# US 2001/0022039 A1 · Metatarsal protectors for footwear

> Agents: this data is available as JSON from the patentgrep API and MCP server — see https://patentgrep.com/llms.txt

- Number: US 2001/0022039 A1
- Document ID: US20010022039A1
- Status: Published application
- Kind: A1
- Application number: 09/785,253
- Filed: 2001-02-20
- Published: 2001-09-20
- Earliest claimed: 2000-03-02
- Inventors: Dezi A. Krajcir
- Web page: https://patentgrep.com/patent/US20010022039A1

## CPC

- A43B 7/32: with shock-absorbing means (resilient soles A43B13/18)
- A43B: CHARACTERISTIC FEATURES OF FOOTWEAR; PARTS OF FOOTWEAR

## Abstract

A metatarsal protector for footwear consists of a body molded from resilient plastics material, thus facilitating walking and kneeling, the material being sufficiently flexible that it can be molded flat and bent to the required saddle shape when it is incorporated into the footwear close against the upper inner surface. The range of hardness required for the material is comparatively narrow, so that it is sufficiently flexible, but can still meet certification requirements, and as measured by a Durometer A test is between 35 and 50 Shore. The protector comprises a plurality of integral ridged projections protruding from one surface, forming between themselves a corresponding plurality of open-mouthed recesses, each of which is surrounded by a single projection (e.g. giving a circular recess) or by a plurality thereof intersecting one another (e.g. giving rectangular or triangular recesses). When an impact force is applied to the metatarsal region the resilient material deforms and absorbs the force. The projections may be more closely spaced at and around the usual impact point. Preferably, the body is provided on the opposite surface with second projections, each of which registers with a respective recess at the first surface, and is the same shape and size, or slightly smaller, so that on deformation the second projections to enter their respective recesses, increasing the impact absorption. It has been found unexpectedly that even with such soft material the resultant boots can meet the highest Mt75 impact classification.

## Claims

### Claim 1

A metatarsal protector for footwear to protect the foot of a wearer from an impact force applied to the metatarsal region thereof, each such footwear comprising an upper having outer and inner surfaces and a sole having outer and inner surfaces, the upper and the sole having respective registering metatarsal regions and being joined to one another with their inner surfaces facing one another;
wherein the protector comprises a protector body having first and second opposite faces, the protector body when incorporated into the footwear being interposed between the registering metatarsal regions with its first surface adjacent to the upper inner surface;
wherein the protector body has two longitudinally extending sides and two transversely extending ends, and when so incorporated is of size to conform to and cover the metatarsal region and of saddle shape, the body first surface is transversely convex and longitudinally concave toward the upper inner surface, and the body second surface is transversely concave and longitudinally convex toward the sole inner surface;
wherein the protector body is molded from flexible, resilient plastics material and at least the central portion thereof has protruding from one surface thereof a plurality of ridged first projections providing a corresponding plurality of open-mouthed first recesses, each of which first recesses is surrounded by a respective first projection or immediately adjacent first projections that are joined together;
the material from which the protector body is molded has an overall hardness as measured by a Durometer A test of from 35 to 60 Shore; and
the width and height dimensions of the first projections and the corresponding dimensions of the first recesses are such that an impact force applied to the footwear metatarsal region at an impact point results in an acceptable minimum clearance inside the footwear during and after the impact.

### Claim 2 (depends on 1)

A protector as claimed in claim 1, wherein the protector body is provided on the other surface thereof not having the first projections protruding therefrom with a plurality of second projections distributed thereover, the distribution of the second projections being such that they each register with a respective first recess.

### Claim 3 (depends on 1)

A protector as claimed in claim 1, characterized in that the width and height dimensions of the first projections and the corresponding dimensions of the first recesses, and the width and height dimensions of the second projections when provided, are such that an impact force of up to 35 foot pounds applied to the footwear metatarsal region at an impact point results in a minimum clearance inside the footwear after the impact, as measured by a permanently compressible wax body under the impact point, of at least 2.5 cm for a 9 D boot and 2.4 cm for an 8 B boot.

### Claim 4 (depends on 1)

A protector as claimed in claim 1, characterized in that the width and height dimensions of the first projections and the corresponding dimensions of the first recesses, and the width and height dimensions of the second projections when provided, are such that an impact force of up to 50 foot pounds applied to the footwear metatarsal region at an impact point results in a minimum clearance inside the footwear after the impact, as measured by a permanently compressible wax body under the impact point, of at least 2.5 cm for a 9 D boot and 2.4 cm for an 8 B boot.

### Claim 5 (depends on 1)

A protector as claimed in claim 1, characterized in that the width and height dimensions of the first projections and the corresponding dimensions of the first recesses, and the width and height dimensions of the second projections when provided, are such that an impact force of up to 75 foot pounds applied to the footwear metatarsal region at an impact point results in a minimum clearance inside the footwear after the impact, as measured by a permanently compressible wax body under the impact point, of at least 2.5 cm for a 9 D boot and 2.4 cm for an 8 B boot.

### Claim 6 (depends on 2)

A protector as claimed in claim 2, characterized in that the width and height dimensions of the first projections and the corresponding dimensions of the first recesses, and the width and height dimensions of the second projections when provided, are such that an impact force of up to 35 foot pounds applied to the footwear metatarsal region at an impact point results in a minimum clearance inside the footwear after the impact, as measured by a permanently compressible wax body under the impact point, of at least 2.5 cm for a 9 D boot and 2.4 cm for an 8 B boot.

### Claim 7 (depends on 2)

A protector as claimed in claim 2, characterized in that the width and height dimensions of the first projections and the corresponding dimensions of the first recesses, and the width and height dimensions of the second projections when provided, are such that an impact force of up to 50 foot pounds applied to the footwear metatarsal region at an impact point results in a minimum clearance inside the footwear after the impact, as measured by a permanently compressible wax body under the impact point, of at least 2.5 cm for a 9 D boot and 2.4 cm for an 8 B boot.

### Claim 8 (depends on 2)

A protector as claimed in claim 2, characterized in that the width and height dimensions of the first projections and the corresponding dimensions of the first recesses, and the width and height dimensions of the second projections when provided, are such that an impact force of up to 75 foot pounds applied to the footwear metatarsal region at an impact point results in a minimum clearance inside the footwear after the impact, as measured by a permanently compressible wax body under the impact point, of at least 2.5 cm for a 9 D boot and 2.4 cm for an 8 B boot.

### Claim 9 (depends on 2)

A protector as claimed in claim 2, wherein the shapes of the plurality of second projections are the same as those of the first recesses and the sizes of the plurality of second projections are not greater than those of the respective registering first recesses.

### Claim 10 (depends on 9)

A protector as claimed in claim 9, and comprising two separate protector bodies disposed with the first surface of one against the second surface of the other and with the second plurality of projections of one protruding into the recesses of the other.

### Claim 11 (depends on 1)

A protector as claimed in claim 1, wherein the protector body comprises a tongue member extending from the transverse end thereof that when the protector is incorporated into footwear is adjacent to a toe box protector, so that when so incorporated it can extend over a surface of the toe box protector and be attached thereto.

### Claim 12 (depends on 2)

A protector as claimed in claim 2, wherein the protector body comprises a tongue member extending from the transverse end thereof that when the protector is incorporated into footwear is adjacent to a toe box protector, so that when so incorporated it can extend over a surface of the toe box protector and be attached thereto.

### Claim 13 (depends on 1)

A protector as claimed in claim 1, wherein the ridge portions of the plurality of first projections are rounded to provide progressive absorption of an impact force by the material of the body.

### Claim 14 (depends on 2)

A protector as claimed in claim 2, wherein the ridge portions of the pluralities of both first and second projections are rounded to provide progressive absorption of the impact force by the material of the body.

### Claim 15 (depends on 1)

A protector as claimed in claim 1, wherein the spacing of immediately adjacent first projections from one another decreases toward the centre portion of the protector body to maximize the impact absorption of the protector body at its centre portion.

### Claim 16 (depends on 1)

A protector as claimed in claim 1, wherein each first projection is joined with immediately adjacent first projections to form a first set of spaced parallel ridges and a second set of spaced parallel ridges extending transversely of the first set, the two sets intersecting at right angles to form between them a corresponding plurality of first recesses of rectangular cross section.

### Claim 17 (depends on 2)

A protector as claimed in claim 2, wherein each first projection is joined with immediately adjacent first projections to form a first set of spaced parallel ridges and a second set of spaced parallel ridges extending transversely of the first set, the two sets intersecting at right angles to form between them a corresponding plurality of first recesses of rectangular cross section; and
wherein each second projection is also of rectangular cross section and registers with a respective first recess, its dimensions being such that it could fit within the respective first recess.

### Claim 18 (depends on 1)

A protector as claimed in claim 1, wherein each first projection is joined with immediately adjacent projections to form a first set and a second set of spaced ridges, the two sets intersecting at acute angles and complementary obtuse angles to form between them a corresponding plurality of first recesses of triangular cross section.

### Claim 19 (depends on 2)

A protector as claimed in claim 2, wherein each first projection is joined with immediately adjacent projections to form a first set and a second set of spaced ridges, the two sets intersecting at acute angles and complementary obtuse angles to form between them a corresponding plurality of first recesses of triangular cross section; and
wherein each second projection is also of triangular cross section and registers with a respective first recess, the dimensions of each second projection being such that it could fit within the respective first recess.

### Claim 20 (depends on 1)

A protector as claimed in claim 1, wherein each first projection is of annular cross section, each surrounds a respective first recess of circular cross section, and each borders a fluted cross section recess between itself and the immediately adjacent annular first projections.

### Claim 21 (depends on 2)

A protector as claimed in claim 2, wherein each first projection is of annular cross section, each surrounds a respective first recess of circular cross section, and each borders a fluted cross section recess between itself and the immediately adjacent annular first projections; and
wherein each second projection is of circular cross section and registers with a respective first recess, and there are provided with the second projections further projections of fluted cross section, each registering with a respective recess of fluted cross section, the dimensions of the second projections being such that they could fit within the first recesses.

### Claim 22 (depends on 1)

A protector as claimed in claim 1, wherein the protector body comprises for interposition between itself and the footwear upper a layer of a more penetration resistant plastics material to increase the overall penetration resistance of the footwear in which it is incorporated.

### Claim 23 (depends on 2)

A protector as claimed in claim 2, wherein the protector body comprises for interposition between itself and the footwear upper a layer of a more penetration resistant plastics material to increase the overall penetration resistance of the footwear in which it is incorporated.
