containing absorber layer on the first dielectric layer, the absorber layer comprising an absorbing material substantially free of titanium dioxide;
wherein the pigment flake exhibits a discrete color shift such that the pigment flake has a first color at a first angle of incident light or viewing and a second color different from the first color at a second angle of incident light or viewing.

### Claim 2 (depends on 1)

The pigment flake of claim 1, further comprising a second dielectric layer on the reflector layer opposite from the first dielectric layer.

### Claim 3 (depends on 2)

The pigment flake of claim 2, further comprising a second titanium-containing absorber layer on the second dielectric layer opposite from the first titanium-containing absorber layer.

### Claim 4 (depends on 1)

The pigment flake of claim 1, wherein the absorber layer substantially surrounds the dielectric layer and the reflector layer, and the dielectric layer substantially surrounds the reflector layer.

### Claim 5 (depends on 2)

The pigment flake of claim 2, wherein the absorber layer substantially surrounds the first and second dielectric layers and the reflector layer.

### Claim 6 (depends on 1)

The pigment flake of claim 1, wherein the reflector layer comprises a reflective material selected from the group consisting of aluminum, silver, copper, gold, platinum, tin, titanium, palladium, nickel, cobalt, rhodium, niobium, chromium, and combinations or alloys thereof.

### Claim 7 (depends on 1)

The pigment flake of claim 1, wherein the reflector layer has a physical thickness of about 200 Å to about 1000 Å.

### Claim 8 (depends on 1)

The pigment flake of claim 1, wherein the reflector layer comprises a core flake section including a reflector sublayer having a top surface, a bottom surface, and at least one side surface, and a support sublayer preformed on at least one of the top and bottom surfaces but not on the at least one side surface of the reflector sublayer.

### Claim 9 (depends on 8)

The pigment flake of claim 8, wherein the reflector sublayer is composed of aluminum and the support sublayer is composed of a silicon oxide.

### Claim 10 (depends on 8)

The pigment flake of claim 8, wherein the core flake section has the coating structure SiOx/Al/SiOx, where x is from 1 to 2.

### Claim 11 (depends on 1)

The pigment flake of claim 1, wherein the reflector layer comprises a composite reflective flake including a central support sublayer having a top surface, a bottom surface, and at least one side surface, and a reflector sublayer preformed on each of the top and bottom surfaces but not on the at least one side surface of the reflector sublayer.

### Claim 12 (depends on 2)

The pigment flake of claim 2, wherein the first and second dielectric layers comprise a dielectric material having an index of refraction of about 1.65 or less.

### Claim 13 (depends on 12)

The pigment flake of claim 12, wherein the dielectric material is selected from the group consisting of silicon dioxide, aluminum oxide, magnesium fluoride, aluminum fluoride, cerium fluoride, lanthanum fluoride, neodymium fluoride, samarium fluoride, barium fluoride, calcium fluoride, lithium fluoride, and combinations thereof.

### Claim 14 (depends on 2)

The pigment flake of claim 2, wherein the first and second dielectric layers comprise a dielectric material having an index of refraction of greater than about 1.65.

### Claim 15 (depends on 14)

The pigment flake of claim 14, wherein the dielectric material is selected from the group consisting of zinc sulfide, zinc oxide, zirconium oxide, titanium dioxide, carbon, indium oxide, indium-tin-oxide, tantalum pentoxide, cerium oxide, yttrium oxide, europium oxide, iron oxides, hafnium nitride, hafnium carbide, hafnium oxide, lanthanum oxide, magnesium oxide, neodymium oxide, praseodymium oxide, samarium oxide, antimony trioxide, silicon carbide, silicon nitride, silicon monoxide, selenium trioxide, tin oxide, tungsten trioxide, and combinations thereof.

### Claim 16 (depends on 2)

The pigment flake of claim 2, wherein the first and second dielectric layers have an optical thickness in a range from about 2 QWOT at a design wavelength of about 400 nm to about 9 QWOT at a design wavelength of about 700 nm.

### Claim 17 (depends on 2)

The pigment flake of claim 2, wherein the first and second dielectric layers have the same optical thickness.

### Claim 18 (depends on 2)

The pigment flake of claim 2, wherein the first and second dielectric layers are composed of the same material.

### Claim 19 (depends on 2)

The pigment flake of claim 2, wherein the first and second dielectric layers are each composed of a dielectric optical stack having a plurality of alternating layers of a high index material and a low index material.

### Claim 20 (depends on 19)

The pigment flake of claim 19, wherein the dielectric optical stack has a gradient index of refraction.

### Claim 21 (depends on 2)

The pigment flake of claim 2, wherein the first and second dielectric layers are each composed of a mixture or multiple sublayers of dielectric materials selected from the group consisting of low index materials, high index materials, and combinations thereof.

### Claim 22 (depends on 3)

The pigment flake of claim 3, wherein the first and second titanium-containing absorber layers comprise a material selected from the group consisting of elemental titanium, titanium-based compounds, titanium-based alloys, and combinations thereof.

### Claim 23 (depends on 3)

The pigment flake of claim 3, wherein the first and second titanium-containing absorber layers comprise an absorbing material selected from the group consisting of titanium, titanium nitride, titanium oxynitride, titanium carbide, titanium oxynitride carbide, titanium silicide, titanium diboride, titanium mixed with carbon, titanium mixed with tungsten, titanium mixed with silicon, titanium mixed with niobium, and combinations thereof.

### Claim 24 (depends on 3)

The pigment flake of claim 3, wherein the first and second titanium-containing absorber layers each have a physical thickness of about 30 Å to about 300 Å.

### Claim 25 (depends on 3)

The pigment flake of claim 3, wherein the first and second titanium-containing absorber layers have the same physical thickness.

### Claim 26 (depends on 3)

The pigment flake of claim 3, wherein, the first and second titanium-containing absorber layers are composed of the same material.

### Claim 27 (depends on 1)

The pigment flake of claim 1, wherein the titanium-containing absorber layer has a discrete boundary interface with the underlying dielectric layer.

### Claim 28 (depends on 1)

The pigment flake of claim 1, wherein the titanium-containing absorber layer comprises an amorphous absorbing material.

### Claim 29 (depends on 1)

A color shifting pigment composition comprising a plurality of color shifting pigment flakes, each of the pigment flakes having a multilayer structure substantially the same as the pigment flake defined in claim 1.

### Claim 30 (depends on 1)

A color shifting colorant composition, comprising:
a pigment medium; and
a plurality of color shifting pigment flakes dispersed in the pigment medium, each of the pigment flakes having a multilayer structure substantially the same as the pigment flake defined in claim 1.

### Claim 31 (depends on 30)

The colorant composition of claim 30, wherein the pigment medium comprises a material selected from the group consisting of acrylic melamine, urethanes, polyesters, vinyl resins, acrylates, methyl methacrylate, ABS resins, epoxies, styrenes, ink and paint formulations based on alkyd resins, and mixtures thereof.

### Claim 32 (depends on 30)

The colorant composition of claim 30, wherein each of the pigment flakes has a dimension on any surface thereof ranging from about 2 microns to about 200 microns.

### Claim 33

A color shifting pigment flake, comprising:
a first titanium-containing absorber layer;
a first dielectric layer on the first absorber layer;
a reflector layer on the first dielectric layer;
a second dielectric layer on the reflector layer; and
a second titanium-containing absorber layer on the second dielectric layer;
wherein the pigment flake exhibits a discrete color shift such that the pigment flake has a first color at a first angle of incident light or viewing and a second color different from the first color at a second angle of incident light or viewing.

### Claim 34 (depends on 33)

The pigment flake of claim 33, wherein the first and second titanium-containing absorber layers comprise a material selected from the group consisting of elemental titanium, titanium-based compounds, titanium-based alloys, and combinations thereof.

### Claim 35 (depends on 33)

The pigment flake of claim 33, wherein the first and second titanium-containing absorber layers comprise an absorbing material selected from the group consisting of titanium, titanium nitride, titanium oxynitride, titanium carbide, titanium oxynitride carbide, titanium silicide, titanium diboride, titanium mixed with carbon, titanium mixed with tungsten, titanium mixed with silicon, titanium mixed with niobium, and combinations thereof.

### Claim 36 (depends on 33)

The pigment flake of claim 33, further comprising a third dielectric layer on the second absorber layer, and a fourth dielectric layer on the first absorber layer.

### Claim 37 (depends on 36)

The pigment flake of claim 36, wherein the third and fourth dielectric layers form a continuous coating layer around the pigment flake.

### Claim 38 (depends on 36)

The pigment flake of claim 36, further comprising a third titanium-containing absorber layer on the third dielectric layer, and a fourth titanium-containing absorber layer on the fourth dielectric layer.

### Claim 39 (depends on 38)

The pigment flake of claim 38, wherein the third and fourth titanium-containing absorber layers form a continuous coating layer around the pigment flake.

### Claim 40

A color shifting pigment flake, comprising:
a core reflector layer;
a dielectric layer substantially surrounding the core reflector layer; and
a titanium-containing absorber layer substantially surrounding the dielectric layer, the absorber layer comprising an absorbing material substantially free of titanium dioxide;
wherein the pigment flake exhibits a discrete color shift such that the pigment flake has a first color at a first angle of incident light or viewing and a second color different from the first color at a second angle of incident light or viewing.

### Claim 41 (depends on 40)

The pigment flake of claim 40, wherein the titanium-containing absorber layer comprises a material selected from the group consisting of elemental titanium, titanium-based compounds, titanium-based alloys, and combinations thereof.

### Claim 42 (depends on 40)

The pigment flake of claim 40, wherein the titanium-containing absorber layer comprises an absorbing material selected from the group consisting of titanium, titanium nitride, titanium oxynitride, titanium carbide, titanium oxynitride carbide, titanium silicide, titanium boride, titanium mixed with carbon, titanium mixed with tungsten, titanium mixed with silicon, titanium mixed with niobium, and combinations thereof.

### Claim 43 (depends on 40)

The pigment flake of claim 40, further comprising at least one additional dielectric layer and at least one additional titanium-containing absorber layer which substantially surround the other layers of the pigment flake.

### Claim 44

A color shifting pigment flake, comprising:
a core reflector layer having a top surface, a bottom surface, and at least one side surface;
a dielectric layer on the top surface and the bottom surface but not on at least one side surface of the reflector layer; and
a titanium-containing absorber layer substantially surrounding the dielectric layer and in contact with at least one side surface of the reflector layer;
wherein the pigment flake exhibits a discrete color shift such that the pigment flake has a first color at a first angle of incident light or viewing and a second color different from the first color at a second angle of incident light or viewing.

### Claim 45 (depends on 44)

The pigment flake of claim 44, wherein the titanium-containing absorber layer comprises a material selected from the group consisting of elemental titanium, titanium-based compounds, titanium-based alloys, and combinations thereof.

### Claim 46 (depends on 44)

The pigment flake of claim 44, wherein the titanium-containing absorber layer comprises an absorbing material selected from the group consisting of titanium, titanium nitride, titanium oxynitride, titanium carbide, titanium oxynitride carbide, titanium silicide, titanium boride, titanium mixed with carbon, titanium mixed with tungsten, titanium mixed with silicon, titanium mixed with niobium, and combinations thereof.

### Claim 47

A color shifting pigment flake, comprising:
a core layer;
a reflector coating substantially surrounding the core layer;
a dielectric layer substantially surrounding the reflector coating; and
a titanium-containing absorber layer substantially surrounding the dielectric layer;
wherein the pigment flake exhibits a discrete color shift such that the pigment flake has a first color at a first angle of incident light or viewing and a second color different from the first color at a second angle of incident light or viewing.

### Claim 48 (depends on 47)

The pigment flake of claim 47, wherein the core layer comprises a material selected from the group consisting of mica, glass, talc, iron oxide, and boron nitride.

### Claim 49 (depends on 47)

The pigment flake of claim 47, wherein the titanium-containing absorber layer comprises a material selected from the group consisting of elemental titanium, titanium-based compounds, titanium-based alloys, and combinations thereof.

### Claim 50 (depends on 47)

The pigment flake of claim 47, wherein the titanium-containing absorber layer comprises an absorbing material selected from the group consisting of titanium, titanium nitride, titanium oxynitride, titanium carbide, titanium oxynitride carbide, titanium silicide, titanium boride, titanium mixed with carbon, titanium mixed with tungsten, titanium mixed with silicon, titanium mixed with niobium, and combinations thereof.

### Claim 51

A color shifting pigment flake, comprising:
a core layer;
a first titanium-containing absorber layer substantially surrounding the core layer;
a dielectric layer substantially surrounding the first titanium-containing absorber layer; and
a second titanium-containing absorber layer substantially surrounding the dielectric layer;
wherein the pigment flake exhibits a discrete color shift such that the pigment flake has a first color at a first angle of incident light or viewing and a second color different from the first color at a second angle of incident light or viewing.

### Claim 52 (depends on 51)

The pigment flake of claim 51, wherein the core layer is composed of mica or glass.

### Claim 53 (depends on 51)

The pigment flake of claim 51, wherein the dielectric layer is composed of silicon dioxide or titanium dioxide.

### Claim 54 (depends on 53)

The pigment flake of claim 53, wherein the dielectric layer is formed by a sol-gel process.

### Claim 55 (depends on 51)

The pigment flake of claim 51, wherein the first and second titanium-containing absorber layers comprise a material selected from the group consisting of elemental titanium, titanium-based compounds, titanium-based alloys, and combinations thereof.

### Claim 56 (depends on 51)

The pigment flake of claim 51, wherein the first and second titanium-containing absorber layers comprise an absorbing material selected from the group consisting of titanium, titanium nitride, titanium oxynitride, titanium carbide, titanium oxynitride carbide, titanium silicide, titanium boride, titanium mixed with carbon, titanium mixed with tungsten, titanium mixed with silicon, titanium mixed with niobium, and combinations thereof.

### Claim 57

A color shifting pigment flake, comprising:
a first titanium-containing absorber layer;
a dielectric layer on the first absorber layer; and
a second titanium-containing absorber layer on the dielectric layer;
wherein the pigment flake exhibits a discrete color shift such that the pigment flake has a first color at a first angle of incident light or viewing and a second color different from the first color at a second angle of incident light or viewing.

### Claim 58 (depends on 57)

The pigment flake of claim 57, wherein the first and second titanium-containing absorber layers comprise a material selected from the group consisting of elemental titanium, titanium-based compounds, titanium-based alloys, and combinations thereof.

### Claim 59 (depends on 57)

The pigment flake of claim 57, wherein the first and second titanium-containing absorber layers comprise an absorbing material selected from the group consisting of titanium, titanium nitride, titanium oxynitride, titanium carbide, titanium oxynitride carbide, titanium silicide, titanium boride, titanium mixed with carbon, titanium mixed with tungsten, titanium mixed with silicon, titanium mixed with niobium, and combinations thereof.

### Claim 60 (depends on 57)

The pigment flake of claim 57, wherein the first and second titanium-containing absorber layers form a continuous coating layer around the dielectric layer.

### Claim 61

A color shifting foil, comprising:
a reflector layer;
a dielectric layer on the reflector layer; and
a titanium-containing absorber layer on the dielectric layer;
wherein the foil exhibits a discrete color shift such that the foil has a first color at a first angle of incident light or viewing and a second color different from the first color at a second angle of incident light or viewing.

### Claim 62 (depends on 61)

The foil of claim 61, further comprising a web carrier with either the reflector layer or the titanium-containing absorber layer deposited on the web carrier.

### Claim 63 (depends on 62)

The foil of claim 62, wherein the web carrier further comprises a release layer thereon disposed between the web carrier and the reflector layer, or the web carrier and the absorber layer.

### Claim 64 (depends on 63)

The foil of claim 63, further comprising an adhesive layer for laminating the foil to a substrate.

### Claim 65 (depends on 64)

The foil of claim 64, wherein the adhesive layer is selected from the group consisting of a hot stampable adhesive, a pressure sensitive adhesive, a permanent adhesive, a transparent adhesive, and a UV curable adhesive.

### Claim 66 (depends on 64)

The foil of claim 64, wherein the adhesive layer is on the reflector layer or the absorber layer.

### Claim 67 (depends on 61)

The foil of claim 61, wherein the reflector layer comprises a reflective material selected from the group consisting of aluminum, silver, copper, gold, platinum, tin, titanium, palladium, nickel, cobalt, rhodium, niobium, chromium, and combinations or alloys thereof.

### Claim 68 (depends on 61)

The foil of claim 61, wherein the dielectric layer comprises a dielectric material having an index of refraction of about 1.65 or less.

### Claim 69 (depends on 68)

The foil of claim 68, wherein the dielectric material is selected from the group consisting of silicon dioxide, aluminum oxide, magnesium fluoride, aluminum fluoride, cerium fluoride, lanthanum fluoride, neodymium fluoride, samarium fluoride, barium fluoride, calcium fluoride, lithium fluoride, and combinations thereof.

### Claim 70 (depends on 61)

The foil of claim 61, wherein the dielectric layer comprises a dielectric material having an index of refraction of greater than about 1.65.

### Claim 71 (depends on 70)

The foil of claim 70, wherein the dielectric material is selected from the group consisting of zinc sulfide, zinc oxide, zirconium oxide, titanium dioxide, carbon, indium oxide, indium-tin-oxide, tantalum pentoxide, cerium oxide, yttrium oxide, europium oxide, iron oxides, hafnium nitride, hafnium carbide, hafnium oxide, lanthanum oxide, magnesium oxide, neodymium oxide, praseodymium oxide, samarium oxide, antimony trioxide, silicon carbide, silicon nitride, silicon monoxide, selenium trioxide, tin oxide, tungsten trioxide, and combinations thereof.

### Claim 72 (depends on 61)

The foil of claim 61, wherein the dielectric layer is composed of a dielectric optical stack having a plurality of alternating layers of a high index material and a low index material.

### Claim 73 (depends on 72)

The foil of claim 72, wherein the dielectric optical stack has a gradient index of refraction.

### Claim 74 (depends on 61)

The foil of claim 61, wherein the titanium-containing absorber layer comprises a material selected from the group consisting of elemental titanium, titanium-based compounds, titanium-based alloys, and combinations thereof.

### Claim 75 (depends on 61)

The foil of claim 61, wherein the titanium-containing absorber layer comprises an absorbing material selected from the group consisting of titanium, titanium nitride, titanium oxynitride, titanium carbide, titanium oxynitride carbide, titanium silicide, titanium boride, titanium mixed with carbon, titanium mixed with tungsten, titanium mixed with silicon, titanium mixed with niobium, and combinations thereof.

### Claim 76

A color shifting foil device, comprising:
a carrier substrate;
a first titanium-containing absorber layer on the carrier substrate;
a dielectric layer on the first titanium-containing absorber layer; and
a second titanium-containing absorber layer on the dielectric layer;
wherein the foil exhibits a discrete color shift such that the foil has a first color at a first angle of incident light or viewing and a second color different from the first color at a second angle of incident light or viewing.

### Claim 77 (depends on 76)

The foil of claim 76, wherein the first and second titanium-containing absorber layers comprise a material selected from the group consisting of elemental titanium, titanium-based compounds, titanium-based alloys, and combinations thereof.

### Claim 78 (depends on 76)

The foil of claim 76, wherein the first and second titanium-containing absorber layers comprise an absorbing material selected from the group consisting of titanium, titanium nitride, titanium oxynitride, titanium carbide, titanium oxynitride carbide, titanium silicide, titanium boride, titanium mixed with carbon, titanium mixed with tungsten, titanium mixed with silicon, titanium mixed with niobium, and combinations thereof.

### Claim 79

A method of fabricating a color shifting pigment flake composition, comprising:
providing one or more reflector layers;
forming one or more dielectric layers on the reflector layers; and
forming one or more titanium-containing absorber layers on the dielectric layers, the absorber layers comprising an absorbing material substantially free of titanium dioxide, thereby producing a pigment flake composition exhibiting a discrete color shift such that the composition has a first color at a first angle of incident light or viewing and a second color different from the first color at a second angle of incident light or viewing.

### Claim 80 (depends on 79)

The method of claim 79, wherein the dielectric and absorber layers are formed by a process selected from the group consisting of physical vapor deposition, chemical vapor deposition, plasma enhanced chemical vapor deposition, sputtering, and electrolysis deposition.

### Claim 81 (depends on 79)

The method of claim 79, wherein the titanium-containing absorber layers comprise a material selected from the group consisting of elemental titanium, titanium-based compounds, titanium-based alloys, and combinations thereof.

### Claim 82 (depends on 79)

The method of claim 79, wherein the titanium-containing absorber layers comprise an absorbing material selected from the group consisting of titanium, titanium nitride, titanium oxynitride, titanium carbide, titanium oxynitride carbide, titanium silicide, titanium boride, titanium mixed with carbon, titanium mixed with tungsten, titanium mixed with silicon, titanium mixed with niobium, and combinations thereof.
