A roofing shingle including an upper edge, a lower edge, a first end, a second end, a headlap section, and an exposed section below the headlap section, wherein a nail zone extends across the roofing shingle from the first end to the second end within the headlap section, the roofing shingle comprising:
- a top shingle layer including a top surface and a bottom surface;
- a reinforcement strip secured to the bottom surface of the top shingle layer and overlapping with the nail zone;
- and
- a thermoplastic elastomer (TPE) self-sealing material disposed within the nail zone and configured to form a seal around a mechanical fastener that punctures the roofing shingle in order to secure the roofing shingle to an underlying roof structure.